My Lenovo t450s experience (review)

Hulk

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,377
2,256
136
I’ve been searching for a new laptop for about four years now and I found one that ticked all the right boxes; The Lenovo ThinkPad t450s. Here are some of my important considerations:
- 14” IPS Matte screen
- Broadwell CPU – With Broadwell right around the corner I wanted to wait for the more power efficient 14nm process.
- 2.5” hard drive - I want the ability to swap out and upgrade to various SSD’s as performance increases and more importantly prices come down. I’m willing to accept the thicker design this format necessitates.
- A really nice keyboard – Good key travel and key placement
- Good build quality – For me this pretty much amounts to picking up the laptop (with the screen open) from one corner and have no flex in the unit.
- Less than 4lbs ready to go

Some Background
I’ve had exactly three laptops to date. A circa 2002 Compaq EVO 600c with a 1.2 MHz Pentium II Tulatin (130nm) processor, 256MB memory (stock), 30GB hard drive, and 1400x1050 TN 4/3 aspect ratio display. I paid $1900 for this laptop. It served me well and I actually still have it although I have to admit I haven’t used it in a few years but it is still good for web browsing.
After the 130nm Tulatin Intel released 130nm Northwood P4 and the 90nm Prescott but the performance per watt was terrible so these parts never tempted. In 2006 Intel released the 65nm Conroe Core 2 Duo processors which were not only the new performance champions but they were also amazingly efficient in terms of performance per watt so I decided to buy a Merom based Dell 620m laptop.
The 620m has a T7200 Penryn 2.00GHz processor with 4MB L2 cache and a 667Mhz FSB. The display is a 16x9 14.1” WXGA+ UltraSharp TFT Display with what Dell calls TrueLife. It’s a TN display with a glossy surface. It’s only saving grace is that it has a relatively high (for the day) 1600x900 resolution. I have never liked this display but merely tolerated it. A couple of years ago I swapped out the 120GB drive for an Intel 320 120GB which gave the system a new lease on life and is probably the reason I waited so long to upgrade. I’m torn on the issue of the display aspect ratio. Outside of watching movies I think for me the 4/3 aspect ratio of the old Compaq Evo 600c is better for the work that I do on the laptop. But 16x9 makes for a better balanced laptop when it’s sitting on your lap (lower center of gravity) or other unstable surface. It’s also a little easier to carry around as it’s more like a book and not a square. 16x10 is actually my ideal display aspect ratio. The measured weight of this laptop with the battery is 5 lbs 7.5 ounces.
After the 65nm Merom Intel released the 45nm Penryn core, and then came Nahalem (also 45nm) but these were only quad core desktop processors. Westmere at 32nm came after Nahalem and basically was a die shrink of Nahelem with dual core parts. Sandy Bridge was next at 32nm and as we all know it was another huge performance boost from what came before it. This is about when my new laptop search started. Ivy Bridge at 22nm came and went as did Haswell at 22nm. It was until Broadwell at 14nm did I start to really get serious about a new laptop. Broadwell seemed like it would be a significant upgrade in terms of performance and performance/watt from my Merom based T7200.

Setup
I ended up purchasing the t450s from the Lenovo site. I deleted the $40 m.2 cache drive as I knew I’d be installing a 128GB m.2 SSD which I did and it was pretty painless. On the first setup “pass” I cloned the 500GB mechanical drive to the SSD and used EasyBCD 2.2 to “tell” the t450s to boot from the m.2 SSD. But as I started deleting all of the Lenovo junk apps I decided to just start from scratch so I used the Microsoft “mediacreationtool.exe” to load up a fresh copy of Windows 8.1 onto a USB drive. From there it was easy to set the USB drive as the first boot device and install windows and ONLY the Lenovo drivers I needed. Windows picked up the product keycode from the BIOS no problem so I didn’t even have to enter it. If anyone tries this here are the drivers I ended up installing:
Synaptics Thinkpad Ultra Nav – Install this one first to get the trackpad working smoothly
Intel HD Graphics Driver
Intel Chipset Drivers
Intel Chipset Management Engine Interface (not sure I needed this one actually)
Intel 7265/3160 Wireless LAN Driver
Intel Pro 1000 LAN Adapter – Gigabit Ethernet Driver
Intel Collaborative Processor Performance Control (CPPC) – To enable CPU power savings
Lenovo Power Management Driver – I don’t know if you really need this one but it does get rid of an exclamation point in Device Manager for “Unknown PCI device.”
Thinkpad Monitor INF Driver
Integrated Camera Driver
Intel 7265 Bluetooth Driver
Enhanced Performance USB Keyboard Driver
Realtek Multicard Driver
Realtek Audio Driver

I was actually quite surprised at the performance of the Transcend 128GB m.2 SSD. It scored 1136 on AS-SSD and according to HD Tach an average read speed of 407MB/sec. The write speeds aren’t off the charts but for a boot drive that’s not really an issue.
The additional 8GB of memory installed without a hitch so now the total is 12GB.
I struggled just a bit deciding on the processor for the t450s. The base processor is the 5200u and for the ridiculous amount of money they want for two to four hundred MHZ more I personally couldn’t justify it. I’m thinking I’m probably a lot like many of the Anandtech over-clockers in that we have a hard time paying for simply a different multiplier And yes, I realize that the best chip they offer does have an additional 1MB cache. Now if that additional money bought four cores instead of two or 6000 series graphics with 48EU’s I might have gone for it.

