Clean installed WXP SP2 fixed the voltage reading issue. With SP2, the voltage AND core speed go up/down with load, as shown by CPUz. That's good. However, I did not notice any change in CPU core temperature during idling with Speedstep ON/OFF. A decrease of Vcore and CPU clock speed should have lowered the CPU core temperture. I use Speedfan, RmClock, and TAT to confirm that there is no change in CPU idling temperature with Speedstep ON/OFF.
Hooked up a calibrated Fluke ammeter on the AC input line to measure the actual current (in mA) during various states of operation. Power Options in Windows is set to NOTEBOOK mode. A Big Typhoon with one medium speed 120 x 38mm Panaflo serves as the CPU cooler. Switching to Minimal Power Management yields no change. ACPI is standard from Microsoft (SP1 or SP2). ACPI 2.0 enabled in BIOS.
Asus P5B Deluxe with 1101 BIOS, C2D E4300, EVGA 7100GS, and 2GB Kingston 800 ValueRam. System is stable with S&M max heat, 32M Super Pi 1.5 XS, Orthos, and TAT.
IDLE; 280MHz FSB; Vcore @ AUTO
-Speedstep ON....1.140Vcore...1680MHz core speed...1140mA current
-Speedstep OFF...1.304Vcore...2520MHz core speed...1220mA current
IDLE; 290MHz FSB; Vcore @ AUTO
-Speedstep ON....1.050Vcore...1740MHz core speed...1240mA current
-Speedstep OFF...1.330Vcore...2610MHz core speed...1240mA current
IDLE; 280MHz FSB; Vcore @ 1.475
-Speedstep ON....1.050Vcore...1680MHz core speed...1320mA current
-Speedstep OFF...1.448Vcore...2520MHz core speed...1320mA current
IDLE; 380MHz FSB; Vcore @ 1.475
-Speedstep ON....1.050Vcore...2280MHz core speed...1410mA current
-Speedstep OFF...1.448Vcore...3420MHz core speed...1410mA current
To verify that the ammeter is okay, I disconnected an 80mm fan and the current went down by about 10mA (1.2 watt).
Speedstep works in lowering the power, but only up to 280MHz FSB with Vcore in AUTO mode. At and above 290MHz, Speedfan still show a drop in voltage and core speed with Speedstep enabled, but the actual power consumption by the PC does not change (same current draw from the AC outlet). The test results were identical with WXP Pro SP1, even though Speedfan does not correctly report the voltage drop with Speedstep enabled.
I don't believe there is a problem with Windows (clean installed WXP Pro SP1 and SP2 with latest Intel drivers). Suspect the engineer at Asus is using BIOS 1101 to ignore the command to lower the voltage. You may think that you're saving electricity and reducing heat with Speedstep, but the BIOS locks Vcore above 280MHz FSB, and perhaps core speed. The actual current draw from the AC outlet remains the same as if Speedstep was disabled in BIOS and Windows!
I cannot downflash to an older BIOS in Windows. To accomplish this, I must use a bootable floppy. Course the 1M BIOS wouldn't fit on a bootable floppy.
I also tested the maximum power draw from the wall with Orthos and TAT @ 100% load for 10 minutes.
FULL LOAD; 380MHz FSB; Vcore @ 1.475; 3420MHz Core Speed
-Orthos...2320mA (~278 watts)
-TAT.......2600mA (~312 watts)
I didn't realize that TAT would draw that much power from the wall. The idle load went from 169 watts at idle to 312 watts at 100% TAT load! You'll need a very powerful CPU cooler if you want to push these latest C2D chips to the max. The technology permits a very high core speed with additional voltage, but the current and heat generated will also explode, BIG TIME. I wouldn't push higher than 1.375Vcore with the stock CPU cooler.
This chip is capable of 3.5 to 3.6GHz on air, but only with a better CPU cooler. I'm already pushing 65C Orthos with 81F ambient (30C no load). Yes, the surfaces are lapped with 2000 paper.