Another update. I ended up getting another after all, deal was too good to pass up. I did some looking at other stores online, found some in Moreno Valley, about 40 miles away. I called and spoke to someone who confirmed they had 4, but they were listed at $119.20. Drove out there with the picture of the price online, was told they don't match that, since its online its different price wise, nothing I haven't heard before from other companies. What the guy said he would do and what I had to do was buy it at $119, then go to the store that has it at $59.60 to either get the difference back, or return it then buy it at the lower price.
I agreed I would do that, if it didn't work out I would just return it for a full refund, he ended up not making me do that and gave me the proper price I was seeing, but like other have said, different stores have them priced differently. This one I got has a newer charger, a soft case over a hard case and it wasn't a used unit, so in the end I got what I wanted at the price of $59.60, plus tax. Both batteries seem to be fine, proper packaging etc also.