Based on my 28+ years of watching pro & college football, Peyton Manning is without question a fantastic quarterback & IMO a first-round hall-of-famer, however anyone who thinks he's better then Dan Marino because the Colts beat "da Bears" in the SB tonight is an extremely poor judge of talent and/or never saw Marino play live in his prime.
In addition, although I don't like to compare teams from different time periods (especially pre-salery-cap which isn't really fair) either of the teams that the Marino era Dolphins lost to in the Superbowl (1984 Montana/Rice 49er's & 1982 Theismann/Riggens 'Skins) would have made a mockery out of either of tonights competetitors & I also believe the Miami teams from those years would have won easily.
The reasons the Colts won tonight were mainly because (1) Indy's offensive line enabled them to run almost at will, which in turn allowed Peyton to pick apart Chicago's secondary. (2) Chicago's running game had about the least effective 112+ yards I think I've ever seen in a football game & (3) Last but by no means least, Grossman is the worst QB I've EVER seen in a high-level playoff game, even allowing for the fact that he's inexperienced... give back the points his pathetic turnovers lead to directly & you have 2-point game which could have gone either way.
Regardless, I did end up feeling a bit sorry for Chicago tonight as I watched their defense get worn gradually down because Grossman couldn't maintain long enough drives to let them catch their breath (never mind score points like an offense is supposed to) ... for the sake of all you loyal Bear fans I hope they have the sense to send him packing in the off season... if I were a Bear fan i'd sure love to see how Jeff Garcia would look dressed in brown.
Edit: Btw IMO the best QB I've personally seen play was Joe Montana ... it wasn't just his receivers, he could have done the same with anyone even half decent... he just had a certain almost magical touch with his passes that used to leave me beating my head against the wall in frustration as a Giants fan.... like Michael jordan he just brought out somthing special in the players around him that I've never seen anyone else capable of.