Comparisons
Keyboard – All three of these laptops have very nice keyboards but the Lenovo is definitely a cut above the rest. The keys wiggle around less and the click at the end of the travel feels good to em. I’d say the Evo 600c is just a little better than the Dell.
Trackpad – I know there was a lot of commotion in the Lenovo community when Lenovo did away with the physical button below the keyboard for the trackpad with the t440s. They did bring them back with the t450s but I have to say while the trackpad is okay I don’t love it. First of all I prefer to have the trackpad inset into the laptop frame so I can feel the edges with my fingers when using it so that I know when to “reload.” I’m finding that I will move to the edge of the trackpad and the movement of the mouse will get sketchy. In addition I don’t like having the buttons at the bottom of the trackpad being built into the pad itself. I find that when I left click to grab a scroll bar that the action of left clicking will sometimes move the mouse off of the scroll bar. On the other hand the track pads and button placement (below the pads) on the 620m and the 600c as well as the action of the trackpads themselves are perfect. Over the last week I have increased the speed of the mouse pointer which has helped the trackpad action because there is less scrolling. Also the rough surface is starting to smooth out with use which makes use a little more precise. I’d still rather have a smaller trackpad with physical buttons below it.

Display – No comparison the 1080p matte IPS display on the t450s destroys the other two in terms of off angle viewing, contrast, and color rendition/saturation. The 600c is probably a little better than the 620m to my eye just because it’s a matte screen but they’re both pretty terrible in comparison to the Lenovo.

Performance - One very outdated metric I still like using is the old Ziff-Davis CPUmark99. It only measures old school integer performance and it doesn’t take multicores into account yet it still seems to provide somewhat meaningful comparative results. The 600c scores 111, the 620m 279 and the Lenovo 467. Another way to look at this is how many MHz each processor requires to “earn” one CPUmark99. This is a somewhat crude way of estimating IPC improvements for this one old bench. The Pentium III Tulatin in the 600c needs 10.8MHz for each CPUmark, the Core2Duo T7200 in the 620m requires 7.2MHz/CPUmark, and the Broadwell based 5200u in the Lenovo requires 5.4Mhz/CPUmark. It is interesting that Broadwell is nearly twice as efficient per CPUmark99 as the Tulatin PIII, the Core2Duo fits neatly in between both of them. Somehow I managed to upgrade at just about equal performance increase levels when looking at CPUmark99 IPC.
There was also a Handbrake benchmark on the forums a while back that I also ran. Unfortunately I couldn’t run it on the Evo 600c, I kept getting a “not a valid Win32 application” error and honestly didn’t want to spend the time to track it down. Suffice it to say it would have been unbelievably dog slow. The 620m ran the bench at an average frame rate of 25.7fps while the Lenovo did it at 85.5fps. Note I did not run the “nightly” Handbrake build. The Lenovo was 3.3 times faster than the Core2Duo at compressing this video. And if we look at the MHz required of each CPU to render at an average frame rate of 1fps the Core2Duo requires 77.8MHz to do 1fps while the Broadwell only requires 29.2MHz. Besides being much faster overall Broadwell is over twice as efficient IPC-wise as Core2Duo when rendering this Handbrake benchmark.
Battery Life - I didn’t run any tests because the Evo 600c battery has long since given up the ghost and the Dell battery (a replacement) isn’t very strong either. I haven’t run any battery life tests on the t450s but I’m thinking 5 or 6 hours of my normal usage. I realize I gave up some battery life to get the display and some other features I wanted and I’m fine with that trade off. The t450s has two batteries. A built in 23.5Whr and a removable 23.5Whr one just like the t440s. I have also noticed that the laptop will use the removable battery first then move to the internal. I’m thinking (hoping) that since the internal battery doesn’t see much use perhaps it will last longer. The battery is also hot swappable so if you have two of the externals you can swap them while the computer is on. There is also a larger battery available that sticks out the back a bit if you need really long battery life.

Size and Weight - The Evo 600c measures 1-5/16” inch thick x 12-3/16” wide x 9-78” deep. The thickness measurement is taken from the surface the laptop is on to the highest point. The manufacturer’s claim will be a little less because they probably don’t include the feet. It weighs 5lbs 12.5 ounces on my digital scale. The Dell 620m measures 1-5/8” thick x 13” wide x 9-5/8” deep and weighs 5lbs 7.5 ounces. The Lenovo t450s measures 15/16” thick x 13-1/16” wide x 8-7/8” deep and weighs 3lbs 7.5 ounces. As you would expect it feels significantly thinner and lighter than the other two when you are handling it.

Build Quality – As you would expect of a ThinkPad it’s solid. As I wrote earlier if you open the screen and then hold the laptop by one corner there is zero flex in the chassis. Of course since it only weighs three and a half pounds there isn’t a lot of mass for inertia and gravity to act on. The lid closes tightly with no gaps and the hinge is tight without being too tight. There is no latch for the screen it just kind of snaps into place and stays there. I like it. The 600c is pretty well built as well but not quite as solid from a subjective point of view as the Lenovo. But again, it’s 13 years old and has held up really well. While the Dell hasn’t fallen apart it isn’t nearly as solid as the other two. The hinge constantly loosens and you have to pull half of the machine apart to tighten it every 6 months or so. There are pretty big gaps between the body and screen when it’s closed and the latch to open the display doesn’t have a nice “feel” to it, it’s kind of sticky but I guess I could put some Teflon lube in it.

Features – For the price I think the Lenovo is pretty well equipped. Integrated camera, Intel Bluetooth, Intel Wireless, 3 USB 3.0 ports, a SDHC reader, and a micro HDMI port. I really can’t fault the other laptops for lack of features because either the technology wasn’t available at the time or I didn’t want to pay for it.

