RE: Ishin
Ok, even after the stupid monkeys, there's one more gimmick fight. At least, this dragon thing wasn't as bad, but still not my cup of tea. Reminds me of the Rykard fight. Suffice it to say, not a fan of either.
Wow, Ashina is burning! Here, FromSoft turned up the volume and the sword fights are amazing. At this point, I can just tell by the sound of the sword clashes when I should stop attacking and begin parrying. So, while not easy per se, I made it through the areas with little trouble.
I thought I found Ishin, but it was the Demon thing. Ah, this fight reminded me of the ER/BMW type fights. Just dodge & jump, remain close, and spam R1. 3 phases are a little different, but only took me around 5 tries to figure it out? This one was like Messmer, just beat it with reflex and reactions. I think this is the first fight I actually found the prosthetic toolkit useful. The upgraded umbrella and whistle helped immensely, so not sure if I cheesed it. Without a doubt, absent those strategies, I think it would've taken me longer.
This fight took 30 min? For me, the Owl Father was much harder and way more fun. This one was kind of like "been there, done that" feeling.
Ok, I think I know where Ishin must be. There's only one more area. So, maybe I'll try to take him on tomorrow.
PS - Ok, just beat Ishiin, the Sword Saint. For me, this was not that hard--under 10 tries and about 45 min? Phase 1 was a cakewalk, just Genichiro. Phase 2, just learn to counter some of his set moves, which was pretty basic, at this point of the game. Phase 3 took some getting used to on his spear, but not too bad. Phase 4, ah, just return lightning and hedge with the eel liver thing.
Conclusion - For me, The Owl Father was the true "git gud" fight of the game.
So, deciding between a new play through or NG+.