Well even if that is the case why the hell did they send them out? If they can't even cherry pick cards for review samples the general public is screwed. Unless some of these are cherry picked and it's gonna get worse.
someone earlier made a decent argument that from a business standpoint, it was a pretty smart move and I agree, because:
--If you can safely overvolt the bad chips and hit close to your relative performance target it is hardly going to matter to the market that is targeted for this card
--they've sold out inventory that was released at an estimated 20x rate than what is currently available for 1080--in about 2 days.
--It seems that AIB cards will be appearing within 1 or 2 weeks time with much better cooling, better drivers by then, and almost certainly better performance/power efficiency.
--the market that was holding out for those AIB cards is likely the market that actually cares about these details.
--It's also still very possible that the best chips were binned for Apple/Sony/Microsoft, probably even full chips that AMD hasn't even announced under Polaris yet? Dunno, that's purely speculation based on past history.
They hit price exactly as advertised with performance at that upper-mid to lower high range target as expected, with power efficiency well below that upper level and still a bit better than it's price point.
It really is still a win.
Where I think the real criticism and concern belongs is what this means for their process going forward--does it actually mean anything for future Polaris chips, Vega, Zen? is this 14nm FinFet "garbage" when it comes to power, is it a GloFo issue? There's a lot of ideas about this floating about and considering that some cards seem to be performing on all levels as they are expected to, while others certainly are not--it's just too early to say what the problem is.
This thing has only been out in retail for a day and over the previous couple of weeks in reviewer hands, I believe there were already 2 or 3 driver updates, and it was still known that they all had issues? Plus, when most of these cards sent to reviewers have a physical capacity of either 4 or 8gb and a BIOS feature to choose between the two, and a retail inventory that is limited only to 4 or 8gb on each card only, with no such BIOS feature, it further complicates what is going on.
I'm guessing we'll know a lot more after the weekend once all of the user stuff starts exploding.