Originally posted by: OdiN
If you printed both of those images, mine would look better.
I work at a professional photo lab and I just printed both images. In yours, the dog looks a
bit better due to the increased saturation, but the overall saturation of the entire photo blows away any kind of detail in the whole image. Everyone that I've asked that's working with me prefers the first Photoshop edit.
I think both images are great, but the first edit with a +1 or +2 on saturation look spectacular out of the printer. Heavy sharpening on the dog's tongue looks pretty gross when printed, so the softer image is preferred to my eyes.
As always from a photographer's standpoint, sharpening, saturation, and overall color balance (cold, warm, b & w) is a very personal preference and is always left in the eye of the beholder.
~Travis