Price – I paid $1930 for the Compaq Evo 600c back in 2002. I also had to buy a PCMCIA Wifi card that I think was about $40 for a total of $1970 not including tax. I paid $903 for the Dell in 2006 plus $95 for an additional 2GB of memory for a total of $998. I’m not going to include the cost of the SSD upgrade because for most of the 620’s “life” I used it with the mechanical drive. The t450s was $879(purchased from the Lenovo site) plus $65 for a Transcend m.2 128GB SSD and $70 for 8GB Crucial Ballistix Sport memory for a total system cost of $1014. Looking back I think I really got ripped on that Evo 600c for what I got. Then again after 13 years the thing still works!

Conclusion
Of course it could be ridiculous to compare technology that was released at different points in time. Newer processors are going to perform better and use less power, the wifi will be faster, the storage bigger and faster, and so on. But there are some things that aren’t as bound by time. Fit and finish, build quality, keyboard layout and feel, trackpads, etc.. Despite new and better technology manufacturers find a way to mess up these staples all the time so I thought it worth comparing them to my older devices.
Outside of the so-so trackpad, which may just be me learning how to use it, the ThinkPad is pretty damn good. I don’t want to say nearly perfect because that would require a better trackpad. And “perfect” would require a quad core processor, a faster gpu, and about double the battery life in a smaller and thinner package. We’re quite a few years away from that I think. Perhaps Cannonlake will get us those 4 cores in ultrabooks.
In conclusion I think the Lenovo t450s is a pretty good deal if you need a solid relatively thin and light laptop with a really nice IPS matte screen for most business tasks, video and audio editing, and perhaps some really light gaming. Remember it only has a 5500 series integrated GPU. Thanks for reading and I hope this little write up was helpful and semi-enjoyable to read. I wanted to give a little back to the amazing Anandtech community that has provided so much knowledge to me over the years.
- Mark
 
Last edited:

bugelrex

Junior Member
Mar 24, 2015
2
0
0
Thanks so much for the review, I'm waiting for the exact same config to be shipped this week.

Did you consider removing the heavy 2.5 HDD completely and 'just' install the tiny m2 SSD? (perhaps 256GB)

I'm thinking of doing this to reduce the laptop weight (and perhaps more cooling area), not sure if it would be noticeable?

I think there is also another M2 slot under the battery if I wanted to add more space, but not sure
 

Hulk

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,377
2,256
136
Thanks so much for the review, I'm waiting for the exact same config to be shipped this week.

Did you consider removing the heavy 2.5 HDD completely and 'just' install the tiny m2 SSD? (perhaps 256GB)

I'm thinking of doing this to reduce the laptop weight (and perhaps more cooling area), not sure if it would be noticeable?

I think there is also another M2 slot under the battery if I wanted to add more space, but not sure


I like having the extra 500GB of storage so I never considered removing the mechanical drive. It's not very heavy so I don't think it has a significant impact on the weight of the laptop. Eventually when prices get even lower I'll swap it out for a 500GB or larger SSD.

For me the biggest drawback of the mechanical drive is the noise of it spinning or waiting for it to spin up if it goes to sleep while you're working.

I don't know if there is another m.2 slot under the battery but that would be pretty cool is there is. I'd check but getting the bottom cover off is kind of scary. You have to be really careful or you'll break the bottom cover. When you take yours off if you think about it let me know by responding to this thread if there actually is another m.2 slot under the battery.
 

sze5003

Lifer
Aug 18, 2012
14,184
626
126
Hmm I thought about getting one of these. I wanted a 15 inch laptop though and they charged extra for a 1920x1080 screen. The processor is the same as in the dell inspirons 15 7000 series.

I ended up ordering a y50 instead, base model. Later I'll be adding an ssd and 8gb more of ram.

How was the shipping time?
 

Hulk

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,377
2,256
136
I think it came in pretty quick. Less than a week if I remember correctly.

Also I ended up having to pull the m.2 SSD that I was using as the boot drive. I don't know if the issue I was experiencing was due to a defective SSD or an incompatibility between the t450s and the Transcend MTS400 but after about 15 minutes of use the system would lock up solid. Only a power cycle would bring it back. It "felt" like a an I/O problem to me so I cloned the SSD to the mechanical drive and pulled the SSD. The problem went away. I probably should have checked if the issue persisted with the m.2 installed but was running out of time on my Amazon return for the drive.
 

sze5003

Lifer
Aug 18, 2012
14,184
626
126
Sounded like a bad drive. Unless the t450s uses a smaller pcie drive as a cache, I've seen that cause some interference with replacement drives.

My y50 is still "released to manufacturing" status since 3/25. I ordered a base model so I'm not sure what's going on. I'll probably cancel the order if I ends up delayed.
 

Hulk

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,377
2,256
136
No other cache in the laptop. Could have been a bad drive or perhaps there is something to Lenovo's warning regarding "don't use the m.2 drive slot as a boot drive."
 

sze5003

Lifer
Aug 18, 2012
14,184
626
126
Yea but you should be able to replace the stock HD with an ssd without a problem. See if amazon will give you a replacement. Many people have dine this as far as I can tell from the lenovo forums.
 

