Your logic isn't much better, and some of your information is flat out wrong. My argument was about the general population, you're trying to use my specific use case as a counter. That's not how it works. You would have to show that generally, people buy consoles for the exclusives. A single exception does not break a general assumption.
A "huge" portion of games on any console are multi-platform. Take your Uncharted, Bloodbourne, etc., and compare that against the full library. It's not huge.
If we go by online numbers, games like CoD and FIFA dominate. Those are multi-plat games. They also have PC releases. If your typical online player finds themselves needing to buy a new console every 3-4 years as opposed to every 6-10, I think many will just migrate to PC instead. Higher up-front costs, upgrades only on an as-needed basis (and for 1080p, that's not very often), cheaper games overall, and no annual fee for online play.
What I want a console for is not what you want a console for. And if you'd seen many of my previous posts, I have been advocating chasing the games you want to play and playing how you like for a good long time. "Just get both." You even pointed out that I want Uncharted 4. I've stated I will get a PS4 in the past because of exclusives. What kind of ground shattering advice are you giving me that I haven't been saying myself for years?
And with all that, I still believe that generally, people will shift over to PC as a short-cycle console provides far fewer benefits over PC as the console investment goes up. Reality is that many people cannot afford multiple systems. It's why there are fanboys and petty arguments over 180 lines of resolution.
I mean, we do live in a world where Steamboxes are sold and nvidia will pre-configure a game's settings for you. There's more choice than ever, and PC is easier than ever to get into. Why wouldn't they shift?
It is much better. Those "in the know" will just by PC's? That argument has been around forever. I personally prefer PC's. I enjoy building them, designing watercoolng, and the freedom they give you. But I'm not oblivious to the fact that a lot of very good games don't come out on them. While the hardware is more like a computer than ever before, it doesn't change the fact there are still exclusives. Other than an emulator I have never played a Mario game on the computer. Likely never will. Your assumption people will just convert to PC's because of a "short" lifespan is silly. For a long time I upgraded video cards every 6 months, that's short. Not 3 years. And people don't have to get the newer version if it comes out. Theirs will still play just as advertised. Every new game will work on it, at least that is the information we're being given now. My opinion would change if that is not the case.
It's an option, one I'm glad for. I realize it won't be a huge jump and 4K gaming will be very limited. Just like it is on the PC. I'm thankful for the advancement. Might even be smaller, quieter, etc. Consoles have had new versions for years, just not new hardware.
I don't recall seeing any previous posts so I'm not aware of your posting habits. To me it's just silly complaining about an option that does nothing but benefit the people who want it.