alexthebored
Junior Member
- Nov 4, 2007
- 12
- 0
- 0
Ridiculous. The average price of the Viewsonic VX2435WM in Canada is $720, and practically no stores have it.
Originally posted by: Overon
Thanks for your advice. I just realized that the hp w2207 has a tiny 1 year warranty. While the viewsonic VX2255wmb has a 3 year warranty. Now I'm leaning toward the viewsonic. I saw both of them at circuit city. As usual, instead of making the monitors look their best, they both had vga connectors connected to them via a splitter box. And what's worse is that both of them were not on their native resolution 1610x1080 but some lower resolution display.
Originally posted by: xtknight
Originally posted by: Ursidave
Thank you for this very informative thread. I am an amateur photographer, just making the switch to digital. My primary use for the monitor will be photo editing, using Photoshop CS3, mostly to prepare digital slide shows, and occasionally some printing. Secondary uses will be video editing, web surfing, and word processing. I am looking at 20" and 21", preferably widescreen for more efficient Photoshop usage. I prefer not to spend more than $700, but might be willing to pay more if necessary to get much higher performance. I have come up with a few models that fit my criteria, but they all seem to have limited availability: Dell 2007WFP, Samsung 215TW, and NEC 20WMGX2. If I have to go 4:3 instead, I might consider the HP LP2065 or Dell 2007FP. Would the NEC LCD2190UXp provide far superior performance compared to the HP and Dell?
To be honest with you, the NEC LCD2190UXp is definitely worth it if you're doing photography.
The 2007WFP/215TW/20WMGX2 continue to have limited availability (or panel lotteries). And the 2007FP and LP2065 have the panel lotteries as well.
I assume the reason you do not recommend the 2007WFP is the panel lottery, but I notice X-Bit favors it, particularly for photo work, and they don't even list the 20WMGX2 in their recent Buyer's Guide. It's tough to choose between the 215TW and 20WMGX2 - some pro reviewers prefer one, some the other. I don't think reflections would be a problem for me on the glossy screen of the 20WMGX2. One thing that put me off the 215TW, when I was researching it more than a year ago, was a problem reported by several users on New Egg, in which a vertical colored line (yellow, red, or blue) appeared permanently on the screen. At that time, I went to look at one in a local store, and saw the same phenomenon on the unit on display - a very noticeable thin blue line from the top to the bottom of the screen. I am surprised I have not found any comments about this defect in my recent research.
I think your biggest problem is finding one of these panels in stock.
The 20WMGX2 is better in most cases because of a tighter gamma curve and more stable viewing angle. But the 215TW is still suitable, certainly. The screen coating really does not have a whole lot to do with its photo editing performance.
215TW color perf.: http://www.xbitlabs.com/articl...ay/20-21inch-3_10.html
20WMGX2 color perf.: http://www.xbitlabs.com/articl...ay/20-21inch-2_15.html
The 20WMGX2 requires little gamma correction, meaning it is accurate by default and it can retain a good number of colors even after calibration. The case is not as good for the 215TW. It will have to lose many color tones before it looks calibrated, and it will end up being not as detailed. In addition, the VA panel means the center plane will lack gray detail and the image may shift at wider angles. Such is not the case with the 20WMGX2.
Assuming I am able to find the models listed above, which one(s) would you recommend for me, in order of preference? As I mentioned, I would prefer widescreen, but image quality is more important. Are there any other models I should consider? Thanks in advance for any advice you can provide.
1. NEC LCD2190UXp
2. NEC 20WMGX2
3. Samsung 215TW
4. HP LP2065
5. Dell 2007WFP
6. Dell 2007FP
The VA panels in the Dells may be 6-bit.
The LCD2190 uses a VA panel but it at least has very good color setup and everything. Plus it was designed with photography in mind.
Originally posted by: Overon
xtnight, thanks for your help. I did some further research and price searching and I finally went to circuit city and bought a viewsonic vx2255wmb. $329.99 plus 6% sales tax resulted in a price that was about $10 higher than the cheapest place I could find online after a rebate and shipping costs were factored in. $10 bucks is okay to get the monitor right away and if I found some problem with it, I could go back and exchange it for the same model and thus that $10 difference is justified. Circuit city had hp w2207 and hp w2007 and vx2255wmb in stock. The hp w2207 was the same price as the viewsonic vx2255wmb l but the hp's had a 1 year manufacturer warranty on the hp is unacceptable when viewsonic has 3 manufacturer warranty.
