The NCAAs penalties were unprecedented for several reasons.
-- The infractions in question were not related to a competitive advantage. Sandusky had left the program years before.
Reggie Bush had left USC several years before the NCAA went after them. And this isn't the first time the NCAA punished a school for past deeds. Certainly not unprecedented re: PSU
-- They resulted from a criminal case. The NCAA interpreted its constitution to conclude that Penn State violated the constitution's "fundamental values" clause. NCAA has always been funny with its "fundamental values." They do this with players receiving money from whomever or wherever. These "fundamental values" from the NCAA tend to mean whatever they want them to mean. I agree that it is generally bullshit, but no reason to play if off this case as if it is unique.
-- Players who had nothing to do with case were penalized. In a famous show of faith, senior Mike Mauti and several other players pledged loyalty to the program two days after the penalties were announced. Sucks for the players, but this is part of why the punishment must be so severe. Responsible adults in charge of these "student athlete's" career at major universities need to realize how their actions affect everyone in their care. Honestly--no sympathy. This is all part of setting precedent
-- Players were allowed to transfer immediately, setting off a set of unintended consequences. Players complained of coaches from interested schools lurking in the parking lot outside the football facility. Seems to offset the above point, doesn't it? The NCAA, then, really wasn't punishing these students. Seems that, in a show of mercy, they were given a free out. Complaints of lurking by other schools? lol, give me a break. Either way, above point and this point run completely counter to each other. Only one is arguable
-- Penn State was not a repeat offender of NCAA bylaws, which automatically triggers the possibility of a death penalty. In fact, Penn State had been one of two schools to win national championships in the wire service era (since 1936) never to commit a major violation in football. BYU is the other.You know why they say about "Never to have __?" Such statements are only true until they no longer are true. Everything before, will never matter again. Fact is, they committed the most egregious violation of trust within the college sports community. This is the most significant violation that any committee--NCAA or college school board has ever seen. Any history before? seriously--so what? Considering how long this went on, what the hell was going on before that we didn't know about?No, I don't think it's all that worthwhile to speculate about that...well, until someone tries to bring up now-meaningless history about they were "so innocent" before. OK, well, not that it matters anymore, but let's think about it...were they?