(POLL) Carmello Anthony or Lebron James for rookie of the year?

[trmiv]

They will likely be co rookie of the year

 

[boyRacer]

Mello deserves it... that other guy... bleh.

 

[Zeeky Boogy Doog]

who is carmello anthony? why bother with basketball? i dont get it...

 

[boyRacer]

Originally posted by: PsychoticIdiot
who is carmello anthony? why bother with basketball? i dont get it...

nice sig.

 

[trmiv]

Originally posted by: PsychoticIdiot
who is carmello anthony? why bother with basketball? i dont get it...

who is PsychoticIdiot? why bother with this thread? i dont get it...

 

[tfinch2]

carmello made the playoffs in the WEST. question answered

 

[machintos]

Mello and Bron should play one on one. Whoever wins gets ROTY.

 

[GhettoFob]

I vote Carmello but I think either Lebron will get it or they'll be co rookies of the year.

 

[skim milk]

melo

 

[Imdmn04]

Melo has an attitude problem. You just don't pull a Scottie Pippen in your rookie year. James is younger but a lot more mature than Melo, and a lot more humble than Melo.
So I'm gonna have to go with James.

 

[suklee]

bron

 

[SuperGroove]

Originally posted by: nitsuj3580

Originally posted by: nitsuj3580

Originally posted by: jooksing
Melo should win based on how much better the Nuggets are this year, but it's probably gonna be co-winners. Anybody remember who the last co winners were?

Grant Hill and Jason Kidd

I'm really hoping Melo gets his props from the media. The Cavs got rid of all the bad eggs getting rid of Davis, etc to make it LeBron's team. Melo has had to put up with Andre Miller who thinks he's a superstar and is too stubborn to recognize that it's Melo's team.

EDIT: Oops...didn't mean to do two posts. Must've hit Quote instead of Edit

To Everyone:
it's CarmeLo Anthony, not Carmello.

Anyways, regardless of what you think, Andre Miller has made the nuggets better.

 

[dethman]

Originally posted by: SuperGroove

Originally posted by: nitsuj3580

Originally posted by: nitsuj3580

Originally posted by: jooksing
Melo should win based on how much better the Nuggets are this year, but it's probably gonna be co-winners. Anybody remember who the last co winners were?

Grant Hill and Jason Kidd

I'm really hoping Melo gets his props from the media. The Cavs got rid of all the bad eggs getting rid of Davis, etc to make it LeBron's team. Melo has had to put up with Andre Miller who thinks he's a superstar and is too stubborn to recognize that it's Melo's team.

EDIT: Oops...didn't mean to do two posts. Must've hit Quote instead of Edit

To Everyone:
it's CarmeLo Anthony, not Carmello.

Anyways, regardless of what you think, Andre Miller has made the nuggets better.

every time someone puts carmello i think of caramello candy.

 

[new2AMD]

Anthony gets my vote mostly cuz im a 'cuse fan and saw him play live a bunch last year and he got Boeheim his first well deserved title. He also gets it cuz im a Blazer fan and I watched him in the last minute of the game down 2 (twice) carry the team to overtime befroe finishing them off to basically eliminate the Blazers from the playoffs.

 

[iamme]

melo because his team made the playoffs.

but, it's so close that i wouldn't be surprised if Lebron won.

 

[Saulbadguy]

Bron Bron.

 

[Emrys]

Originally posted by: Imdmn04
Melo has an attitude problem. You just don't pull a Scottie Pippen in your rookie year. James is younger but a lot more mature than Melo, and a lot more humble than Melo.
So I'm gonna have to go with James.

Sure... and LaBron doesn't? Who was the one complaining when they were a back-up for the allstar game because someone else was better than them. LaBron is the one with the attitude problem and on an ego trip.

 

[iamme]

Originally posted by: Emrys

Originally posted by: Imdmn04
Melo has an attitude problem. You just don't pull a Scottie Pippen in your rookie year. James is younger but a lot more mature than Melo, and a lot more humble than Melo.
So I'm gonna have to go with James.

Sure... and LaBron doesn't? Who was the one complaining when they were a back-up for the allstar game because someone else was better than them. LaBron is the one with the attitude problem and on an ego trip.

don't forget Melo's comment about how he thought he should have made it over Kirilenko.

 

[Emrys]

Originally posted by: iamme

Originally posted by: Emrys

Originally posted by: Imdmn04
Melo has an attitude problem. You just don't pull a Scottie Pippen in your rookie year. James is younger but a lot more mature than Melo, and a lot more humble than Melo.
So I'm gonna have to go with James.

Sure... and LaBron doesn't? Who was the one complaining when they were a back-up for the allstar game because someone else was better than them. LaBron is the one with the attitude problem and on an ego trip.

don't forget Melo's comment about how he thought he should have made it over Kirilenko.

Maybe so, but he didn't have to be forced to go to the game if I remember correctly.

 

[boyRacer]

well guess who won it... surprise surprise... :frown:

 

[suklee]

Originally posted by: bR
well guess who won it... surprise surprise... :frown:

http://sports.espn.go.com/nba/news/story?id=1786166

 

[CtK]

LJ had much more hype, pressure and he lived up to it
so it should goto LJ
or at least shared ROTY

 

[boyRacer]

co-rookie of the year wouldve been better IMHO

 

[kyparrish]

i think Lebron deserved it