Now since I did all this research (research I have been doing on and off on various other sites before I first posted in this thread), I might as well make things as good as they can be. Let me first ask about color space.
This vx2255wmb has the following settings:
sRGB, 9300K, 7500K, 6500K, 5400K and a user controlled adjustment. What should I set?
I thought if I used the sRGB it would be good, but in this mode it locks out brightness and contrast adjustment. It sets the brightness to 100% and it's like looking at a bright light constantly. Too damn bright. So I can't use the sRGB preset.
I am currently using the 9300K preset because that's supposed to approximate normal day sunlight. However, I can't shake the feeling that I should be using the user controlled color adjustment settings. How do I go about actually configuring those to the right values?
I went to viewsonic's website and downloaded the "driver" for this monitor. I noticed that after installing it, it put in some color management profile after installing this "driver" in the windows color management tab. What exactly does this profile do and should I use it?
Finally I read about gamma all over the web. I read about mathematical formulas etc and things I do not understand very well. All I want to do is set these gamma, brightness, contrast, color space values so that my image looks as good as possible without buying colorometers. How do I accomplish this?
Originally posted by: ClockHound
Mallomar, LCD2690WUXi-SV in stock here for $1,359.33 CDN
http://www.tddirect.ca/product...ITORS/LCD2690WUXIBKSV/
Or here for $1,364.53 CDN with free shipping in Canada.
http://www.agileelectronics.ca...rod_id=LCD2690WUXIBKSV
From his post at the TFTcentral forum, xtknight, did not get the SV version. I'm still jealous tho. My new and now obsolete 241W hasn't even arrived and I already have acute pixel envy.
Originally posted by: Mallomar
I've got questions!
Did you get the LCD2690WUXi or the LCD2690WUXi-SV?
I have my heart set on the SV model, but can't find it in stock anywhere (at least not at an attractive price). And I have spent hours trolling the web, looking for it. I ordered it a couple of weeks ago from one of the resellers on NEC's list, but as of today they still couldn't give me even a tentative delivery date (plus they had dropped the price by $100 on their web page, but I'd still have to pay the previous higher price), so I cancelled the order. I would have been able to live with paying the extra hundred smackers if they had told me the monitor had already shipped and it was too late to cancel, but they had no idea when the order was going to be filled.
I did find one reseller that claims to have the SV model in stock, but the price is a couple of hundred bucks higher. (Even higher than the "street price" shown on the NEC site!)
I suppose I could buy the non-SV model (assuming I could find one in stock) and buy a separate calibration device, but I'd really prefer to get the SV-equipped model. I seem to remember there was some technological advantage (something to do with the LUT?) to getting the built-in SV thang.
One thing I'm a little foggy on -- if you buy the SV model, do you still have to pay extra for software?
Originally posted by: Ursidave
Thanks for the information. I am leaning toward the LCD2190UXp at this point. Considering that 20-21" is a popular size in monitors, and that the widescreen format is becoming very popular, and that so many people are doing digital photography these days, I find it astonishing and very frustrating that there is not a single LCD monitor currently in production at any price that ideally matches these criteria. All four of the models that previously had these characteristics - VX2025wm, 2007WFP, 20WMGX2, and 215TW - have been, or are in the process of being, discontinued. What are these manufacturers thinking?! So we are forced to go down to 19" or up to 24", or to use 4:3 instead of the more convenient and efficient 16:10 format, or to make a major compromise in image quality with the restricted viewing angles of TN panels.
I considered the 24" size, even though I would find it difficult if not impossible to fit such a monstrosity on my small desk. However, apart from the footprint issue, I have another concern specifically about the NEC LCD2490WUXi. It is my understanding that the panel in that monitor is the same one used in 24" iMacs. I saw an article on THG about the problems with defective displays that some owners of iMacs have been reporting over the past few months, on both the 20" and 24" models. Apple and its resellers have been refusing to acknowledge these problems as defects. It involves gradient color change across the display, and backlight leakage. Have you heard of any problems like this on the 2490WUXi, or do you think it is most likely limited to iMacs? I would hate to spend over $1,000 on a monitor, and then find it has a defect that neither the manufacturer nor the seller will acknowledge.
Originally posted by: Butterbean
Just in case people are interested in Dell 3008 (I am sorta) a chinese site has pics of it online. Specs they publish on last page has it as a S-IPS and with the anti-glare (moans).
First link is to page 1
http://www.pcpop.com/doc/0/255/255288.shtml
Says S-IPS on this last page:
http://product.pcpop.com/000074557/Index.html