Hulk

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,377
2,256
136
Yes, that's plan B. Plan A was to use the m.2 SSD as the boot drive and the 500GB mechanical for data for a while then swap out the 500GB for an SSD. I returned the m.2 to Amazon today for a refund. Now the question is whether to go with the 850EVO or the BX100. Despite the read issue problem with the 840EVO I'm leaning toward the 850EVO. I have some faith in the larger process 3D NAND. I think.
 

sze5003

Lifer
Aug 18, 2012
14,184
626
126
I dunno I've been reading that the 850 evo is not that much different than the normal one. I need to get a good deal on a 1tb ssd to replace the slow 1tb in the y50 if it ever comes.
 

bugelrex

Junior Member
Mar 24, 2015
2
0
0
Also I ended up having to pull the m.2 SSD that I was using as the boot drive. I don't know if the issue I was experiencing was due to a defective SSD or an incompatibility between the t450s and the Transcend MTS400 but after about 15 minutes of use the system would lock up solid. Only a power cycle would bring it back. It "felt" like a an I/O problem to me so I cloned the SSD to the mechanical drive and pulled the SSD. The problem went away. I probably should have checked if the issue persisted with the m.2 installed but was running out of time on my Amazon return for the drive.

I put a 128GB mydigitalssd m.2 in mine and totally removed the HDD (for now). Its been a day, no problems so far. I probably should have waited for thr 256GB version to come back in stock

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00EZ2E8NO/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1


I didn't bother looking for the 3rd M.2 slot, as other posters mentioned it wont be present if you didn't order the small 16GB m.2 cache. The HDD is quite light, maybe 75% weight of the 3cell battery, the weight savings is not 'that' noticeable when replaced with a m2 ssd.
 

Trombe

Senior member
Jun 30, 2007
213
2
81
I bought one recently too, had it for about 5 days now. Just some notes:

-I stripped mine down to save on cost; they actually have and use a bezel and top baseplate design without any cutouts for the camera and fingerprint reader, looks very clean. Wouldn't be surprised if they do in fact have motherboard variants without the 3rd M.2 slot below the internal battery.
-I like the physical keys of the older Thinkpads better, something about the chiclet design makes it less user friendly to me. No LED to show CapsLock status seems like an oversight.
-Inability to upgrade the soldered RAM (even as a factory option at ordering/building time) and M2.2242 instead of 2280 size slot for SSD are mind-boggling.
-Trackpad's multitouch detection is pretty crappy, but I mostly use the Trackpoint nub instead anyway. Not sure if this is an issue with most Windows laptops in general but it's what I've heard (at least relative to Macbooks).
-For the people having issues with using the M.2 slot as their Windows drive, try setting the boot mode to Legacy in BIOS, that apparently worked for the predecessor T440s. Seems to only have problems if there's also an SATA drive in the system, if the M.2 is the only drive then it should be fine without any BIOS adjustments.
-Power Manager app not available for Windows 8, I liked this on my older X200T to set the battery charging parameters and to see live battery information (voltage, current draw on battery, etc.).

I like it overall but if it weren't for that random 35% off customized order sale I likely would've gone with an XPS 13 or HP Spectre x360 instead. The battery efficiency on those are way better, though I guess the keyboard quality and lack of Trackpoint were cons in comparison. Paid $623ish plus taxes (so about $700 total) for bare bones (upgraded to 1080p panel, removed everything else that wasn't necessary like camera and cache drive), upgraded memory to 12GB and 500GB Samsung EVO 850 SATA for another $240. Probably going to the extended battery for another $80.
 

TwiceOver

Lifer
Dec 20, 2002
13,544
44
91
I recently got two of these in at work. They have both performed well so far. Even though I'm not the end user, I was pretty impressed when I was setting them up. Really a good balance of power/business class and weight/size. My users need *real* docking ability, and the 450s fits well into our business needs.
 

Hulk

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,377
2,256
136
I've been running for a few days now with only the hard drive with absolutely no issues.

The issue I noticed was the system suddenly becoming unresponsive and then total lock up. Manual shut off was the only way to get it back. Sometimes it would go to sleep and there would be no waking without power cycle. I think both issues were related.

I'm in "analysis paralysis" in looking for a 500GB drive. The 850EVO seems like the logical choice but I'm still not convinced of the TLC (even 3D) NAND at this point in time. Also I don't like how Samsung has handled the issue and their customers with the recent read issue problem.

I'm also considering the Crucial BX100. The Silicon Motion controller seems to be pretty solid and giving decent performance.
 

wangotango

Member
Sep 11, 2014
142
0
0
I’ve been searching for a new laptop for about four years now and I found one that ticked all the right boxes; The Lenovo ThinkPad t450s. Here are some of my important considerations:
-14” IPS Matte screen
-Broadwell CPU – With Broadwell right around the corner I wanted to wait for the more power efficient 14nm process.
-2.5” hard drive - I want the ability to swap out and upgrade to various SSD’s as performance increases and more importantly prices come down. I’m willing to accept the thicker design this format necessitates.
-A really nice keyboard – Good key travel and key placement
-Good build quality – For me this pretty much amounts to picking up the laptop (with the screen open) from one corner and have no flex in the unit.
-Less than 4lbs ready to go

