Originally posted by: 1EZduzit
I think the point I was trying to make is that we had no acts of terror from the Japanese on our mainland during WW2. Except of course for the hot air incendary bombs they sent over in the jet stream.
How much would we have lost if we lost the war?? EVERYTHING!! Now the Japanese are one of our best allies. Go figure. The interened japs lost a lot of freedom and time, but I think our goverment did the right thing for the majority of it's citizens. Perhaps it's unfortunate that a group of high risk people can be so easily identified, but it would have been remiss of us not to take advatage of it.
To try to compare slavery to being detained is, at best, a gross exaggeration. I also don't see how it relates to segregation (which was a regional problem) or the civil war which freed the slaves?
My main point is that the Muslims in this country will just have to suck it up for a bit and put up with being detained. It's not like our young men and women fighting this war don't have to suck it up a bit. Their ass is on the line, not yours. Try thinking of the best way to get them home ASAP and quit worrying about a few detainees. We need to get this war OVER!!!!! I'm for anything short of nukes that will speed the end of this insane war on terrorism. We don't live in a perfect world and we didn't start the fire.
You still didn't answer my request for figures. You're attributing the lack of mainland sabotage/terrorist actions to the internments when in fact you've established no such link. Give me figures on the numbers of spies detained and imprisoned and we'll talk.
The interned Japanese families didn't just lose time and freedom, as you call it. Many families lost everything they had, ancestral possessions, businesses, homes, and land. That is not a minor inconvenience and it is an action that our government should be loathe to commit.
Our troops will not be coming home for some time. By going into Iraq we've opened up a hornet's nest and only bolstered Al Queda's cause. We've seen an insurgency take root that the warplanners in the Bush administration apparently didn't see fit to plan for.
On that note, has it ever occurred to you to wonder why we attacked Iraq when our friend Mr. Bin Laden is in Pakistan?
Has it ever occurred to you that terrorism (a less incendiary, related term is asymmetric warfare) is a tactic? A tactic, an idea, a strategic move cannot be eradicated any more than an ideology can. It's a tactic used when one side in a conflict doesn't possess the military might or ability to take on an adversary head-on. It's common throughout history, in all conflicts. To think any differently is ignorance.
I never meant to compare internment to slavery, merely giving examples of when a certain standard of government misconduct was at the time considered moral, rational, and/or necessary.