Discussion The Incel issue and ways to fix them.

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

whm1974

Diamond Member
Jul 24, 2016
9,460
1,570
96
Not just understand, but to solve too. West Virginia, you know what I am talking about
View attachment 10163
Don't they marry their close cousins and half siblings over there? What is the Age of Consent and Marriage in that State, 10, 12? Good God the more I read about West Virginia the more the State sounds like a damn Third World Country then part of the US.
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
72,679
6,195
126
Well you did assumed correctly that I do indeed have the good sense to thank those who have done things of value to me. But however I was merely advising you to be mindful of just assuming anything at all about people.
Well, let me caution you, then, that you make assumptions about people every day and you would be hard pressed to function if you didn't. Let me stress again, therefore, that the assumption I made that you thanked the person who linked the video, not for the act of linking it, but for the content it contained that you liked, is not just an "anything at all" assumption but a logical one. And you yet haven't said if you watched and what you think of what the video contained.

You made this claim also, that goes to the root of why I brought this matter up with you in the first place. "But I don't do any self loathing anyway at all." I simply wanted to advise you this was a seriously dangerous assumption you make. The mere fact that in post after post where I bring up this truth about people, the information triggers you to disagree or down vote what I have to say. Those are classic signs of a defensiveness that suggests the opposite is in fact true, that you do indeed hate yourself and hate being told it. Not a good idea in my opinion because you deny what is true but only true of what you feel, not of something really wrong with you.

An important step on the road to better mental health, in my opinion, is to know the truth of where you are because only then will there be any motivation to change. Hello, I am Moonbeam and I hate myself...................
 

whm1974

Diamond Member
Jul 24, 2016
9,460
1,570
96
Well, let me caution you, then, that you make assumptions about people every day and you would be hard pressed to function if you didn't. Let me stress again, therefore, that the assumption I made that you thanked the person who linked the video, not for the act of linking it, but for the content it contained that you liked, is not just an "anything at all" assumption but a logical one. And you yet haven't said if you watched and what you think of what the video contained.

You made this claim also, that goes to the root of why I brought this matter up with you in the first place. "But I don't do any self loathing anyway at all." I simply wanted to advise you this was a seriously dangerous assumption you make. The mere fact that in post after post where I bring up this truth about people, the information triggers you to disagree or down vote what I have to say. Those are classic signs of a defensiveness that suggests the opposite is in fact true, that you do indeed hate yourself and hate being told it. Not a good idea in my opinion because you deny what is true but only true of what you feel, not of something really wrong with you.

An important step on the road to better mental health, in my opinion, is to know the truth of where you are because only then will there be any motivation to change. Hello, I am Moonbeam and I hate myself...................
Since you do actually hate yourself you can't help assuming that everybody else also hates themselves as well. While in Reality the fact is very people actually do!
Self hatred isn't formed in a complete vacuum, far from it. It is caused by the actions and failures of those that resulted in great harm to others. And since I have not done any major injuries to other folks I have no cause to hate myself or feel large amounts of guilt.

All the major Religions encouraged followers to have self-hatred and guilt simply for being alive as a Human Being.
 

Blackjack200

Lifer
May 28, 2007
15,995
1,685
126
Since you do actually hate yourself you can't help assuming that everybody else also hates themselves as well. While in Reality the fact is very people actually do!
Self hatred isn't formed in a complete vacuum, far from it. It is caused by the actions and failures of those that resulted in great harm to others. And since I have not done any major injuries to other folks I have no cause to hate myself or feel large amounts of guilt.

All the major Religions encouraged followers to have self-hatred and guilt simply for being alive as a Human Being.

Not assuming. Observing.
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
72,679
6,195
126
Since you do actually hate yourself you can't help assuming that everybody else also hates themselves as well. While in Reality the fact is very people actually do!
Self hatred isn't formed in a complete vacuum, far from it. It is caused by the actions and failures of those that resulted in great harm to others. And since I have not done any major injuries to other folks I have no cause to hate myself or feel large amounts of guilt.

