My local Tesla store got some Y's in & I was able to go in for a test-drive this week. Review time!
Note: don't conflate negatives with the car being
bad. I don't look at
any products with rose-colored glasses; I like to go in knowing what the upsides & downsides are. Anyway, I was able to take out the PUP (AWD Performance Upgraded) Model Y on a 30-minute test ride. Initial thoughts:
Positive:
* The 21" Uber Turbines look WAY better IRL than they do in pictures. I didn't like how they looked in photos at all, but they're great in person & do not look oversized!
* The PUP with the 21" wheels rides FAR better than my Mustang with lots of rubber on 18" wheels. It's still sporty, but I think the weight of the battery helps smooth out the ride.
* Definitely more interior room than the 3. The 3 feels like a bobsled or a coffin, just kind of straight on both sides. The Y is kind of curved on the door side, so you have more room for your legs. Not as comfy as an X, but definitely more roomy for big & tall people than the 3. Not as comfortable as my Mustang, but lightyears better of a fit for my legs than my wife's Forester. I did have to adjust my leg positioning a little bit because of the center console height, but it wasn't a dealbreaker. I'd put the fit into the neutral category below, actually.
* The seats are amazeballs. Just sooooo comfy. They're the 3's seats, but with the added height.
* Built-in wireless phone charging is a really nice feature.
* This feels like the right car "for the people". Kind of a be-all, do-all vehicle. It's a bit like Goldilocks...the 3 is a bit too small, the X & S are a bit too big, and this one is "just right".
* The Performance's zero to 60 is bananas. I laughed every time I punched it. Snaps your neck right back in the seat. It's stupid fast. 3.5 seconds in a hatchback is hilariously fun!
* One-pedal driving is still really great & easy to get used to.
* Feels like driving a video game car. Really smooth, really easy, really zoomy fast. Just feels super clean & easy to drive.
Neutral:
* WAY smaller than expected! (on the outside) It looks like an X in pictures, but it doesn't feel anywhere near the size of an X at all. The X is way roomier inside. On the plus side, seems like it would be a great city car because it's not as big as the X or S.
* This is nothing like the Model X. It does not have the helicopter-cockpit effect at all. The front roof bar is pretty huge. In the front seat, you don't really appreciate the overhead glass ceiling.
* The interior gets pretty warm with the giant glass roof. It was also a bit bright with the sun overhead, even with the tint. I wish it had SmartTint or something to block it. I don't think I'd want to own this car if I lived in like, Arizona. And tbh, you don't really get the overhead glass effect very much while driving because it's directly over your head. I wouldn't mind a solid roof & a sunroof/moonroof.
* The 20" Gemini wheels actually look a bit smaller in-person. They did have the color combo I like (gray paint + 20" black wheels), but someone else was test-driving it & they were pretty booked, so I didn't get a chance to test-drive it to compare the ride quality between the Performance & PUP models. Side note, the blue is gorgeous on the Y, and the midnight metallic grey has blue flecks in the sun! Very nice. Not a big fan of the solid red on the Y...although it looks amazing on the 3.
* The screen looks surprisingly small in the larger Y, as opposed to the 3.
* They said the upcoming 7-seater version will have rear-facing seats, not forward-facing seats for the third row in the back. I'd be curious to see that in person before locking into the 5-seater.
* The hatchback is actually a lot smaller than I expected. Not tiny, but the photos made it look pretty huge. It felt deeper than our Forester, but not nearly as tall because of the hatchbox slope. Nice deep well when you lift up the back floor flap tho.
* It's not a particularly
sexy car. The 3 is pretty good-looking, especially in red. The Y is nice-looking, but it's kind of like a futuristic, bloated Nissan Versa lol. On the flip side, it's crazy practical, size-wise.
* Steering wheel requires some effort, even in Comfort mode. I would have thought it would have been easier to turn. It was less easy than our Subaru, oddly enough.
* Autopilot is...pretty iffy. tbh I think I like Subaru's EyeSight better, as I can pretty much rely on it 100% to do its specific jobs. Sometimes Autopilot felt like wrestling a toddler who was playing a driving video game. Per what
@Aikouka said previously, I think I'd probably end up driving it "manually" most of the time. If I were to get AP, it'd be for the long-term investment, I think. Love the idea, implementation is decent, but not as fantastic as they advertise, for sure.
* Apple's CarPlay is a really big deal for me. I have it in my current ICE vehicle & love love love it. I wish that Tesla had a screen pane for Carplay & Android Auto. I almost want to put this in the negative group. I usually spend 60 to 120 minutes daily in my car (pre-COVID) & having the apps & integration readily available was really nice. Felt like I was missing features in the Tesla OS.
Negative:
* The A/C fan was pretty noisy outside of the car.
* The A/C inside is surprisingly noisy. You don't realize how much the engine noise masks the other sounds of the car. I didn't find the road noise to be too bad. The road noise is noisier than the 3 with the A/C off. The Y's A/C noise isn't like, crazy loud, but it is kind of in-your-face, surprisingly. With the A/C up (it was almost 90F outside & super humid), I really had to crank the stereo up, and it still felt like the A/C noise was winning lol.
* The rearview mirror & rear visibility is absolutely AWFUL. Worst I've ever seen in any car anywhere. Granted, the windows were decent & the autopilot did a good job of showing cartoons of the cars around you, and you could turn on the rearview camera while driving, but just for spatial awareness...terrible lol. Just really really bad. Tiny rearview mirror & virtually useless rear window.
* The turning radius blows. Our Subaru Forester is 17.4' and the Y is 19.9' Doesn't sound like much, but we tried to do a U-turn & had to pull into a parking lot instead.
* No holy-crap handles. Annoying.
* The seam on the steering wheel feels awful. It's a large, protruding, itchy seam. I don't know why it doesn't feel nice & tucked in like pretty much every other car. Weird. It doesn't feel good on the fingers at all!
* The floor buzzed sometimes. I don't know what it was. It felt like motor buzz. Like a vibration. Wasn't sure if it was when we went over certain road features or was from the motor or what. It was very odd.
Overall:
* Pretty much what I expected. The surprise was how the wheels looked IRL, and how dang FAST the 3.5s Performance model was! This is a great car!
* A few glaring negatives, but nothing dealing-breaking. The most surprisingly was the
horrific rear visibility. The steering wheel seam was annoying & the A/C will take some getting used to. Nothing that can't be worked past, however.
* Fully-loaded with everything, taxes included, it runs $79k delivered in my state. Yowza. The base X with 351 miles starts at $75k, and the base S with 391 miles is $70k. If you're looking for a fully-loaded model, those are some interesting price dynamics to check out.
* I really really REALLY want a Cybertruck lol.