Originally posted by: palehorse
Originally posted by: Lemon law
But GWB instead took out his can of instant whipass, used too small of a force, and made a fatal blunder that plagues us still.
You're finally correct -- by accident. That "blunder" was our stopping at the imaginary, and otherwise unrecognized, Pakistan-Afghanistan border.
And while the revisionist history is that 300 of our special forces chased all of the Taliban out of Afghanistan, the real muscle was provided by the Northern alliance
They helped... but, if you ever bothered to get to know a former Northern Alliance leader, as I have, they'll be the first ones to tell you that our air power and SOF troops were THE deciding factor. Combined, the trifecta was unbeatable...
So, once again, why the fuck did we stop at the border!?
And guess what, the Taliban is back and many look at them to be the cure Nato is not providing.
Only Taliban members, or former Taliban members, "look at them to be the cure" to anything. The rest are forced to do while staring down the barrels of Taliban guns. This is perhaps the biggest flaw in your entire argument. You consistently refer to the mysterious populace who "look to" or "prefer" the Taliban...
Who the fuck are you referring to!? I've been all across the country of Afghanistan and I've never met a truly innocent Afghan civilian who "prefers" or "looks to" the Taliban. Every single one of them, who is not a member of the Taliban themselves, is
afraid of the Taliban as though they were each the devil himself.
You're fucking delusional and ill-prepared to have this debate any further. Why you continues to bloviate is beyond comprehension...
Worse yet, Nato is not doing the smart thing, namely to drive a wedge between Al-Quida and the Taliban who have totally different objectives.
uhh, that may be the most inaccurate thing you've EVER written on this subject, and that's saying a lot!
Meanwhile the Taliban driven into Pakistan are ethnically indistinguishable from the native tribes. But as guests, cannot play the Sharia law card, because the tribal areas are not at war with each other, and corruption and anarchy do not flourish.
Are you fucking kidding me?! Sharia Law, in all its inhumanity, is the very foundation of the control the Taliban enforces throughout the entire tribal region. It has nothing to do with "corruption and anarchy," and everything to do with cold-blooded murder, rape, and an inhumane set of "rules" being forced upon the populace.
Where the fuck do you get the idea that the Taliban and tribes are separate!? At this point, thanks to our waiting six years, they are one in the fucking same. The tribal leaders are ALL members of the Taliban throughout Northwest Pakistan. And they ARE fighting amongst themselves on a daily fucking basis! There are at least three predominant "sects" of the Taliban living and vying for control throughout the tribal areas. Each of them maintains the same focus on attacking NATO forces in Afghanistan; but, they are also fighting with one-another for control of the entire show.
Hundreds of elders, leaders, and others have died in the fighting between the tribes during the same period of time they've been fighting NATO -- the last six years.
So they have to be somewhat on their best behavior or they will alienate their hosts. Meanwhile the Taliban network extend into all the Northern Stans and they also can bring in money and foreign fighters from States in the Mid-East. But one thing for sure, the people of the Tribal areas are 100% in opposition to Nato incursions onto Pakistani soil.
They are quickly approaching a point when they will be 100% Taliban as well. They're well into the 90+ percentile already, and growing every day (except for the women, of course. they are relegated to the eternal slavery that comes with living with Taliban men... lucky them!)
blockading them at the border is a better alternative, and there is now enough popular Afghan support for them to hide in plain sight in Afghanistan.
What you describe is a physically impossible objective, even with a NATO force of astronomical size. You'd know that if your experience in the region went beyond the interweb and PBS...
The "border region" is impossible to cover in its entirety.
From wikipedia (your lifeline on this topic?):
The Hindu Kush reaches a height of 7485 m. / 24,557 ft. at Nowshak, Afghanistan's highest peak. Of the ranges extending southwestward from the Hindu Kush, the Koh-i-Baba reaches the greatest height (Shah Fuladi, 5,142 m /16,870 ft). The Safed Koh range, which includes the Tora Bora area, dominates the border area southeast of Kabul. Important passes include the Unai Pass across the Sanglakh Range, and the Kotal-e Salang, connecting Kabul with central and northern Afghanistan, respectively. The approaches to the Khyber Pass across the Safed Koh are in eastern Afghanistan; the summit of the pass at 1070 m. / 3,509 ft. at Landi Kotal, Pakistan is five kilometers east of the border town of Torkham. Other key passages through the mountainous Pakistan border include two from Paktika Province into Pakistan's Waziristan region: one at Angoor Ada, a village that straddles both sides of the border east of Shkin, and, further south, the Gumal River crossing, plus the Charkai River passage south of Khowst, Afghanistan, at Pakistan's Ghulam Khan village into North Waziristan. The busy Pakistan border crossing at Wesh, just northwest of Chaman, Pakistan, connecting Kandahar and Spin Boldak, Afghanistan, to Quetta, Pakistan, is in a flat, dry area, though this route involves Pakistan's Khojak Pass at 2,707 m. / 8,881 ft. just 14 km. from the border.
Originally posted by: Lemon law
Now suppose we buy into this magic bullet plan of Nato unilaterally invading the Tribal areas of Pakistan.
Fuck "invasion"... nobody has ever called for an "invasion." Our SOF units and other SMU's, combined with extensive air support and a small number of Afghan advisers, could clear out the entire tribal region in six months, or less.
We've had six years to put together the target packages, establish networks, and devise a thorough strategy for doing just that.
Our "hounds" are very fucking good at their jobs.
With military might and air support, Nato could start in the Southern end of the Tribal areas and march its troops right up to the borders of the Northern Stans
with the Taliban somewhat powerless to resist. Blowing up houses and villages as they go, and just generally creating chaos and anarchy. And do we envision that the Taliban, finally chased like rats, will finally be cornered, with no place to run, and be finally be forced to stand and fight, AK-47's against 2000 thousand pound bombs and helicopter gunships able to hose the entire area up? And thereafter, the world, rid of Al-Quida and the Taliban, shall be instant paradise on earth. The things comic books and hollywoods scripts are made off, complete with the they lived happily ever after.
Sounds good to me.
LL, you get more and more ridiculous every time you post...