One night werewolf SECOND and ONLY day

[Charmonium]

Post #1 of this thread...

Damn, I did notice that but for some reason didn't make the association. I know that doesn't make any sense, just trust me.

I'm going to hide for the rest of this thread.

 

[Chiropteran]

You don't want to do that, you will see why later.

 

[PenguinPower]

Damn, I did notice that but for some reason didn't make the association. I know that doesn't make any sense, just trust me.

I'm going to hide for the rest of this thread.

Yeah. That was a pretty big blunder, especially since there are 9 roles listed up there. Six of us and three in the middle and not a single one is a vanillager.

 

[glenn1]

Shhh.... be wevvvry quiet, I'm hunting wabbits wolves. Hehehehe

 

[Chiropteran]

Charmonium - unknown, probably some evil role
Chiropteran - troublemaker
PenguinPower - seer
ElFenix - unknown
Krazy4Real - unknown
glenn1 - hunter
center - insomniac, mason, unknown

Remaining- mason, werewolf, werewolf, tanner

My guess is charmonium is the tanner, which would lead to him making an obvious fakeclaim in the hopes of getting caught and lynch to win.

ElFenix and Krazy could both be werewolves if the third center card is the other mason, or one is a mason and the other is a werewolf.

 

[Chiropteran]

I guess I should just reveal my hand:

I swapped Krazy & penguin. Krazy, if you were the werewolf we can just lynch penguin and win easily. If not, at least you can confirm and that narrows down the pool of suspects.

 

[Krazy4Real]

Wow... troublemaker can be extremely powerful if used correctly.

I was a werewolf, and now I am a seer (penguin's old role). Everyone should vote for Penguin (who is now a wolf).

Sorry buddy.

 

[glenn1]

Wow... troublemaker can be extremely powerful if used correctly.

I was a werewolf, and now I am a seer (penguin's old role). Everyone should vote for Penguin (who is now a wolf).

Sorry buddy.

If true then you can confirm the identity of the other wolf also.

 

[Krazy4Real]

If true then you can confirm the identity of the other wolf also.

That's irrelevant. I'm a villager now. What do I benefit by lying?

 

[glenn1]

That's irrelevant. I'm a villager now. What do I benefit by lying?

Why is it irrelevant? It's extremely relevant and there's absolutely no reason for you to withhold the information.

 

[PenguinPower]

That's irrelevant. I'm a villager now. What do I benefit by lying?

Because both you and Chiro could be wolves and the swap never really happened. We really need to hear from ElFenix about what his role is, and we need to hear from you about who the other wolf is.

Why would you be hesitant to provide it unless the swap didn't actually happen?

I'm guessing that you and Chiro are wolves, Char is the tanner, and ElFenix is actually the Troublemaker or Mason. Nice play.

 

[Krazy4Real]

There is no way except for the troublemaker to know if a swap happened. If your cards are swapped, you are not given any indication of it actually happening.

 

[PenguinPower]

There is no way except for the troublemaker to know if a swap happened. If your cards are swapped, you are not given any indication of it actually happening.

That's an understood. Still doesn't make sense for you not to share the other wolf. That's what leads me to believe that, as far as you and Chiro are aware, you are both still wolves and you're shifting the focus to someone else in an attempt to win.

It's possible that the third card is the Troublemaker and no one can swap card.

 

[Chiropteran]

I am the troublemaker, but I was lying. I just wanted to find out Krazy4Real's role, since it was probably evil.

Vote krazy4real and town wins.

 

[Krazy4Real]

That works. Vote for Krazy.

 

[PenguinPower]

Waiting for ElFenix before voting

 

[glenn1]

I am the troublemaker, but I was lying. I just wanted to find out Krazy4Real's role, since it was probably evil.

Vote krazy4real and town wins.

Then who did you actually switch?

 

[Chiropteran]

Then who did you actually switch?

I switched PenguinPower and Charmonium, but since I am guessing Charmonium was the tanner even if he shares his role it doesn't directly help us win.

 

[Dr. Zaus]

Official Final-Votes are open!

 

[Chiropteran]

Remember, vote krazy4real!

 

[Dr. Zaus]

Krazy4Real, the

Spoiler

WOLF

is dead

 

[Chiropteran]

Wow... troublemaker can be extremely powerful if used correctly.

I agree.

Makes me feel a bit dirty using it like that.

Fun game though!

 

[Chiropteran]

One last fear I had was that town could still lose even knowing Krazy4Real's role.

If tanner self votes and the two wolves voted for the tanner, out of spite, that would be a 3-3 vote. I guess that would mean both voted players are lynched, the tanner would get lynched and win and everyone else loses. But that would take some coordination from the wolves and ultimately doesn't actually help them "win", it just lets them stick it to town out of spite.

 

[Charmonium]

Yea!!! Looking forward to doing a better job in the next game. Although we were a little light in terms of players this time around.

 

[Dr. Zaus]

I'm going to put the game (my running it at least) on hiatus until July 5th. I think that'll let people get back in.

If someone else runs it I'll participate; but sometimes It's good to take a break.