first thing, let's stop pretending to be shocked when a good director puts out a
bad film; it's not like it's never happened before.
Reservoir Dogs
i know this was loved by everyone but i am not too keen on it.
i applaud the fact that it's basically a stage play on film, but i find that the violence - both verbal and physical - is there to shock people, not to drive the story. It's basically a splatter-horror tool.
decent film.
Pulp Fiction
his masterpiece; Orson Welles was always held up to his Citizen Kane and could never match it with later films, so no surprise that Tarantino's best film is also his first major production.
violence and vulgarity beyond anything ever seen before (Die Hard was considered a "rough" film when it aired), but they serve to drive forward the plot.
Zed's rape is why bruce willis comes back. the accidental killing of marvin is the introduction of wolf. etc.
fantastic editing of different plotlines, which are different viewpoints of the main plot, a revolutionary soundtrack, masterful production, this is one of the best films ever made.
Natural Born Killers
from my perspective, this film was a turning point. the story begins easy enough with a bonnie & clyde theme, yes they are bad, and extreme, yes they kill people, but it's bad people they kill and essentially, they just want to be left alone and live in peace; then there's the scene of the shamans and the characters are flipped into people who kill because they can't help themselves. we rooted for them, and then we start rooting against them.
now that might have been the whole point of the film, but in the script it's just the beginning, and there's another hour of them just killing everything which "i'm not sure why i should be watching this". it's no way to write a story.
- i didnt see four rooms, no idea -
from dusk till dawn
still angry i paid full price for this. it's basically " let's see if we can sneak this joke script past the executives", and while it might be an amusing joke, i'm pissed off that you want ME to pay for it.
Jackie Brown
finally a good QT film; teh story makes sense, the characters make sense, the plot makes sense. it's almost as if QT got told he had 1 last chance to make a "proper" film or he'd be banned from hollywood forever.
Kill Bill(s)
ok, i get it, you have a list of references. and while the first watch was mildly amusing, it doesn't have the flow of any of his previous films, including dusk2dawn. it's just a collection of scenes, of which many are rather bland. uma thurman really carries the films, but from both a direction, and writing PoV, it really lacks that something special, the inspiation. for example, the final scene with Bill is pathetic. ORen's death is horrible .. anticlimax is the word.
Grindhouse + Death Proof
absurdist films, to the limit of being comedy spoofs, but both reasonably fun to watch (i liked Grindhouse and not Death Proof). If we lose touch with reality, it's hard to know what we should take seriously and what not. Here he's clearly just writing anything weird that comes to his mind and then filming it, blowing everything out of proportion.
I suspect that, if rodriguez was not co-directing, it would have been a disaster.
Inglorious Basterds
to me, this is the uncanny valley; it looks almost human, but there's a touch of something wrong that makes me uneasy. i finally understand i'm supposed to just watch the specatcle and ignore the acting, because there is nothing realistic about this film - this film reminds me, of all thing, of Barton Fink.
At this point i'm convinced that QT has completely lost the ability to direct human emotions, he's only capable of doing caricatures, and when he tries unsuccessfully to do something "normal", this is what comes out.
"you owe me 100 scalps.."
you could have had telly savalas do this in a 1968 film, directed by Sydney Pollack, and it would be remembered as an epic, grim speech. QT does it and it's a joke only fit for youtube videos.
Django unchained
i just got bored here. if QT wanted to depict a character who becomes wild with bloodlust, what he came up with is a robot causing destruction. these characters have no aspect of their personality i can relate to, at all.
the real lead, christopher waltz, keeps the film interesting (if somewhat disjointed) for a while, but when he bows out it's time to walk out of the theater. i honestly think most real blaxploitation films did the Black Revenge films better, keeping the surrealism in check and bringing a touch of class that QT wishes he had.
H8
game over man, game over. QT has lost all sense of what it's like to sit in a theater and have to watch two hours of his garbage. nobody wants to see him chirp "and now i'm gonna ruin the script! and again! and even more!" because nobody thinks that joke's funny anymore.
at this point i'd rather watch a linear script rehash of something seen a million times before than watch QT amusing himself into thinking his scenes are great. he's thinking "and now, we're gonna shoot a huuuuge ass panoramic of snow with an armed black man staring in the middle, because that's totally awesome!!!" and we're just like" aww man, just tell me a story that makes sense, come on".
just consider that, modern stuff clearly inspired by QT, such as Black Dynamite, are actually better QT films than what QT can come up with these days.