Originally posted by: DoctorM
Anyone ever try the HP Pavilion w2408h?
It's a TN 24" but prad.de gushed about it in their review.
I only see the non-h version in the U.S., I don't know if it is only an HDMI connector difference or something more.
Originally posted by: DoctorM
I'm scratching my head why the HP looked good.
Maybe after staring at all those TN panels my eyes were fried.
Btw muggeh. You sound like you're somewhere in Europe. You should take a look at the Belinea 2485 S1W.
http://www.prad.de/en/monitore...-belinea-2485-s1w.html
Seems like you couldn't go wrong with it. After reading the review I wish I could find one on this side of the pond.
Originally posted by: DoctorM
I'm scratching my head why the HP looked good.
Maybe after staring at all those TN panels my eyes were fried.
Btw muggeh. You sound like you're somewhere in Europe. You should take a look at the Belinea 2485 S1W.
http://www.prad.de/en/monitore...-belinea-2485-s1w.html
Seems like you couldn't go wrong with it. After reading the review I wish I could find one on this side of the pond.
Originally posted by: GarfieldtheCat
@xtknight:
First off, thanks for taking time to answer my questions (and all the questions in this thread!).
Luckily, I've just upgraded my PC (passing my parts to my wife's PC) with a Q6600 @3.4GHz and a OC'd 8800GT. So SupCom and Dawn of War should run OK.
As a proud new owner of a bouncing baby Nikon D300, and who is just getting into editing/touching-up my photos (currently using Capture NX, might try out Lightroom and maybe CS3), I am a bit confused as to the whole "wide gamut" problems. I have searched over at dpreivew, and it seems several people don't like the "HC" displays, because Windows isn't colorspace aware, so you get one color in photo programs like CS3 or CNX, and another color when viewing in IE or other programs.
The 3007 (and it appears the 305T does as well) doesn't have any hardware calibration options, but it could be done in video driver, with a spyder or Eye one I mean, correct?
Since you have a "wide gamut" NEC, how do you handle the color calibration problem? Some people have commented to avoid all HC type displays for photo editing. Is this overkill on their part?
EDIT: My worry is that if I use a WC monitor, and edit my photos in CNX, they will look correct when I view then in CNX. But as soon as I email them to friends/family (who will be using regular non-HC non-calibrated monitors), they will look wrong.
Thanks!
Originally posted by: DoctorM
The LP2065 can use either an AMVA or S-IPS panel (a lot have been S-IPS actually). But if you're willing to get this the VX24 is a better idea as it's probably a better VA panel.
To be clear, with the LP2065 you win the lottery if you get the S-IPS, but if you end up with the AMVA it's not as good as the VX2435WM's panel?
Also how is the Viewsonic for gaming (he asked as his CRT monitor continued to slowly shrink in height...)?
Edit: Does anyone know how NewEgg and TechOnWeb are for returns?
From what I've read NewEgg seems distinctly unfriendly about returns.
I've dealt with ToW before (not an LCD) and they really seemed determined to be helpful.
Originally posted by: redlinez33
Well I have the HP W2207 and have played a few games now, and I notice a few things. First it has backlight bleeding around the edges of the screen. Is this normal for a TN panel? or should I return to get a new one? It also has a dead pixel right in the middle.
Otherwise its a pretty good monitor. Image quality isnt as good as my samsung 971P but its much better for games. I love the size. Right now I wouldnt consider myself happy with this monitor, but its not BAD..... I am thinking of either returning it for another w2207, or returning it for a viewsonic 22" or samsung 22".......
xtknight (or anyone else with experience) what would you recommend? Is backlight bleeding around the edges normal for TN panels????
Originally posted by: Mallomar
Nope, I didn't cancel my order for the 2490 -- buy.com did it for me.
I'm one of the people who ordered it for $825 when buy.com was flipping the prices back and forth a couple of weeks ago. I waited a week, during which I heard nothing, then got an e-mail telling me the item was out of stock and they were canceling my order. I bought mine from the buy.com eBay store, but the same thing happened to several people who ordered it at the lower price from the web site. Buy.com still has the monitor listed (their eBay store claims to have dozens of them in stock), but they raised the price.
One person in another forum said he did receive the monitor he ordered at the $825 price. I guess he was just lucky. I'm very disappointed in buy.com -- never had a problem with any of my previous 14 transactions.
But I really wanted the 2690 anyway (I just ordered the 2490 on impulse because it was such a deal -- I was going to give it to my husband if I didn't like it), because I'm a graphic designer and frequently have to adjust photos in Photoshop. So I'm convinced that the wide-gamut 2690 is the monitor of my dreams. My current CRT is very good, but it's too small (21"). I'm so tired of moving palettes around so I can see what I'm working on!
