Disagree
completely.
The Department of Justice, on Micron's request, went after Rambus. After wasting millions of dollars of taxpayer money all the way to the Supreme Court, came up empty handed. Their Administrative Law Judge McGuire completely exonerated Rambus, stating "...the commission has taken an aggressive interpretation of rather weak evidence.":
http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2004/02/rambusid.shtm
Rambus did not have "off-the-wall" accusations. In fact, the FTC case against them helped them uncover damning documents, including:
Managing Director of International Sales Linda Turner. Ms. Turner was responding to reports by her staff that Hynix was lowering its DDR pricing: "No problem! We want DDR to explode into the marketplace so have actually been requesting Infineon, Samsung, and Hynix to lower their DDR pricing to help it become a standard and drive Rambus away completely."
http://rambus.org/legal/menace.pdf
Willie Meyer, IBM, "Rambus is a deadly menace. One day all computers will have to be built like this, but hopefully without the royalties going to Rambus."
October 1999, an Intel manager explained to Intel's Peter MacWiliams, "so far all our discussions with Appleton (Micron CEO) have had zero benefit for us, we have gone out of our way to help them resolve Rambus contract issues and in return we have gotten nothing but deception. Micron is working very hard to do everything against RDRAM." (RX 1515 at 2)
Farhad Tabrizi, Hynix executive, in his June 2000 email to Park, Tabrizi stated: "I really want to ask you to let me go back to my old mode of RDRAM killing. I think we were very close to achieving our goal until you said we are absolutely committed to this baby."
From the FTC evidence: ''Jeff Mailloux, a senior Micron executive, President Tabrizi on February 20, 1998 that he had called a reporter and had told him that RDRAM was "at least 30% more expensive to manufacture than SDRAM. Mr. Mailloux urged Mr. Tabrizi to make a similar call to the reporter, warning Mr. Tabrizi not to forward his email to anyone and asked Mr. Tabrizi "Anyhow, please visit me if I end up in jail, but felt it was important and timely enough to get our message out there that 5% is not realistic in our opinion."
Hynix manager Andy Ha that Hynix "get together with Samsung and ask them to suggest to Micron to have a joint management meeting for RDRAM/DDR price control in the future."
Like I said before, I am completely baffled how 9 of those jurors could see it any differently.