However, at the last minute he told her he was not withdrawing and told her 'because you are my wife and I'll do it if I want'.
da fuq does that have to do with Sharia law holding up in a UK court.
UK, you suck.
DM said:In his landmark decision Lord Judge ruled that because the man, the woman's husband under Sharia law, did not stick to his part of the pre-sex deal he could, in the eyes of the law, be held guilty of rape.
Breaking an agreement regarding sex is not rape. If by "last minute" it means he pinned her down and kept going for another thirty seconds, sure, rape.
Superman arrested for masturbating in mid-air. His sperm flies thru an open office window and gets seven women pregnant simultaneously.
I believe some states have a no rape can occur between a married couple law in the books.
So if a woman tells a man that she's on the pill or some form of birth control, but she's not and she gets pregnant, that's also rape?
No. Then the man needs to "Man Up" and take responsibility for having sex.
Sex takes two parties to tango, so if a man has to 'man up' for having sex. A woman can't claim rape if she gets pregnant either. She's responsible for having sex too.
And this story is an excellent example of why no man should support marital rape laws. They are part of the feminist goal of making it so that any act of intercourse can be called rape if the woman decides it.
This judge is full of crap. You shouldn't have sex if you don't want a baby, sex is a passionate engagement where logical thinking is temporarily put aside. Things like pulling out seem to get lost in the moment.
If you choose to have sex anyway you should use contraceptives to minimize the risk of pregnancy. This is just a case of a woman who is trying to blame her man for something I feel she had an equal part in. If you consent to sex without contraceptive there is a good chance you can get pregnant. If he started beating her during the sex or doing something other than sex there very well could be charges laid but not for rape. If this is the new standard for agreements perhaps I should go down to the bank and tell them that I changed my mind about that mortgage and I'm just going to stop paying it because I don't feel like it any more.
We need to put judges like this out to pasture and find some good men and women who can put an end to these 'blame game' type cases. It's not his fault you got pregnant, it is a product of your combined efforts.
Just to be clear: you believe that men should be legally allowed to forcibly rape their spouses?
There's nothing right about this story, and anyone who says otherwise can go fuck themselves. What are the consequences for the woman if she gets pregnant against the wishes of the man? Yea, I didn't think so... The government has no place in the bedroom. It's an issue between two adults, and they need to work it out themselves.
I completely agree, the government has no place in the bedroom. No witnesses, no supporting evidence, two adults who are pissed at each other, how the hell does any justice feel like they can make a fair ruling?
See the bolded above.
The reason for marital rape laws is to give women power over men.
So as long as he doesn't beat her it's all good? Marriage is implicit consent to sex whenever and wherever?
So as long as he doesn't beat her it's all good?
Marriage is implicit consent to sex whenever and wherever?
Sharia Law is not taken seriously in the UK... it's just the religious marriage part. So they are legally married under Sharia Law. Nothing else from Sharia Law is legal in the UK.
I feel that most of you have either not read the article, specifically this bit
"The woman had consented to sex, but only on condition that her husband withdrew as she did not want to become pregnant. However, at the last minute he told her he was not withdrawing and told her 'because you are my wife and I'll do it if I want'."
Or you are just completely stupid.
I have to agree with the Judge. They made an agreement and he WILLFULLY broke it. This was not an accident, which can happen.
This judge is full of crap. You shouldn't have sex if you don't want a baby, sex is a passionate engagement where logical thinking is temporarily put aside. Things like pulling out seem to get lost in the moment.
If you choose to have sex anyway you should use contraceptives to minimize the risk of pregnancy. This is just a case of a woman who is trying to blame her man for something I feel she had an equal part in. If you consent to sex without contraceptive there is a good chance you can get pregnant. If he started beating her during the sex or doing something other than sex there very well could be charges laid but not for rape. If this is the new standard for agreements perhaps I should go down to the bank and tell them that I changed my mind about that mortgage and I'm just going to stop paying it because I don't feel like it any more.
We need to put judges like this out to pasture and find some good men and women who can put an end to these 'blame game' type cases. It's not his fault you got pregnant, it is a product of your combined efforts.
What if he said something horrible to her during sex - 'your father and I had sex', 'I voted for Romney' - that makes her want him to stop - that does turn into rape.
The pull out method is an effective method of contraception now? Interesting.
And this story is an excellent example of why no man should support marital rape laws. They are part of the feminist goal of making it so that any act of intercourse can be called rape if the woman decides it.
So much for keeping the government out of the bedroom huh?
No. Then the man needs to "Man Up" and take responsibility for having sex.
Do yourself a favor and Google "no go zones in UK" and then tell us again about how the UK does not take Sharia law seriously.
Studies show that there is no sperm in pre-ejaculate. So if you do it correctly, pulling out can absolutely be an effective method.