Originally posted by: Zenoth
Originally posted by: skace
I do think Diablo 1 was a much darker and more roguelike Diablo game. And I do prefer it over Diablo 2. But at this point, and with the massive success that D2 got, I'd expect D3 to be much more similar to Diablo 2 than the original. The footage we've seen at this point sort of demonstrates that fact. While they show giant demons, even those do not look scary by comparison to the butcher. The biggest difference between D1 and D2 is that D1 was a game where you may or may not get powerful but the game actively wanted to kill you at all times. The series has moved from this, very roguelike sentiment, to the monty haul perspective, which is your character should become the god and the enemies should fear you. Monty haul is actually the original loot whoring term, but the end result is that your character gets massively powerful due to a constant stream of good items.
I agree, but it was less so with the original Diablo II.
When the expansion came out and especially starting from patch 1.10 (also 1.09) Assassins could Whirldwind, any classes could Teleport, Barbarians could have Paladin Auras and the Paladin could cast Battle Orders... I mean playing D2 doesn't feel unique as it did without the expansion. The influx of good items doesn't help, and the mega-powerful Runewords are just basically screwing everything, turning most Lvl 90+ characters into auto bots running Baal non-stop. I never finished the original Diablo, but I remember having a very hard time with it when I tried it, and I cannot recall ever finding any "awesome" item, contrary to Diablo II which happens roughly twice a week or so.
Basically, yes, Diablo was more challenging than Diablo II, but Diablo II was also more challenging than Lord of Destruction. I hope that Diablo III's general atmosphere and chosen colors palette won't reflect its challenge, because we'll have DII all over again with polygons and physics this time around. I am going to buy D3, but I'm honestly not over-hyped for it, I believe "it's cool", you know, it's getting to be released, well, nice, but nothing more, let's wait, then buy, then play, and then judge, for now I'm still busy with TF2 and M2:TW.