Some Background
I’ve had exactly three laptops to date. A circa 2002 Compaq EVO 600c with a 1.2 MHz Pentium II Tulatin (130nm) processor, 256MB memory (stock), 30GB hard drive, and 1400x1050 TN 4/3 aspect ratio display. I paid $1900 for this laptop. It served me well and I actually still have it although I have to admit I haven’t used it in a few years but it is still good for web browsing.
After the 130nm Tulatin Intel released 130nm Northwood P4 and the 90nm Prescott but the performance per watt was terrible so these parts never tempted. In 2006 Intel released the 65nm Conroe Core 2 Duo processors which were not only the new performance champions but they were also amazingly efficient in terms of performance per watt so I decided to buy a Merom based Dell 620m laptop.
The 620m has a T7200 Penryn 2.00GHz processor with 4MB L2 cache and a 667Mhz FSB. The display is a 16x9 14.1” WXGA+ UltraSharp TFT Display with what Dell calls TrueLife. It’s a TN display with a glossy surface. It’s only saving grace is that it has a relatively high (for the day) 1600x900 resolution. I have never liked this display but merely tolerated it. A couple of years ago I swapped out the 120GB drive for an Intel 320 120GB which gave the system a new lease on life and is probably the reason I waited so long to upgrade. I’m torn on the issue of the display aspect ratio. Outside of watching movies I think for me the 4/3 aspect ratio of the old Compaq Evo 600c is better for the work that I do on the laptop. But 16x9 makes for a better balanced laptop when it’s sitting on your lap (lower center of gravity) or other unstable surface. It’s also a little easier to carry around as it’s more like a book and not a square. 16x10 is actually my ideal display aspect ratio. The measured weight of this laptop with the battery is 5 lbs 7.5 ounces.
After the 65nm Merom Intel released the 45nm Penryn core, and then came Nahalem (also 45nm) but these were only quad core desktop processors. Westmere at 32nm came after Nahalem and basically was a die shrink of Nahelem with dual core parts. Sandy Bridge was next at 32nm and as we all know it was another huge performance boost from what came before it. This is about when my new laptop search started. Ivy Bridge at 22nm came and went as did Haswell at 22nm. It was until Broadwell at 14nm did I start to really get serious about a new laptop. Broadwell seemed like it would be a significant upgrade in terms of performance and performance/watt from my Merom based T7200.

Setup
I ended up purchasing the t450s from the Lenovo site. I deleted the $40 m.2 cache drive as I knew I’d be installing a 128GB m.2 SSD which I did and it was pretty painless. On the first setup “pass” I cloned the 500GB mechanical drive to the SSD and used EasyBCD 2.2 to “tell” the t450s to boot from the m.2 SSD. But as I started deleting all of the Lenovo junk apps I decided to just start from scratch so I used the Microsoft “mediacreationtool.exe” to load up a fresh copy of Windows 8.1 onto a USB drive. From there it was easy to set the USB drive as the first boot device and install windows and ONLY the Lenovo drivers I needed. Windows picked up the product keycode from the BIOS no problem so I didn’t even have to enter it. If anyone tries this here are the drivers I ended up installing:
Synaptics Thinkpad Ultra Nav – Install this one first to get the trackpad working smoothly
Intel HD Graphics Driver
Intel Chipset Drivers
Intel Chipset Management Engine Interface (not sure I needed this one actually)
Intel 7265/3160 Wireless LAN Driver
Intel Pro 1000 LAN Adapter – Gigabit Ethernet Driver
Intel Collaborative Processor Performance Control (CPPC) – To enable CPU power savings
Lenovo Power Management Driver – I don’t know if you really need this one but it does get rid of an exclamation point in Device Manager for “Unknown PCI device.”
Thinkpad Monitor INF Driver
Integrated Camera Driver
Intel 7265 Bluetooth Driver
Enhanced Performance USB Keyboard Driver
Realtek Multicard Driver
Realtek Audio Driver

I was actually quite surprised at the performance of the Transcend 128GB m.2 SSD. It scored 1136 on AS-SSD and according to HD Tach an average read speed of 407MB/sec. The write speeds aren’t off the charts but for a boot drive that’s not really an issue.
The additional 8GB of memory installed without a hitch so now the total is 12GB.
I struggled just a bit deciding on the processor for the t450s. The base processor is the 5200u and for the ridiculous amount of money they want for two to four hundred MHZ more I personally couldn’t justify it. I’m thinking I’m probably a lot like many of the Anandtech over-clockers in that we have a hard time paying for simply a different multiplier And yes, I realize that the best chip they offer does have an additional 1MB cache. Now if that additional money bought four cores instead of two or 6000 series graphics with 48EU’s I might have gone for it.

Comparisons
Keyboard – All three of these laptops have very nice keyboards but the Lenovo is definitely a cut above the rest. The keys wiggle around less and the click at the end of the travel feels good to em. I’d say the Evo 600c is just a little better than the Dell.
Trackpad – I know there was a lot of commotion in the Lenovo community when Lenovo did away with the physical button below the keyboard for the trackpad with the t440s. They did bring them back with the t450s but I have to say while the trackpad is okay I don’t love it. First of all I prefer to have the trackpad inset into the laptop frame so I can feel the edges with my fingers when using it so that I know when to “reload.” I’m finding that I will move to the edge of the trackpad and the movement of the mouse will get sketchy. In addition I don’t like having the buttons at the bottom of the trackpad being built into the pad itself. I find that when I left click to grab a scroll bar that the action of left clicking will sometimes move the mouse off of the scroll bar. On the other hand the track pads and button placement (below the pads) on the 620m and the 600c as well as the action of the trackpads themselves are perfect. Over the last week I have increased the speed of the mouse pointer which has helped the trackpad action because there is less scrolling. Also the rough surface is starting to smooth out with use which makes use a little more precise. I’d still rather have a smaller trackpad with physical buttons below it.

