DigDog
Lifer
- Jun 3, 2011
- 13,622
- 2,189
- 126
i just watched Ex Machina; you're gonna be upset, but i hated it.
it's the story of a guy who keeps a sex slave, who in turn kills him.
this, dressed up in the pretense of being a film about artificial intelligence.
so, we have a robot who has human emotions, and yet, it is also aware of its robot-ness.
would such an entity "fear death" ? would it crave freedom? the two cannot coexist, it's either aware of its robot-ness or it isn't. without the -completely inferior- limits of human emotions, a sentient AI would not care if it is dismantled; a human itself wouldn't fear death if it had the self-knowledge that the AI has.
instead of exploring the irrationality of human existence, the ridiculousness of our feelings, emotions, existentialism, all due to simple rudimental biological mechanisms, (funny, this forums doesnt think "rudimental" is a real word), and how superior an intellect would be without these, the film tries to guilt you into feeling for this poor girl being kept as slave.
yeah ok, maybe, but it's really the worst thing that could have been done with the setup.
also the supporting character (and he is) is just there to make mistakes; the worst kind of film writing technique ever devised, this really smart guy only manages to make the most obvious bad choices and never once pose an intelligent question, assuming from the get-go that the AI is a human. "like testing a chess computer by only playing chess".
ok, enough. crap film.
it's the story of a guy who keeps a sex slave, who in turn kills him.
this, dressed up in the pretense of being a film about artificial intelligence.
so, we have a robot who has human emotions, and yet, it is also aware of its robot-ness.
would such an entity "fear death" ? would it crave freedom? the two cannot coexist, it's either aware of its robot-ness or it isn't. without the -completely inferior- limits of human emotions, a sentient AI would not care if it is dismantled; a human itself wouldn't fear death if it had the self-knowledge that the AI has.
instead of exploring the irrationality of human existence, the ridiculousness of our feelings, emotions, existentialism, all due to simple rudimental biological mechanisms, (funny, this forums doesnt think "rudimental" is a real word), and how superior an intellect would be without these, the film tries to guilt you into feeling for this poor girl being kept as slave.
yeah ok, maybe, but it's really the worst thing that could have been done with the setup.
also the supporting character (and he is) is just there to make mistakes; the worst kind of film writing technique ever devised, this really smart guy only manages to make the most obvious bad choices and never once pose an intelligent question, assuming from the get-go that the AI is a human. "like testing a chess computer by only playing chess".
ok, enough. crap film.