All the major Religions encouraged followers to have self-hatred and guilt simply for being alive as a Human Being.
Look, you're not the first person whose gone wonky at my suggestion we hate ourselves. I have been saying this from the time I first posted here. I also remember my own opinions about the notion the first time I was introduced to it. I also remember, vividly like I remember little else, the first time having turned myself to such a self-exploration via therapy, I let go and fell deep into my own inner reality. I remember well saying to myself over and over and over again, to my utter amazement, I had no idea. I had no idea that kind of hurt lay deep within me. I simply was overcome by amazement that such pain could actually have been hidden within me.

Later, deeper than sadness, when I got into the rage, when the feelings got close to what I really felt, memory kicked in and I knew what the hurt was about. I knew the event well enough in my memory but that memory had been completely cut off from the pain, and that this emotion and that event could be tied together, was again something I just couldn't have ever before believed. I can't also tell you how feeling the grief that lay behind that rage proved tremendous emotional relief. I went from self bruising rage to laughter.

So I know that what we really feel at an unconscious level is not just profoundly shocking but healing to experience and I am and have been on both sides of that. I know that admitting to, letting go, permitting one to get in touch with oneself is not only difficult to do, but is difficult for two reasons. We don't know how to do it consciously, and we don't ever ever what to. Pain hurts. But relief is sweet.

So, in my opinion and in the opinion, I think of the person who first helped me with this, all the misery in the world is tied up with the fact that we hate ourselves, don't know it, don't want to know it, and don't want to know we don't want to know. We are at arms length, behind a massively armored wall, to feelings we actually feel and which therefore are our actual inner reality, that are nothing but lies. What we really feel, the reality of it, is completely false and because we won't allow ourselves to know what it is, we suffer from it.

So, please, I know that what you hear in my words you unconsciously feel is a threat. Been there and done that. What I want to do is simply tell anyone who will listen there is a way out. We are trapped in an invisible prison, a catch 22. The thing that we fear, that we are the worst in the world isn't real. I want to tell your conscious mind that if you can't maintain your denial for some life event reason, do not fear. The door to heaven is accessed through hell. There is nothing really wrong with you. I just happen to know that better than you do, of course, in my opinion. Do with this what you will.
 

SMOGZINN

Lifer
Jun 17, 2005
14,218
4,446
136
No Moonbeem is bare ass baselessly assuming that everyone has Self Hatred without any evidence.

It is his philosophy. He believes that self hate is the baseline human condition, and the cause of basically all our problems. It is in essence his word for evil, and we are all tainted by it from his version of original sin.
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
72,679
6,195
126
It is his philosophy. He believes that self hate is the baseline human condition, and the cause of basically all our problems. It is in essence his word for evil, and we are all tainted by it from his version of original sin.
Sort of: our original sin was to buy into the notion that sin exists. It’s but a step from there to call others evil and make them believe it. This splitting of the unity of reality into things by the language of naming caused us to become mired in the delusion of duality. Once there was only the non-reflective purity of being, the garden of eden if you will.

In all times in all places there has and will always arise some souls who will see this and reawaken into being. God speed to you. It collapses time and space.
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
72,679
6,195
126
No Moonbeem is bare ass baselessly assuming that everyone has Self Hatred without any evidence.
Go in peace. As you cautioned me let me caution you.........you may only assume you know what evidence is. But I only offer. Not my job to persuade you. I’ve given you what I can.
 

whm1974

Diamond Member
Jul 24, 2016
9,460
1,570
96
Go in peace. As you cautioned me let me caution you.........you may only assume you know what evidence is. But I only offer. Not my job to persuade you. I’ve given you what I can.
You had never even once presented evidence of everyone having self-hatred to begin with. You only dine to speak in riddles that makes little sense if any at all.
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
72,679
6,195
126
You had never even once presented evidence of everyone having self-hatred to begin with. You only dine to speak in riddles that makes little sense if any at all.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-hatred

https://www.psychalive.org/self-loathing/

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/...the-self-loathing-see-the-same-self-others-do

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/stuck/201307/self-loathing-the-ultimate-prejudice

Learn Ways to Stop Self-Hatred - Verywell Mind
https://www.verywellmind.com/ways-to-stop-self-hatred-4164280 Anonymous View
6 days ago ... You can't even get away from the relentless critic because it's you; self-hatred comes from within. But you can learn to stop self-loathing and ...

