I've PMed the original email address to you. I've also sent the password reset or hint or whatever it is to that email. (Forgive me, it's the first time I've used that piece of the vBulletin software, so I don't know exactly what it's doing.) Hopefully, that's sufficient for you to be able to log on under your old account. I'm leaving this account activated for now so you can communicate any other problems you're having retrieving your old account. Once you can successfully log in, just let us know & we'll close the "2" account.
-DrPizza