Originally posted by: Michael
alkemyst - I took direct hits to the throat and head. How hard do you think SCA swords hit? Much harder than an unarmed strike. Throats are well protected.
You're also nuts in what you think about helmets. They took repeated, direct blows in combat. They're also designed to deflect blows and any semi-decent fighter knows how to roll with a shots so it skips off.
I've swung real swords (with a real tang) against helmets. I was able to dent the helmets, but none failed. I also have been hit hard enough to have the helmet I was wearing get dented but it had almost no effect on me. Armor is multi-layered and spreads impact well. Hammers and maces concentrate the blow into one place. If the angle is right, it can limit the amount the blow is spread and that results in broken ribs. The head is generally a lousy place to aim. I would aim at a gap in the collar bone area, the armpits, and the groin area. Those areas are usually much less armored as it is hard to cover with plate.
Throwing a rock at me will do almost nothing when I'm in armor. Best case - I block my vision with my shield and you "pounce" closer and attack a joint. Shield technique is designe dto keep vision open, so that's risky.
I'm curious - do you have real life experience to back up your claims or is this from comic books and movies? I've actually fought against people who are much, much better than me, so I know that there are gaps that are huge between different people and their skill levels.
Michael
I have watch the SCA battles, I am aware the strikes are hard, saying they are harder than all unarmed strikes I don't know about that. You know just as a sword can pierce and break bones so can trained hands....a sword will strike harder most of the time....
I have real life evidence just based on the fact take a motorcycle helmet....rider is dead due to brain hemmorahge, helmet nice and shiny still.
If you look into any book, study of armor with real weapons you will find a helmet was not designed to ever withstand a direct blow and allow the wearer to be unharmed...it was to save his life. You saying any semi-trained fighter knows to roll off blows....that pointless...sometimes what you know and what you can do are two different things....otherwise noone would ever win a battle unless the opponent was clueless.
I don't base anything on comics or movies or any type of fiction. However, I know biology, I know weaponry, I know combat and I know that no matter what you encase your head in the weaklink will be your neck and also the impact the brain can withstand.
My debate had nothing to do with other weak points of armor...I would need to know the type and how it was worn....with helmets I can speak in general. Let a friend take a 5-10lb mallet and strike you in the side of the head full force wearing your helmet....I will guarantee if the hit was 'real' you will be unconscious or dead. Heck take the best helmet you can find and do this test.