Display – No comparison the 1080p matte IPS display on the t450s destroys the other two in terms of off angle viewing, contrast, and color rendition/saturation. The 600c is probably a little better than the 620m to my eye just because it’s a matte screen but they’re both pretty terrible in comparison to the Lenovo.

Performance - One very outdated metric I still like using is the old Ziff-Davis CPUmark99. It only measures old school integer performance and it doesn’t take multicores into account yet it still seems to provide somewhat meaningful comparative results. The 600c scores 111, the 620m 279 and the Lenovo 467. Another way to look at this is how many MHz each processor requires to “earn” one CPUmark99. This is a somewhat crude way of estimating IPC improvements for this one old bench. The Pentium III Tulatin in the 600c needs 10.8MHz for each CPUmark, the Core2Duo T7200 in the 620m requires 7.2MHz/CPUmark, and the Broadwell based 5200u in the Lenovo requires 5.4Mhz/CPUmark. It is interesting that Broadwell is nearly twice as efficient per CPUmark99 as the Tulatin PIII, the Core2Duo fits neatly in between both of them. Somehow I managed to upgrade at just about equal performance increase levels when looking at CPUmark99 IPC.
There was also a Handbrake benchmark on the forums a while back that I also ran. Unfortunately I couldn’t run it on the Evo 600c, I kept getting a “not a valid Win32 application” error and honestly didn’t want to spend the time to track it down. Suffice it to say it would have been unbelievably dog slow. The 620m ran the bench at an average frame rate of 25.7fps while the Lenovo did it at 85.5fps. Note I did not run the “nightly” Handbrake build. The Lenovo was 3.3 times faster than the Core2Duo at compressing this video. And if we look at the MHz required of each CPU to render at an average frame rate of 1fps the Core2Duo requires 77.8MHz to do 1fps while the Broadwell only requires 29.2MHz. Besides being much faster overall Broadwell is over twice as efficient IPC-wise as Core2Duo when rendering this Handbrake benchmark.
Battery Life - I didn’t run any tests because the Evo 600c battery has long since given up the ghost and the Dell battery (a replacement) isn’t very strong either. I haven’t run any battery life tests on the t450s but I’m thinking 5 or 6 hours of my normal usage. I realize I gave up some battery life to get the display and some other features I wanted and I’m fine with that trade off. The t450s has two batteries. A built in 23.5Whr and a removable 23.5Whr one just like the t440s. I have also noticed that the laptop will use the removable battery first then move to the internal. I’m thinking (hoping) that since the internal battery doesn’t see much use perhaps it will last longer. The battery is also hot swappable so if you have two of the externals you can swap them while the computer is on. There is also a larger battery available that sticks out the back a bit if you need really long battery life.

Size and Weight - The Evo 600c measures 1-5/16” inch thick x 12-3/16” wide x 9-78” deep. The thickness measurement is taken from the surface the laptop is on to the highest point. The manufacturer’s claim will be a little less because they probably don’t include the feet. It weighs 5lbs 12.5 ounces on my digital scale. The Dell 620m measures 1-5/8” thick x 13” wide x 9-5/8” deep and weighs 5lbs 7.5 ounces. The Lenovo t450s measures 15/16” thick x 13-1/16” wide x 8-7/8” deep and weighs 3lbs 7.5 ounces. As you would expect it feels significantly thinner and lighter than the other two when you are handling it.

Build Quality – As you would expect of a ThinkPad it’s solid. As I wrote earlier if you open the screen and then hold the laptop by one corner there is zero flex in the chassis. Of course since it only weighs three and a half pounds there isn’t a lot of mass for inertia and gravity to act on. The lid closes tightly with no gaps and the hinge is tight without being too tight. There is no latch for the screen it just kind of snaps into place and stays there. I like it. The 600c is pretty well built as well but not quite as solid from a subjective point of view as the Lenovo. But again, it’s 13 years old and has held up really well. While the Dell hasn’t fallen apart it isn’t nearly as solid as the other two. The hinge constantly loosens and you have to pull half of the machine apart to tighten it every 6 months or so. There are pretty big gaps between the body and screen when it’s closed and the latch to open the display doesn’t have a nice “feel” to it, it’s kind of sticky but I guess I could put some Teflon lube in it.

Features – For the price I think the Lenovo is pretty well equipped. Integrated camera, Intel Bluetooth, Intel Wireless, 3 USB 3.0 ports, a SDHC reader, and a micro HDMI port. I really can’t fault the other laptops for lack of features because either the technology wasn’t available at the time or I didn’t want to pay for it.

Price – I paid $1930 for the Compaq Evo 600c back in 2002. I also had to buy a PCMCIA Wifi card that I think was about $40 for a total of $1970 not including tax. I paid $903 for the Dell in 2006 plus $95 for an additional 2GB of memory for a total of $998. I’m not going to include the cost of the SSD upgrade because for most of the 620’s “life” I used it with the mechanical drive. The t450s was $879(purchased from the Lenovo site) plus $65 for a Transcend m.2 128GB SSD and $70 for 8GB Crucial Ballistix Sport memory for a total system cost of $1014. Looking back I think I really got ripped on that Evo 600c for what I got. Then again after 13 years the thing still works!

