No it's not that good but definitely worth watching.
It's excellent IMO. Not perfect, but excellent nonetheless.
That pretty much sums it up for me too. It's no Breaking Bad, but it has the spark of greatness. Lots of excellent moments. The finale was surprisingly good with the final fight & all that. I think one of the main issues is the writing & editing, there were some parts that were kind of empty or forced, but others that were
beyond good.
Probably my biggest complaint is that the show kind of lacks soul. The story is excellent, but it doesn't really suck you in the way really good shows like BB or the first couple seasons of Lost did. They don't really push you into caring about any of the characters...like with Urich, they put in the token "I want to write real stories" and "my wife is sick" but you never really care about him, even when he dies...only a little bit once he's decided to blog about it. So it's kind of lacking in the care-about-the-characters department, which is a really big deal for getting people to love the show. But Fisk's character was really good, I liked the surprise of his girlfriend being kinda evil, Murdock has his moments, etc.
There were a lot of kind of "what the heck, really?" moments though. Like when the old blind mentor guy actually killed the weapon kid from the Japanese. You were all like, no he didn't, he's just telling Matt a line, but then yup...he really did. That didn't really work for me. But then when Karen offed Wesley, that was so well done, your heart sinks along with Karens as a "what did she just do!!!" type of reaction. A lot of the story felt too loose - Chinese, Japanese, Russians, crazy kingpin Fisk, etc. - I think it would have been better to have saved some of those for season two, or just brush on them but not really have them play a part so that they're introduced but not a focus. Like the weapon kid that the old guy took out, did he have mystical powers? Because the show's not really about that, you know? I dunno. I enjoyed it a lot though, will definitely be watching the next season! :thumbsup: