OFFICIAL:American Idol thread, new season, new judges, TONIGHT

[NFS4]

I thought Casey was gonna have a heart attack on stage.

 

[her209]

Casey + Hailey (?)
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbi...tants-Casey-Abrams-Haley-Reinhart-dating.html

 

[TheNinja]

Wowowow... Hulk Hogan on American Idol.

blonde chinese hair and skin of a hotdog.

YA BROTHA!!

 

[FeuerFrei]

Was that last episode "Lie to the Audience" night? I think Freemantle crossed a line there. Keep that up and no one will ever take it seriously when you say they're voted off.

 

[zinfamous]

Casey + Hailey (?)
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbi...tants-Casey-Abrams-Haley-Reinhart-dating.html

Good for Casey. I really like Haley's voice, too. sad that neither of them will last much longer.

 

[shopbruin]

Casey + Hailey (?)
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbi...tants-Casey-Abrams-Haley-Reinhart-dating.html

EWWWWWWWW NO CASEY DON'T DO IT.

I can't stand Haley.

 

[zinfamous]

I think Haley can be pretty hot if she wants to. Also has a great, great voice. Her performances aren't always spectacular, but she's the only girl up there with any real soul behind her voice.

I think only Pia is the better female singer. :\

 

[Udgnim]

a lot of good performances this week

think Stefano and Naima should be on the chopping block, but we'll see how voting actually goes

 

[NFS4]

Randy straight up lied to Haley. Best performance of the night? BULLSHIT!

 

[moshquerade]

So, two are eliminated tonight. My choices are 2 of these 3. Thia is sweet, but she's not star quality. She's too shy. Paul is just awful. He's too odd. Jacob can't lose the whiny gospel singing. He's not adaptable to anything.
I wouldn't like it if anyone else got the boot tonight, because after those 3 are gone it's going to be tough losing any other one.

• Thia Megia
  
  16 years old | Hayward, CA

• Paul McDonald
  
  26 years old | Huntsville, AL

• Jacob Lusk
  
  23 years old | Compton, CA

 

[trmiv]

Randy straight up lied to Haley. Best performance of the night? BULLSHIT!

No kidding. Maybe he was afraid she'd bite him after all that growling she did on stage?

 

[NFS4]

So, two are eliminated tonight. My choices are 2 of these 3. Thia is sweet, but she's not star quality. She's too shy. Paul is just awful. He's too odd. Jacob can't lose the whiny gospel singing. He's not adaptable to anything.
I wouldn't like it if anyone else got the boot tonight, because after those 3 are gone it's going to be tough losing any other one.

• Thia Megia
  
  16 years old | Hayward, CA

• Paul McDonald
  
  26 years old | Huntsville, AL

• Jacob Lusk
  
  23 years old | Compton, CA

I'd love to see some girl on girl action with Thia and Pia

 

[moshquerade]

I'd love to see some girl on girl action with Thia and Pia

LOL, wrong forum :twisted:

All the girls on Idol are hotties right now. Most talented, and most beautiful people on there ever.

 

[her209]

Randy straight up lied to Haley. Best performance of the night? BULLSHIT!

I liked Haley's performance the best last night. Of the girls left, Haley has the best vocals. Thia and Pia are boring. Lauren just reminds me of a ditsy Kelly Clarkson. Naima is making it through on her back story. She's has the worst singing ability of the girls left.

 

[Ns1]

BENNY AND THE JETS


caps

 

[moshquerade]

Randy straight up lied to Haley. Best performance of the night? BULLSHIT!

Bennie and the Jets is a hard ass song to sing. She did well by it.
Hopefully though she used up her growls and won't bring them into a song again. :awe:

Who was the best of the night then in your opinion?

 

[her209]

Also, did anyone else think Casey was singing the song to Haley?

 

[shopbruin]

He better not have been singing that song to Haley, damnit. Eyes on the prize!

I personally cannot stand Haley, and I was not paying attention. The hubs was loving it. That growl is annoying. Utterly annoying.

My favorite performance last night was Casey, because he really restrained himself.

The other person I don't like is Pia. I realize she's mad talented, but she is so utterly boring, I can't take it. No personality. At all. Plus she sang another ballad, no matter how hard she tries to disguise it.

I hated Naima's performance last night. All of a sudden she developed a Jamaican accent - talk about forced. She understands the performance part, but it is distracting from the singing part.

Last night in my massive voting spree, I voted for everyone not named Thia, Pia or Haley. Or Naima.

My personal bottom three would be Haley, Stefano, and Thia.
A realistic one would prob Thia, Stefano and Naima, with possibly some Paul thrown in there.

 

[her209]

If you took Pia and dyed her hair blond, you'd get Jessica Simpsons.

 

[moshquerade]

If you took Pia and dyed her hair blond, you'd get Jessica Simpsons.

Not.

Jessica Simpson hasn't had a body like Pia's in a long time.

 

[NFS4]

Bennie and the Jets is a hard ass song to sing. She did well by it.
Hopefully though she used up her growls and won't bring them into a song again. :awe:

Who was the best of the night then in your opinion?

Casey.

 

[her209]

Casey.

I'm a big Casey fan, but he really pulled back this week after being saved last week. I agree that he was growling too much in the last couple performances, but last night, the song couple have used some growling at certain points of the song to make it not so sleepy.

 

[Ns1]

I'm a big Casey fan, but he really pulled back this week after being saved last week. I agree that he was growling too much in the last couple performances, but last night, the song couple have used some growling at certain points of the song to make it not so sleepy.

casey right behind haley for me.

 

[zinfamous]

I liked Haley's performance the best last night. Of the girls left, Haley has the best vocals. Thia and Pia are boring. Lauren just reminds me of a ditsy Kelly Clarkson. Naima is making it through on her back story. She's has the worst singing ability of the girls left.

I thought Haley's performance was awesome--most interesting voice in the competition when she really brings it out. I thought Casey was better though...Pia solid again.

I think Stefano, and perhaps Naima are gone. None of them were bad, they just have a tough time getting through and this will be it for them. Stefano's was the worst, imo.

i thought Thia was really good, but she bored me, yet again.

I will say, realistically, that Haley is likely gone. She's too good for the AI crowd to understand. :awe:



I am completely underwhelmed by this season.

 

[zinfamous]

wow, people didn't like Haley "growling?" That was fucking awesome. the wort part was the BBBB Benny part of the chorus. way too soft and underutilized for her arrangement. very distracting.

the rest of the performance was tits.