Conclusion
Of course it could be ridiculous to compare technology that was released at different points in time. Newer processors are going to perform better and use less power, the wifi will be faster, the storage bigger and faster, and so on. But there are some things that aren’t as bound by time. Fit and finish, build quality, keyboard layout and feel, trackpads, etc.. Despite new and better technology manufacturers find a way to mess up these staples all the time so I thought it worth comparing them to my older devices.
Outside of the so-so trackpad, which may just be me learning how to use it, the ThinkPad is pretty damn good. I don’t want to say nearly perfect because that would require a better trackpad. And “perfect” would require a quad core processor, a faster gpu, and about double the battery life in a smaller and thinner package. We’re quite a few years away from that I think. Perhaps Cannonlake will get us those 4 cores in ultrabooks.
In conclusion I think the Lenovo t450s is a pretty good deal if you need a solid relatively thin and light laptop with a really nice IPS matte screen for most business tasks, video and audio editing, and perhaps some really light gaming. Remember it only has a 5500 series integrated GPU. Thanks for reading and I hope this little write up was helpful and semi-enjoyable to read. I wanted to give a little back to the amazing Anandtech community that has provided so much knowledge to me over the years.
-Mark
Great insight and review, I enjoyed reading it very much.

If I may add, as a long time ThinkPad user, the TrackPoint (red button) is where it's at. It is perfectly precise and once you get used to it, you well never go with anything else.

I actually use a Lenovo usb keyboard with TrackPoint on my desktop. I have not used a mouse in years. It is very productive. I fought retiring my IBM Clicky keyboard and put it in my museum along with its original IBM OS/2 PC.

You made a wise choice on selecting that laptop. ThinkPads are the best hardware out there. High quality components, design, and engineering. Thanks again for that enjoyable read.

As far as a SSD drive, I would stick with Intel. They have the best firmware. They are durable, stable, relatively fast, and low failure rate. I have been seeing a lot of bad EVOs and other popular brands for what it's worth. I have put ADATA in lower cost scenarios but prefer Intel because they just don't comeback. I still have a lot of X series out there holding their own even in enterprise environments.
 
Last edited:

sze5003

Lifer
Aug 18, 2012
14,184
626
126
I'm thinking of canceling my lenovo order. I ordered on 3/25. It got delayed when I was told it would ship within 1-3 days. Now it says estimated 4/22. Also the specs on the base model I ordered were upgraded.
 

WeirdG

Junior Member
Apr 3, 2015
5
0
66
I'm thinking of canceling my lenovo order. I ordered on 3/25. It got delayed when I was told it would ship within 1-3 days. Now it says estimated 4/22. Also the specs on the base model I ordered were upgraded.

Odd... I ordered on April 1st, and my T450S shipped today. Expected delivery is April 14th.

I ordered from the Canadian EPP site, but that shouldn't make a difference since they all come from China.

I ordered mine with the 16GB M.2 Solid State Drive, since $40 wasn't a huge dent in my wallet. Because I purchased the 16GB drive, I'll also get the 3rd M.2 SSD slot.

Since the 3rd M.2 SSD slot supports Single-sided M.2 SSDs, does that mean 2280 is supported?

2260 = Double-sided
2280 = Single-sided

ThinkPad T450s Platform Specifications
 
Last edited:

sze5003

Lifer
Aug 18, 2012
14,184
626
126
Odd... I ordered on April 1st, and my T450S shipped today. Expected delivery is April 14th.

I ordered from the Canadian EPP site, but that shouldn't make a difference since they all come from China.

I ordered mine with the 16GB M.2 Solid State Drive, since $40 wasn't a huge dent in my wallet. Because I purchased the 16GB drive, I'll also get the 3rd M.2 SSD slot.

Since the 3rd M.2 SSD slot supports Single-sided M.2 SSDs, does that mean 2280 is supported?

2260 = Double-sided
2280 = Single-sided

ThinkPad T450s Platform Specifications
I got an email today saying my order is delayed 30 days. Called support and they can't find my order. Says that model doesn't exist anymore.

I tell them well the base model now has the newer processor for the same price. Then they tell me its suppose to ship sometime in April. They say I can cancel and order the newer model. So I ask how soon will the newer model ship and they say about 3 days since they have them in stock in north Carolina.

I asked to have my order canceled and they tell me they put a request to cancel it but that it may not get canceled. If it ships, I have to accept it and call back to get shipping labels to send it back. Ridiculous. Waiting for them to hopefully cancel the order because it requires approval.

I want to re order but I have no idea what's going to happen..I'm stuck in limbo now and I kind of wanted the laptop by now. I can't get the same EPP price anywhere else or I would have ordered it somewhere else.

The PayPal funds are pending and I have enough to order another one but I don't even know if that one will get delayed or not. I'm stuck waiting now.

Edit: Yea 2280 single sided should work. Just take out that 16gb cache drive and plug in your new one.
 
Last edited:

WeirdG

Junior Member
Apr 3, 2015
5
0
66
I got an email today saying my order is delayed 30 days. Called support and they can't find my order. Says that model doesn't exist anymore.

I tell them well the base model now has the newer processor for the same price. Then they tell me its suppose to ship sometime in April. They say I can cancel and order the newer model. So I ask how soon will the newer model ship and they say about 3 days since they have them in stock in north Carolina.

I asked to have my order canceled and they tell me they put a request to cancel it but that it may not get canceled. If it ships, I have to accept it and call back to get shipping labels to send it back. Ridiculous. Waiting for them to hopefully cancel the order because it requires approval.

I want to re order but I have no idea what's going to happen..I'm stuck in limbo now and I kind of wanted the laptop by now. I can't get the same EPP price anywhere else or I would have ordered it somewhere else.

The PayPal funds are pending and I have enough to order another one but I don't even know if that one will get delayed or not. I'm stuck waiting now.

Ya... and the bad thing about Paypal is, they hold on to funds forever and regardless the reason. I still wish we could use Paypal with Lenovo Canada, and with the BillMeLater option. For Canadians, the only payment option is Credit Card.