I'll probably go ahead and order the 2690 SV from one of the US resellers next week. And then relax and wait several weeks to get it!
Originally posted by: DoctorM
Anyone ever try the HP Pavilion w2408h?
It's a TN 24" but prad.de gushed about it in their review.
I only see the non-h version in the U.S., I don't know if it is only an HDMI connector difference or something more.
Originally posted by: Trean
xtknight:
Found out that Viewsonic as a manufacturer offers a 30-day zero dead pixel guarantee. So that is good. Also found out that Office Depot carries viewsonic monitors; going to call them today and see if they carry the vx2435wm and if they do I will go check it out.
Through this limited warranty, you are guaranteed high-quality screen performance with no more than four (4) improperly operating pixels total and no more than three (3) bright or three (3) dark pixels.
I seem to be teetering back and forth between which I like better the BenQ or the Viewsonic. I hate making expensive decisions .
Originally posted by: muggeh
...
Since however reading this thread from start to finish(i deserve a beer i reckon) i consider myself more enlightend in this subject and have come to understand that the newer screens don't use that harsh coating anymore like they did 3 years ago.
My current options (i'm willing to spend some more seeing as i'm quite fussy about it) are:
Samung 275T 1050,-
Nec 2690Wuxi 1150,-
Originally posted by: DoctorM
I'm really stumped.
I WANT to get the vx2435wm, but the reviews aren't particularly glowing.
It just seems to be the best of whats out there... which I'm not sure is enough to justify the price.
To boot, it's response time for games is a bit too slow to be good.
And if not the 24" it looks like I have to settle for the VX2255wmb... and I just hate the really narrow viewing angle.
Is there anything in between at all? Anyone? Waaaah, I hate this!
Originally posted by: breckenridgej
After reading through all of these great messages, I think I am getting closer to a decision... But, I still have some questions. This is my criteria:
- Looking for a 21-27" LCD - I'm not particularly hung up on the size. I'm using a 19" so I think anything > 21" would be fine.
- Primary use is image editing (I'm critical, but not a purist) and will also use it for some occasional gaming, surfing and movie watching.
- Price limit is probably around <$1500
I think it comes to balancing color accuracy with speed and size. Although I would appreciate an s-video input, its not a deal breaker. Given the low price difference between the NEC LCD2490WUXI and others I am considering, I think it comes out at top. This is my short-list with Amazon prices:
1. NEC LCD2490WUXI $1130
2. Samsung 275T $1060
3. NEC LCD2190UXP $900
4. HP LP2465 $790
5. Samsung 245T $880
Does this list make sense, any others you would consider (or not consider) given these criteria? Will the NEC LCD2490WUXI be fast enough for occasional gaming and/or movies? I had initially included the NEC 20WMGX2 but its a bit small and virtually impossible to find. I also eliminated the Viewsonic VX2435WM because of negative comments I had read on the glossy finish being temperamental with cleaning/calibration. In terms of value both the HP LP2465 and Samsung 245T seem like they are well priced and its not clear to me how badly I need the color accuracy associated with the LCD2490WUXI.
Thoughts, comments very much appreciated.
Jordan
Originally posted by: DoctorM
VP2030b or the VX2435wm?
They seem fairly similar on the surface just 4:3 vs. 16:9... is there any real pros or cons between these?
Besides of course the fact VX24 offers more multimedia inputs.
Originally posted by: xtknight
Originally posted by: muggeh
...
Since however reading this thread from start to finish(i deserve a beer i reckon) i consider myself more enlightend in this subject and have come to understand that the newer screens don't use that harsh coating anymore like they did 3 years ago.
My current options (i'm willing to spend some more seeing as i'm quite fussy about it) are:
Samung 275T 1050,-
Nec 2690Wuxi 1150,-
AFAIK this is my understanding of it also (my VP930b seems to have a harsher coating, though).
As for 275T vs 2690...what are your usage patterns mostly?
I am a tad disappointed in the 2690's contrast (but not surprised). So if you want a monitor for multimedia primarily you might consider the 275T. The 2690 is great for this still though and I have little evidence the 275T can produce a better image other than that fact it's a VA panel which would help in the contrast area.
Originally posted by: xtknight
Rest assured the color management/ICC stuff is all very complex and confusing to me too. I never found it explained in terms I could understand. I believe Windows, at least XP, is entirely based on RGB(r,g,b) or ARGB (alpha+RGB) and nothing else like Lab. So as far as I can tell, unless the application specifically implements color management features, there's no reason there would be any compensation. Which apps do implement color management features? I was under the impression only Photoshop or other image editors (maybe The GIMP) did.