Skeptical about the reboot, but we'll see.
Someone needs to do another series like BSG. God that show was amazing until it went completely bananas in the last season.
The weirdness starts at the end of season 1. If you didn't realize you were in for some weird stuff in the S1 finale, you weren't paying close enough attention. Let's not forget that Head Six flat out tells Baltar that she's an angel in S2. Most people didn't take that line seriously and thought the finale was surprising or something. Little stuff like that. I actually didn't pick up on that line until the 2nd time I watched it. The show is much more consistent if you watch it from the right perspective, which most that disliked the end did not. But, even the 2nd time around, I realized how they keep beating the drum of mythology, religion, spirituality, prophecy, etc. from the very start. I also particularly liked that they didn't explain everything in the show. Weird things happen, and you don't know any more than the confused, human characters do. Some things never get a hard explanation without necessarily feeling like they just trailed off.
Awww, you gotta be kidding me... I'm halfway through season 3. Damn it son...
Just remember that it's not actually a science fiction...it's a drama that talks more about god(s), mythology, religion, angels, etc. than science stuff (which, in many ways, the mythology IS real). Again, if you didn't pick up on that late S1 and throughout S2, you missed the point.
I personally loved how strange and epic things got in the end, yet at the same time very human, and it only gets better the more times you watch it (you can pick up on elements you missed earlier, and everything makes a lot more sense). S1 was boring, I thought, right up until the end. You'll see most people that didn't like how the show turned out tend to really like S1.