<< Both did it but gourds have it on their Gogitchyershinebox, shinebox, and all the labour albums.
Phish on crazy train >>
PHISH has NEVER played Gin and Juice in public or any CD they released. Therefore, there is no known version of this song to exist. The crazy train album you listed is not a PHISH show, nor are any of the songs listed PHISH songs. Must be mis-labeled or complete BS.