- Jun 26, 2006
- 10,769
- 52
- 91
I turn 21 in a couple of months so I'll be buying my first handgun awe
Right now I'm trying to decide between these two (other suggestions are welcome as well). It'll just be a range toy and backup home defense.
S&W M&P in 9mm, 4" barrel
or
S&W 686+ (7 round) in .357 magnum, 4" barrel
Here's how I see it:
M&P 9
-More capacity (10+1 in CA)
-Lighter by about half
-Slightly smaller
-Cheaper gun by about $200, slightly cheaper ammo (compared to .38special)
-More tacti-cool, could add a light on the rail under the barrel
686
-More effective against two legged animals with .357 loads
-Less recoil than the 9mm with .38specials
-My grandpa has about 500 rounds of .38 special he said he'd give me for free (he doesn't shoot them, he thinks shooting full power .357's out of his snubnose revolver is fun D
-It says MAGNUM on the side of it which makes chicks wet amirite?
-Probably has a better trigger than the M&P
So what does ATOT think?
Update: Bought the M&P and joined the legions of the Semi-automatic master race.
Right now I'm trying to decide between these two (other suggestions are welcome as well). It'll just be a range toy and backup home defense.
S&W M&P in 9mm, 4" barrel
or
S&W 686+ (7 round) in .357 magnum, 4" barrel
Here's how I see it:
M&P 9
-More capacity (10+1 in CA)
-Lighter by about half
-Slightly smaller
-Cheaper gun by about $200, slightly cheaper ammo (compared to .38special)
-More tacti-cool, could add a light on the rail under the barrel
686
-More effective against two legged animals with .357 loads
-Less recoil than the 9mm with .38specials
-My grandpa has about 500 rounds of .38 special he said he'd give me for free (he doesn't shoot them, he thinks shooting full power .357's out of his snubnose revolver is fun D
-It says MAGNUM on the side of it which makes chicks wet amirite?
-Probably has a better trigger than the M&P
So what does ATOT think?
Update: Bought the M&P and joined the legions of the Semi-automatic master race.
Last edited: