Ichinisan
Lifer
- Oct 9, 2002
- 28,298
- 1,234
- 136
Because it wasn't an outright "broken" issue - it was a bug that effected certain keyboard drivers or specific ICs in the keyboards or the combo of the system's USB driver + the keyboard driver... etc etc etc.
Thus why many reported no problems, while others reported problems.
For the longest while, I didn't have to worry about it on Windows 8 and Windows 8.1 with my Razer Blackwidow Ultimate Stealth. Then after a complete format and a fresh install of 8.1, it stopped working correctly until I found that registry fix.
No idea if it'll remain fixed in Windows 10, or if the fix will be removed and it will work.. or it won't work for whatever reason.
I was fairly certain the behavior was intentional.
The reasoning:
Condensed keyboards (especially laptops) have the numpad keys over-layed on the normal keyboard keys. If you didn't know your numlock key was accidentally turned-on, and you typed your normal password, you might get it wrong repeatedly until you're locked-out of your PC / workstation. WinXP defaulted to an off state, but remembered the state you left it in.
I just wish there was a normal GUI option on the login screen to set the default state. Still, someone will forget and connect a condensed keyboard, and businesses will have disasters as important people get locked-out of their PCs. Yeah, it's such an obscure problem, even an IT admin type could get screwed by it.