Thanx for replying. I suppose the first part contributes to my not loving that movie.
I don't identify with apes at all. They aren't humans, and don't speak English.
"Massive suspension of disbelief" is required to even appreciate the entire premise of the movie.
I would need to watch it again and make some detailed notes of why i didn't like it all that much, but i recall it feeling very cliched far too often (assuming we are treating apes are human characters).
I know many critics love this one too, so i'll go with we'll have to agree to disagree. I think it's a good movie, just probably not one for me.
Are you saying that a virus engineered to improve brain function which may prove deadly to humans but not primates requires "massive suspension of disbelief?" You don't think that a smarter ape raised with humans who brought intelligence to the others by giving them the virus would be a natural leader now that they all have human-like intelligence? I have no problem with that.
Treating childbirth differently, standing upright just because they are smarter, and not having proper, er, anatomy (no monkey penises), were dumb elements but they helped the human audience relate to their ape society and they are easy to forgive in the name of story-telling.
Also, they DO speak English. Not sure how you missed that. Sign language has the advantage of being A) partially understood by some apes already before their viral intelligence boost, and B) able to be used by all type of apes regardless of vocal ability (notice: Orangutans, Gorillas, and Chimpanzees). The virus didn't grow voice boxes so even Ceasar obviously had difficulty vocalizing with words. That much is very realistic. Having the brain capacity for complex speech before having the biological capacity for complex vocalizations