Rumpltzer
Diamond Member
- Jun 7, 2003
- 4,815
- 33
- 91
OMG, too elaborate a ruse from people who dress up as vagrants, wander around the jungle barefoot with torches, and a pose a village with straw huts??Originally posted by: ThePresence
They heard an irregular helicopter rotor, saw a splash out at in the ocean and the helicopter noise suddenly stopped. Too coincidental and too elaborate a ruse.Originally posted by: Rumpltzer
Did they see the helicopter?? Someone asked that same question during this week's episode, but I think the question wasn't answered.Originally posted by: Ilmater
That would mean that the Others have a helicopter (they saw it crash), and Ben couldn't be the only one that knows about it. Juliette clearly doesn't know about the helicopter - she wants to leave, that's not a ruse, and she saw the sub going down as her only way off the island to be gone now - and she was in the inner circle of Others. No way she - of all of them - didn't know about it. There would have to be a heli-pad, so they couldn't easily hide it.Originally posted by: purbeast0
I dunno ... if she was an other, she knows that the island would heal her quickly. Also she could have done it not expecting any injuries to occur.
Oh, one more thing I just thought of that completely kills that theory: if they did have a helicopter, then THAT was likely their only other way off the island. Do you think they'd risk that just to mess with the minds of the Tailies? That just doesn't make sense.
Plus, the vision came to Desmond, and without him having the vision - something that the Others couldn't have counted on - they never would have seen her crash.
Let's put this one to rest. She's not a plant, she's who she says she is.
As I recall it, they heard the helicopter but they didn't see it.
I just thought the blatant question (was it Jack who asked it?), "Did you see the helicopter?" was a little odd.