Star Wars>Star Trek

[PatboyX]

star wars new episodes are crappy.
star wars old ones are fun and fluffy with a happy amount of pop-philosophy and harrison ford.
star trek old ones are campy and goofy.
movies are too few and far between a good moment.
new star trek is lame and, while supposedly more "intellectually developed" than star wars is fine provided you only like to get half-way to an interesting thought before deus ex machina-ing your way out and ending with some lamoid "captains log"
bottom line:
they both are now just vehicles to make money.
but star wars makes better video games (and more, so it might not be fair)
f-it. Kotor makes up for all the garbage.

 

[GamingGuy246]

Originally posted by: Riceball

The ion cannon aboard a Klingon vessel is no way meant to disable or what not, its just a big phaser thats short ranged and has a lot more killing power all in one blast. Even if the SW weaponry would be able to penetrate the shielding on an ST vessel, ST would still win, I read on some website where they had two fanboys arguing about it on a webpage, not a forum, but an actual dialogue, and basically listed the power dispensed when attacking and it was conceded by both fanboys as they used evidence from the books to determine that a Galaxy class Federation vessel firing one of its phasers is equivalent to a SW star destroyer firing all of its 1800+ turbolasers and everything else at once.

So obviously even if SW had a snowballs chance in hell of destroying an ST vessel, the sheer killing power of a Federation vessel is far superior than any ship the Empire or Rebel Alliance possess.

Sorry if I don't your word on it but link?

I read up on this site quite awhile ago, and do not have a link for it because I cannot find it, I've googled everything I can think of and the only conclusion I can come to is that the site may no longer be up or the argument is no longer there, I read the above stated, I'd say 2-3 years ago, so I'd be suprised to find the same argument anywhere, but I will continue my search and try to find it nevertheless.

edit

not the site but makes good points on both sides, but I still believe ST all the way.

http://angel.scientium.com/surveys/st_sw/stsw.htm

 

[MegaWorks]

Trek>Wars

 

[Riceball]

I read up on this site quite awhile ago, and do not have a link for it because I cannot find it, I've googled everything I can think of and the only conclusion I can come to is that the site may no longer be up or the argument is no longer there, I read the above stated, I'd say 2-3 years ago, so I'd be suprised to find the same argument anywhere, but I will continue my search and try to find it nevertheless.

edit

not the site but makes good points on both sides, but I still believe ST all the way.

http://angel.scientium.com/surveys/st_sw/stsw.htm

I still hold the view that SW has sufficient advantages and disadvantage that are not so great to prevent SW from prevailing. We'll just have to agree to disagree.

 

[sweeper2]

star wars for the movies.... star trek for the tv shows and movies....

 

[GamingGuy246]

Originally posted by: Riceball

I read up on this site quite awhile ago, and do not have a link for it because I cannot find it, I've googled everything I can think of and the only conclusion I can come to is that the site may no longer be up or the argument is no longer there, I read the above stated, I'd say 2-3 years ago, so I'd be suprised to find the same argument anywhere, but I will continue my search and try to find it nevertheless.

edit

not the site but makes good points on both sides, but I still believe ST all the way.

http://angel.scientium.com/surveys/st_sw/stsw.htm

I still hold the view that SW has sufficient advantages and disadvantage that are not so great to prevent SW from prevailing. We'll just have to agree to disagree.

Totally, don't get me wrong I love Star Wars, its just that if I had to choose a side thats technically more advanced and just a reality I'd rather live in, I'd go Star Trek. Same goes for this reality, I couldn't say "forget this" to this reality fast enough if I had a chance at going into the realm of Star Trek. May sound geeky, but its just too great a chance to pass up.

 

[Siddhartha]

Star Wars is better visually more interesting
Star Wars has Darth Vader

Star Trek has better stories, plots, on the whole actors.

 

[DurocShark]

Originally posted by: SelArom
WHERE IS BABYLON 5?!!

Babylon 5 > TNG > star wars (old trilogy) > poop in a shoe > star wars (new trilogy)

I know there's like 125 posts between this one and the end, but...

:thumbsup:

Farscape should be in there between Ep 4-6 and poop in a shoe.

 

[Koing]

Originally posted by: NFS4
Trek > Wars

 

[ohtwell]

I think Star Trek is better.


: ) Amanda

 

[CrowBarr]

Definately Trek...Star Wars was, at one, time the greatest...but come on....

 

[meltdown75]

Data > c3p0

 

[IAteYourMother]

ST sucks
SW rules in the first 3, but the new episodes suck

 

[meltdown75]

oh yeah and

Enterprise > *

 

[ZDStout]

Definately Trek. Voyager and the first 3 seasons of enterprise may have sucked, but then there's TNG and DS9, which introduced the Borg and the Dominion. How can you not go wrong with them?

 

[SirPappy]

Originally posted by: ZDStout
Definately Trek. Voyager and the first 3 seasons of enterprise may have sucked, but then there's TNG and DS9, which introduced the Borg and the Dominion. How can you not go wrong with them?

Simple, just look at the poll.

Star Wars 4,5,6 > anything else

 

[TwiceOver]

I had to go with trek. Mainly because there is more to work with there.

 

[SirPappy]

i like trek, but thats it. i just like it, even with all those bad series and mediocer movies.

But STAR WARS, it gets my blood going! I get excited every time I see a new trailer for a new movie thats coming out!
mind you, eps 1 was weak, and eps 2 could have been a lot better, but 4,5,6 just owns all others out there. and eps 3 looks very promising.

heres hoping eps 3 will be a great way to finish the saga.

but SW will always own ST, and it seems most ppl agree according to the poll in this thread

 

[SirPappy]

P.S. dont mind all my spelling errors

 

[artikk]

star trek> star wars
star wars have crappy sequels
star trek is a golden oldie classic.

 

[SirPappy]

Originally posted by: russianpower
star trek> star wars
star wars have crappy sequels
star trek is a golden oldie classic.

ahhh, and the minority speaks out

SW>ST

the polls dont lie

 

[SirPappy]

oh, and i agree, eps1,and 2 were less than worthy, but I think eps 3 will be on par with eps 4,5, and 6