Greetings! I'm getting ready to tackle some automation and I've read through this thread, as well as the sister thread for Wink. I'm willing to do some hard-core DIY, but I'd rather not. Wink and Smartthings speak to me, but so much for their simplicity, but because I would like to see the volume, and hence, mass-market pricing, for the peripherals. Can't complain about $60-100 for a controller; but $45 for every node? Ouch!
I'm surprised by the lack of mass-market products for window coverings. Besides basic lighting, I would expect to see a lot of demand for automated blinds/shades/etc. Seems to me that Somfy has an effective, if short-term, monopoly and are using RTS protocols to keep the market ($300+ for a Z-wave to RTS interpreter???) to themselves. Anybody see it differently?
More like $60 for every node (outlets, wall switches, etc.). The market is still fairly niche. Eventually when it catches on, it will get cheaper, but it will take years - even with Home Depot behind Wink, pushing them forward. The IPv6 modification of Zigbee called "Thread" looks the most promising to me, but we'll see how it plays out.
Yup, Somfy is pretty much the name of the game. You can buy them through various blinds dealers, such as Bali, but if you want reliability, they seem to be the way to go. For me, most of this stuff is "gee whiz, it'd be nice to do X or Y", but is it $200 nice for a wireless deadbolt or $300 nice for a motorized blind? That, plus none of this stuff is 100% reliable. Having had the Wink up for a week or two, I can definitely tell you it is not as reliable as plain old regular switches. But it's neat & offers some power-saving options, so there's that!
Right now, I think home automation is mostly for enthusiasts & wealthy people. In 5 or 10 years, it will be the norm, especially with companies like Apple pushing HomeKit, Home Depot pushing Wink, Samsung pushing Smart Things, and lots of big initiatives being corralled together. They just need to make it cheap & reliable!