The problem is, even with a premium cooler on the Fury X and performance almost the same as the 980 TI @ release for the same price, people shit all over AMD.
Less memory, more power draw, pump noise issue, slower, and short in stock. While I'm sure you won't believe me, I tried to buy a Fury X. But I couldn't. Why I settled for a reference GTX 980 Ti I bought after saying screw it. I can show you my receipt where the order was literally made at 1AM almost into July because I couldn't wait anymore.
Throw in a $10 Gift card, two free games, and buying the EVGA Hybrid cooler separate, my card cost me less than Fury X and is water cooled
They can't win by offering better quality at the same price, they HAVE to provide better price/perf or people won't even give them a look. Its sad but many people won't even buy AMD when they are better price/perf (see low end cards last gen with 960 selling like crazy).
Well, that is due to their bargain bin repertoire. One they cultivated for years. Hell, the backlash here for $550 HD 7970 was astounding. Even when AMD had a better product, faster, used less power, and $50 less than the 3GB GTX 580, it went pretty much unrecommended by a prolific poster here. AMD jacked up MSRP from HD 6970 almost 50%. That was a no-no. I happily paid the cost of admission and loved my HD 7970, until I tried CFX and then just realized mGPU (specially at the time AMD's implementation of it) was terrible.
When perf / price is pushed so hard by one side and this trickles into other forums, I'm not surprised people WONT spend extra money for AMD. This is where I feel NV by even spitting in the face of majority of buyers did right. The Founder's Edition is nothing special, but it created this perception of value. And NV is reaping the profits because of it. I mean, look at the Fury Brand. I said it from the start, I don't think AMD handled it right. Fury should have been their premium name, one that demands a little extra. But because of performance and the AMD leadership, Fury was no Titan. And we go on to see Fury get price cuts Titan does not. Even if most consumers know Titan is not worth it, the perception is still there.
AMD launched the RX 480 with the sales slogan of "$500 GPU for only $200!"
So how can they win? Even with 290(x) providing much better price/perf over the 780 (ti) they couldn't gain lots of market share. Every high end they've released has been very good but still lost market share to nvidia.
One of those things here a lot of people promote actually hurt AMD. Bitmining. Radeons between 2013 and late 2014 were going for 20-50% over MSRP because of bitmining. When that bubble burst the market was flooded with used cards. It went from $800+ Radeon 290X to literally <$350 Radeon 290X in a little under a month.
This too hurts perception. Then R9 300 series launched and every scoffed at AMD raising the price because 290X could be easily had for <$250.
Taking back market share is very important for PC gaming because of how optimizations are done per game.
I disagree. Because even when AMD had a strong market share, games devs weren't going out of their way to optimize for AMD. That's why I loved AMD's Gaming Evolved push in 2012-2013. Lots of games they sponsored. Then that dried up and GameWorks showed up. AMD must have run their coffers thin because even the Mantle sponsored games can be counted on one hand. EDIT: And I think this is what ultimately hurt AMD for higher end GPU buyers. Mantle delivered so little and so late. And the mantra of "wait for the DX12 push" was heralded since basically 2015. 2016 is almost done and this onslaught of DX12 games is still lacking. Sure someone will rattle off a list of games, just like someone else did in 2015, but I won't be surprised if half the list gets blocked by NV-Gameworks money hatting. The other subset of every-day games will not be pushing these boundaries until well into 2017 if not beyond. I mean, come one look at some of the biggest sellers - they are literally still using modified DX9 code!!! in 2016!!!!
Now with the consoles trend, I see NV more than ever blocking AAA titles from running optimized on AMD day 1.
And NV is laughing all the way to the bank.