A Discussion of Self Hatred - MentalHelp.net
https://www.mentalhelp.net/depression/self-hatred/ Anonymous View
Theodore Isaac Rubin, MD and Psychoanalyst addressed this self dissatisfaction in a book entitled, Compassion and Self Hate. If you do not know who Dr.

Self-hatred | Psychology Wiki | FANDOM powered by Wikia
https://psychology.wikia.org/wiki/Self-hatred Anonymous View
Feb 7, 2007 ... "Ethnic self-hatred" is considered by some people as being a cultural issue, to which psychological theories have limited relevance.

11 Symptoms Of A Self-Loathing Mindset (+ How To Overcome It)
https://www.aconsciousrethink.com/6351/self-loathing-mindset/ Anonymous View
Aug 13, 2019 ... Self-loathing can manifest in all sorts of different ways. ... Similarly, emotional and psychological abuse as an adult can dismantle an .... have dug for themselves, and they'll freak out if anything threatens that, even in theory.

How to Tell If You're Self-Loathing and What to Do About It | HuffPost ...
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/how-to-tell-if-youre-self-loathing-and-what-to-do-about-it_b_6042452 Anonymous View
Oct 27, 2014 ... However, self-loathing isn't something that we are born with. As Anneli Rufus says in this Psychology Today article: "We aren't born with low ...

7 signs you have a self-loathing mindset (and 14 ways to overcome ...
https://hackspirit.com/7-signs-youre-self-loathing-and-dont-even-realize-it/ Anonymous View
Aug 24, 2018 ... Self-loathing refers to an extreme dislike or hatred of oneself. When it reaches that point, it can wreak havoc on your emotional and personal life ...

Self Hatred | WHY WE SUFFER
https://whywesuffer.com/tag/self-hatred/ Anonymous View
Oct 7, 2017 ... The principles of depth psychology reveal a possible motive. ... He was likely being assailed with pure self-rejection and self-hatred that emanated from ... Terrorists provide clear evidence for one of Sigmund Freud's theories.


And so on.

==================================

Perhaps you would like proof the earth isn't flat.

I learned all this from a man who was extremely successful and on top of the world, a psychologist, but he also discovered it was true of him too, much to his own amazement. I can't give you experience you have not had and the only way to know how true this is is to feel it yourself. I have.
 

DisarmedDespot

Senior member
Jun 2, 2016
589
588
136
<lots of irrelevant links>

==================================

Perhaps you would like proof the earth isn't flat.

I learned all this from a man who was extremely successful and on top of the world, a psychologist, but he also discovered it was true of him too, much to his own amazement. I can't give you experience you have not had and the only way to know how true this is is to feel it yourself. I have.
Moon, no one is saying self hatred doesn't exist, they're saying you need to prove it's as central to the human condition as you think it is. The burden of proof is on the one presenting the theory. Linking to random medical pages for dealing with self hatred doesn't actually support your argument. As-is, you're doing a terrible job of conveying your point.
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
72,679
6,195
126
Moon, no one is saying self hatred doesn't exist, they're saying you need to prove it's as central to the human condition as you think it is. The burden of proof is on the one presenting the theory. Linking to random medical pages for dealing with self hatred doesn't actually support your argument. As-is, you're doing a terrible job of conveying your point.
But self understanding can never work that way. Truth isn’t a formula or prescription. It isn’t a set of facts. It is a state of conscious awareness that is affirmed internally as a peak experience. You know it by taste. How would you know the beauty of the beloved if you weren’t in love. My aim isn’t to prove, it is to share. You will take from from that only what YOU can take. The only price I ask are your sacred cows in the form of your demanding assumptions. I can only pay that price for myself. I can’t pay it for you.
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
72,679
6,195
126
But self understanding can never work that way. Truth isn’t a formula or prescription. It isn’t a set of facts. It is a state of conscious awareness that is affirmed internally as a peak experience. You know it by taste. How would you know the beauty of the beloved if you weren’t in love. My aim isn’t to prove, it is to share. You will take from from that only what YOU can take. The only price I ask are your sacred cows in the form of your demanding assumptions. I can only pay that price for myself. I can’t pay it for you.

