apparently nobody read this, so i'll post it again:
listen, this topic has been beaten to DEATH! i've been browsing anandtech and the ng's for a long time now, and EVERYhard drive discussion goes like this:
"I'll never buy a <<Insert name here>> again, it died on me after XXX days! I'm only sticking with <<Insert name here>>. I've never had a problem with them."
THAT'S JUST THE WAY IT IS!! so buy Quantum, buy WD, buy Maxtor, buy IBM, it don't matter. Go for $$ per meg and performance. End of story.