The acting and direction for this film are so far beyond anything in the prequels,(and even the originals) that this will never (fairly) get destructed like those steaming piles. Sure it's nostalgic, and repeats some theme's, and the overall story isn't perfect by any means, but of all the Star Wars movies, including the first and overly-coveted 2nd, it's far and away the best.
[anyone who reads through the beginning to the end of this post will see that I actually like this flick, but my criticism is heavily featured up front]
the acting and writing is certainly better overall, for sure (primarily because Mark Hamill never opened his mouth). Directing is on-par with Empire.
You underrate that one, methinks, and I'm not sure why; especially compared to this one. They are all "bad" for their own reasons, especially episode IV, but when judging simply among Star Wars films, I don't see how this one generally surpasses the trilogy, certainly not by far (OK--writing and directing for episode IV; but at least that was the first version of this plot, and it had a real, effing terrifying collection of villains. Peter Cushing, for one, gets far less credit than he deserves.). As bad as episode IV was, there were some goddamn brilliant moments that can't be denied--primarily related to Vader.
None of the baddies in this terrify me, as they all seem like caricatures of what came before. The New Order scenes were also overly-digitized primary-colored palates of cliched Nazi summer camps. In the trilogy, the Emperials commanded a certain gravitas of charm and menace. In TFA, the New Order main "angry-face dude in a funny hat" was simply snarling too hard most of the time, and with no effect on anyone watching. You can't honestly think that this portrayal was better than the combo of Vader-Tarkin or Vader-Piett or Vader-Emperor?
Those guys in the original trilogy were true hardcore Nazi fucks--these New Order fellows with their pre-pubescent sith wannabe were more like Il Duce's version of fascismo and his thugs' preferred public shaming via laxative overdosing. Please...
The nostalgia...I felt it was good at parts and also quite unsettling in a way? How best to explain it. Seeing Han and Chewie at first brought a quick tear, but then it honestly felt a bit tedious--It was like sitting painfully through Indy 4 when I just wanted it all to stop; somethings you can never un-see. Let's not get into the pointless video game scene: monsters on Han's smuggling frigate. Too much PTSD re: the uselessly identical droid factory scene in Attack of the Clones.
Of course, I like seeing Han and Chewie back, but it all just seemed completely out of place, or simply there as motivation for something else (Abram's argument that "Well, we want to give a reason for Han to be here rather than just love story with Leia--so we made him the primary motivation for his son's evilness--He must be killed!"). So, well, there really isn't speculation there: his role was explicitly written into the script as a meatbag prop. That kinda sucks, for Han. A lot of me went into this movie ecstatic to see Han and the rest, but you realize early on that this story is moving on without them, and they are pretty much dragging the whole thing down (I like Oscar Isaacs--but this character looks way too dull so far--all of the brashness and confidence of the real Solo, none of the cynical scoundrel. A true one-note cypher. I hope he is improved-upon).
Finn...again, not enough character here, yet. He just seemed, I dunno...too excited and childlike to me? Is that a thing--is he supposed to be a teenager?
I loved Rey, though. As Luke Skywalker with boobs, she did a fantastic job. The real nostalgia for me, and probably my favorite part of the film--true geeky tearjerker--was when she snapped on Vader/Luke's lightsaber for the first time. That was badass. She is absolutely the best part of the series since the original trilogy.
The lightsaber battles were superb. Far better than anything before (I still like Luke vs Vader in Jedi: the brash rage of it all), but everything about the prequels was a dizzying mess of circus performers obviously playing around in a green-colored gym.
This film is
gorgeous, and simply the shots of Rey scavenging on Jakku are worth the price of admission, imo. It is the best part of nostalgia re: comparisons to episode IV. It is not, overall, a digital monstrosity (despite the glaring issues with the New Order), and no quick-cut "elbow shots" ala Nolan or Bay when it comes to action.
As mentioned earlier, I hope this gets a nice DC with better pacing for characters and a bit more background. I don't mind being tossed into the middle of a very active world sometimes--but this one very much feels like a a bunch of semi-connected stuff tossed together as a setup for what follows.
I think Luke really should have been the main focus--ending the way they did, feels more like a desperate attempt to
avoid ending on yet another blown-up death star.
I can't say I am truly disappointed with this--history with this franchise being what it is, and especially having already seen an already too-old Ford in a hamfisted version of a beloved franchise, I kinda knew what that would be--but I would have preferred less of a safe Disney vehicle and more of something like when Star Wars actually did challenge conventions, whether or not you want to admit it, with Empire. But anyone knows that would be asking too much.
I'm glad that we get a new director for the next episode. Not because I thought Abrams was bad here (I thought he was solid), but because we get a chance for a new vision. It worked wonders for the original trilogy.