I'm using the 212 with 2 aftermarket fans, and it's great. Idle temps are 35, load is 59 on the hottest core. You really can't beat that unless you spend $50 more. Make sure though that you don't put too much thermal paste on, what I did was to smear a tiny amount on each of the copper pipes, then a tity on the center of the CPU. I prolly used less than 1/2 of the size of a pea in paste, and I'm getting much better temps than most people with this cooler. Plus, the dual fans really do help.
But ya, get the 212.