Heck, Paypal's BillMeLater won't even work up here.
 

sze5003

Lifer
Aug 18, 2012
14,184
626
126
Ya... and the bad thing about Paypal is, they hold on to funds forever and regardless the reason. I still wish we could use Paypal with Lenovo Canada, and with the BillMeLater option. For Canadians, the only payment option is Credit Card.

Heck, Paypal's BillMeLater won't even work up here.
It used to be that way but I've never had a problem with PayPal returning the funds to my bill me later. Its lenovo who has to accept my request to cancel and release the funds. I don't get why my order can't be canceled if its delayed 2 weeks or more. I want to re order just cancel it for me and I'll order the new model. Really stupid process they have. I could understand if it shipped but I've been reading about people canceling and still receiving the order.
 

Hulk

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,377
2,256
136
I've been using the t450s for about a week now with a hard drive and not an SSD. It's been a few years since I've used a system with a mechanical drive. To the credit of the t450s with 12GB RAM and the Broadwell 5200u it's actually not too bad. Don't get me wrong, opening Photoshop, Vegas Pro, Coreldraw, etc.... is pretty painful but for web browsing or Office apps it's bearable.

I'm all but settled on the Crucial BX100 500GB but haven't been able to pull the trigger. I keep waiting for the next latest and greatest or a nice price drop. The 850EVO price, performance, and power consumption have me tempted but I just can't get with that TLC NAND.
 

WackyDan

Diamond Member
Jan 26, 2004
4,794
68
91
Yes, that's plan B. Plan A was to use the m.2 SSD as the boot drive and the 500GB mechanical for data for a while then swap out the 500GB for an SSD. I returned the m.2 to Amazon today for a refund. Now the question is whether to go with the 850EVO or the BX100. Despite the read issue problem with the 840EVO I'm leaning toward the 850EVO. I have some faith in the larger process 3D NAND. I think.

1TB 850 EVO in my w540 and it is better than the 500GB 840 EVO I had in my W510 before
 

chubbyfatazn

Golden Member
Oct 14, 2006
1,617
35
91
If it ships, I have to accept it and call back to get shipping labels to send it back.

I've read of a person over at the Thinkpad forums just refusing delivery when he was in a similar situation to yours. He said he didn't get charged restocking or anything when it got back to the warehouse.

Might be worth a shot.
 

sze5003

Lifer
Aug 18, 2012
14,184
626
126
I've read of a person over at the Thinkpad forums just refusing delivery when he was in a similar situation to yours. He said he didn't get charged restocking or anything when it got back to the warehouse.

Might be worth a shot.
Their site FAQ states if you refuse shipping you can get charged a 15% restocking fee. I just want to confirm its canceled so I can order the newer model y50 or look at another laptop. For the price I can get it directly through my discount, I can't just go and pick one up at beat buy because its about $2-300 more and not the same specs.
 

crashtech

Lifer
Jan 4, 2013
10,556
2,139
146
I've been thinking of getting a T450 for a client with particular needs, but it seems they want an exorbitant premium for the 1080 display, which is afaik new to the 14" model this year. I'd rather peddle a T550 to them, but at ~2 pounds additional carry weight it appears to be deal killer.

It's good to know that it is carrying on the tradition of being a solid machine, though it appears to me they have changed the trackpads for the worse on all the T-series machines, and the keyboards, too, according to some. Been a while since we have seen the old "Big Blue" Enter key of the old style keyboards.
 
sale-70-410-exam    | Exam-200-125-pdf    | we-sale-70-410-exam    | hot-sale-70-410-exam    | Latest-exam-700-603-Dumps    | Dumps-98-363-exams-date    | Certs-200-125-date    | Dumps-300-075-exams-date    | hot-sale-book-C8010-726-book    | Hot-Sale-200-310-Exam    | Exam-Description-200-310-dumps?    | hot-sale-book-200-125-book    | Latest-Updated-300-209-Exam    | Dumps-210-260-exams-date    | Download-200-125-Exam-PDF    | Exam-Description-300-101-dumps    | Certs-300-101-date    | Hot-Sale-300-075-Exam    | Latest-exam-200-125-Dumps    | Exam-Description-200-125-dumps    | Latest-Updated-300-075-Exam    | hot-sale-book-210-260-book    | Dumps-200-901-exams-date    | Certs-200-901-date    | Latest-exam-1Z0-062-Dumps    | Hot-Sale-1Z0-062-Exam    | Certs-CSSLP-date    | 100%-Pass-70-383-Exams    | Latest-JN0-360-real-exam-questions    | 100%-Pass-4A0-100-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-300-135-exams-date    | Passed-200-105-Tech-Exams    | Latest-Updated-200-310-Exam    | Download-300-070-Exam-PDF    | Hot-Sale-JN0-360-Exam    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Exams    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-JN0-360-exams-date    | Exam-Description-1Z0-876-dumps    | Latest-exam-1Z0-876-Dumps    | Dumps-HPE0-Y53-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-HPE0-Y53-Exam    | 100%-Pass-HPE0-Y53-Real-Exam-Questions    | Pass-4A0-100-Exam    | Latest-4A0-100-Questions    | Dumps-98-365-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-98-365-Exam    | 100%-Pass-VCS-254-Exams    | 2017-Latest-VCS-273-Exam    | Dumps-200-355-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-300-320-Exam    | Pass-300-101-Exam    | 100%-Pass-300-115-Exams    |
http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    | http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    |