Originally posted by: halfadder
Macs have no problems reading and writing to FAT32 volumes.
BUT.... Macs can't currently write to NTFS volumes, they can only read from them. It'll be interesting to see how Apple deals with NTFS when the iPod hard drives get bigger and require NTFS instead of FAT32.
FAT32 for iPods is no problem for music, but for data, it can be an issue.
1) FAT32 on Mac OS X is a lot slower than HFS+ on Mac OS X. But this is irrelevant on iPods, because the drive is so slow to begin with.
2) Certain characters in filenames are not accepted on FAT32, but work fine on HFS+. It's not an issue with music encoded with iTunes (since iTunes names the files appropriately), but is an issue if you're saving Mac data files with special characters. For example, if you copy a directory full of files from a Mac to a FAT32 iPod, and one of the files has a weird character in it, then the copy will simply terminate when it hits the file and give you a cryptic error message. Then you have to search thru the directory to find the file with the errant character. Now imagine if you have 200 files in that directory.
In truth though it doesn't affect me, since I don't use strange characters in my filenames, but some Mac users are used to using them.
Originally posted by: halfadder
Macs have no problems reading and writing to FAT32 volumes.
BUT.... Macs can't currently write to NTFS volumes, they can only read from them. It'll be interesting to see how Apple deals with NTFS when the iPod hard drives get bigger and require NTFS instead of FAT32.
How big? For example, 120 GB FAT32 drives work just fine in Windows XP.