Originally posted by: Darwin333
Originally posted by: Harvey
Originally posted by: xj0hnx
They should do away with the term "marriage" in a legal sense. The term "marriage" should only apply to the religious ceremony. The state should then only recognize civil unions. Civil unions should be applicable to gay, straight, biracial people etc. Current marriages could be grandfathered in or simply relabeled as civil unions.
I would hope that should end the "gay marriage" debate.
That would be meaningless. You can't legislate the contemporary use of language, and changing the name of the same actions is a meaningless jack off... or jill off in the case of lesbians.
How would it be meaningless? We aren't talking about legislating the contemporary use of the language this is about getting the government out of religion. Marriage is a religious sacrament and therefor the government has no business allowing or denying access. Both straights and gays would enter into some sort of civil union or whatever they come up with, no separate but equal anything. What you and your spouse do in church is between yall and the church.
I am actually quite shocked about how many people here are dead set on using the word marriage instead of another term being applied across the board. I know a ton of gay folk and none of them give half a shit about the word marriage. They just want to be treated equally and most realize that it will be a LOOONG time before the federal government legislates that gays be allowed to get "married". There are simply to many religious districts that will vote out any rep who voted for it and reps care far more about their jobs than any of us. On the other hand, leaving marriage up to the churches and the government using civil unions for everyone is actually becoming more politically feasible everyday. Hell, once the economy settles down a bit, with the right leadership I think its quite possible to get it passed today (well, maybe after the 2010 elections, doubt Obama would touch it till his 2nd term though).
Are there actually any gay folk here that disagree with removing marriage from the government and everyone being treated equally with civil unions?