Its one of these what do need more, your arm or your leg questions.
The piano... it's just so much more versatile.
However, if you purpose is to learn enough to get laid, then the guitar.
The guitar is a portable douche version of the piano.
In all seriousness, this is like arguing chocolate vs vanilla.
I'm changing my vote to harp harptallic baby!
http://www.harptallica.com/
I'm changing my vote to harp harptallic baby!
http://www.harptallica.com/
The guitar is a portable douche version of the piano.
In all seriousness, this is like arguing chocolate vs vanilla.
Musically, in my opinion, the piano is far superior. Even the best classical guitarists can't touch a piano... you can only do so well plucking strings.
I don't see how the guitar is less versatile. Technique changes style, as does post processing effects and even tuning. You also have much different sound in acoustic vs. electric. Then of course you even have bass guitars.
I'm not saying pianos AREN'T versatile, but I think the gap is much closer than you're claiming (and IMO slightly favors guitar, but there's bias involved there).
Nobody ever got laid playing piano.
Not true! The last recital I did got me laid :biggrin:
And figure I should mention I'm not biased by my instrument. I only play violin (play being generous), but I'd really like to pick up both piano and bass guitar later on in life.