Originally posted by: dawgies
Originally posted by: Afrd2shtstrngerS
First of all thank you xtknight; you built a very informative thread here. After skimming this thread, I have couple of questions and I am all open to your suggestions.
I have to echo this comment as well as that of other posters. You've done a remarkable job of creating an informative thread. I've spent quite a bit of time trying to read through as many posts as possible.
Thanks, I have to say most of the time I really enjoy answering questions as well.
I currently have a Dell Ultrasharp 1905FP with the Samsung panel. No dead pixels, no banding, nice color....good monitor. The only time I'm aware of issues is when I order prints of photos and they look somewhat different than what I'm seeing on my monitor. I do not game. Most important is text quality/no eye strain. I'm just getting into photography and had read that IPS panels are better for digital editing. I'd like a larger landscape, but don't want to change if I'm not significantly improving over the quality I have now. Is calibration as important on VA panels as IPS?
It's usually more important on VA panels because IPS panels tend to come better calibrated from the factory. That's totally a 'tendency' thing and nothing to do with the actual alignment of the crystals (the "VA/IPS" mode).
Am considering:
1) Doublesight DS-263N or 263W
2) HP LP2465
3) Doublesight DS-243W
I'd appreciate input on these options. Thanks!
You are doing print matching, so I would look for a wide gamut monitor. Only the first DS-263N and DS-265W will satisfy this. That's also the only monitor that satisfies being an IPS panel. So I think your choice is made here.
You could consider getting a colorimeter, but the DoubleSight comes pretty good default too. The colorimeter might make details a little more visible or something already too conspicuous a little less visible, but it's not going to make a world of difference. Assuming you are already using a decent white point (6500K, probably not far off from factory), the calibration will not really help you match prints. The wide gamut on the other hand will, and you will want to make sure you are not in the monitor's sRGB mode for doing that.
I would recommend the IPS panel in this case even if you are doing photo editing because you can still use the ICM provided on the CD to allow you to edit in the sRGB space. (In no circumstances do you want to select 'sRGB' from the monitor's menu, however, because the monitor's emulation is not as sophisticated as the software's).