SherEPunjab
Diamond Member
- Oct 23, 2002
- 3,841
- 0
- 0
Originally posted by: BaliBabyDoc
Vouchers are not the solution but they would have value in communities with excess capacity at good public (or private) schools. Alas, you will not find a single study demonstrating such excess capacity exists at good schools. Granted, voucher proponents rarely bother with such details. Poor administrators should be fired (there's no hope for them). But you cannot just shutter public schools b/c there's no place for those children to go. School systems have to find new adminstrators, train ALL their teachers better, and fire the non-productive ones . . . not to mention learning to ignore the dumbarses on local and state school boards.
As for complaining about the costs of more school, more healthcare, etc. How many prisons has CA built since 1980? How many new colleges or universities? Which form of higher education makes sense to you? You cannot divest the various elements of social support systems. It's akin to having a powerful military but poor military intelligence or having a wonderful Constitution but few in government actually follow it. Strong systems of social support are as close as any nation can get to equal opportunity . . . it's up to the individual to do something with those opportunities.
Unless you plan to regulate childbirth (admittedly, I'm open to the suggestion) then there's no choice but to choose between investment in their success or paying for their future failure. Many will fail to become productive members of society but on balance it's still cheaper than paying for chronic, preventable health conditions, indirect costs of crime, and direct cost of the criminal justice system.
Excess Capacity is merely one part of the problem. Inadequate, irresponsible, and careless teachers are another part. Outdated facilities, books, and curriculums are another. Standard, boiler plate academics is another (as opposed to invididualized approaches many private schools take, which challenges each student at their appropriate level, instead of naively thinking that all students are at the same level and teaching them together like public schools do.) btw, from my observations, good school districts and excess capacities are connected. If you have a good public school district, people flock there. Go ask any real estate broker. Excess capacity occurs, and then high ratios.
Having vouchers and empowering parents will drive competition between private schools and public schools -- which is a good thing. No teacher, whether they be a private, or public school teacher should feel that they are irreplaceable or untouchable. if they do, they have no motivation to perform well.