PS: with regard to your narrow point, not self hate exists, but does so universally, I wanted whm to be aware of that the notion has been established rather extensively in the psychological literature. It is in the observation and understanding of how it works in those obviously affected that one acquires the foundational basis for going deeper and seeing it in oneself. Horse goes before cart.
 

SMOGZINN

Lifer
Jun 17, 2005
14,218
4,446
136
Sort of: our original sin was to buy into the notion that sin exists. It’s but a step from there to call others evil and make them believe it.
Self defeating statement. Does sin exist or not? If it does, and we did it, then it is proper to find evil where it exists. If it does not exist, then we could not have done it, and it was not a sin and did not cause the problem, and evil must exist outside of it. Either way under this philosophy evil exists, and you are stating that it is noticing it that is the problem. That is actually really close to the Christian original sin story.


This splitting of the unity of reality into things by the language of naming caused us to become mired in the delusion of duality. Once there was only the non-reflective purity of being, the garden of eden if you will.

In all times in all places there has and will always arise some souls who will see this and reawaken into being. God speed to you. It collapses time and space.

Indeed, ignorance is bliss. Until reality comes crashing down on your head. Then it is nonstop pain and misery.
 

Moonbeam

Elite Member
Nov 24, 1999
72,679
6,195
126
SMOGZINN: Self defeating statement. Does sin exist or not? If it does, and we did it, then it is proper to find evil where it exists. If it does not exist, then we could not have done it, and it was not a sin and did not cause the problem, and evil must exist outside of it. Either way under this philosophy evil exists, and you are stating that it is noticing it that is the problem. That is actually really close to the Christian original sin story.

M: I am not sure whether by saying 'a self defeating statement' you are commenting on the paradox created by looking at what is in reality a unified state from a duality conscious frame or suggesting that what I said resolves nothing because of the questions you raised. If your intention was to suggest simply that what I described comes close to the Christian original sin story, I want to say I'm no expert is Christian theology and can offer only what I hear in the small notion of what I know of it:

For me, the Garden of Eden represents the pre-language human state, human life before the invention of language and the split in the self it created, and also the state in which each of us was born and formed conscious awareness before we were split by language as children. Except as yee be a little child you will not enter the kingdom of heaven enlightenment, realization, the collapse of unity, the return to our original state, and so on.

To eat the fruit of the tree of knowledge, to acquire the notion of good and evil, to know shame in the form of self loathing, that was what happened to us when we bit of the apple of the knowledge of good and evil.

All this to me is the result of thinking, the knowledge of the naming of things. Thought creates division, separation, comparison, things, and abstract ideas, and suffering. Words that form our thinking create and cause pain. We put ourselves and others down with them. Words are what we think in, how we divide and compare, how we create that which we create pleasure and pain. Our thoughts and self concept create ego, our beautiful self image that hides our necked shame. To compare is to create good and evil, to create duality, to separate the self from the oneness of all things, to close the door on the joy of being, to fall into sleep, repression, and hate.

S: Indeed, ignorance is bliss. Until reality comes crashing down on your head. Then it is nonstop pain and misery.

M: On the contrary, pain and misery are the result of not suffering. In suffering one becomes whole again. To suffer is to remember and awaken compassion for all sentient beings, to love again via the joy of being. One's true self can never be lost, it can only be hidden behind illusion, ego driven thinking.

From my point of view Jesus was a man who gave up his life so that we might suffer our own crucifixion and live again. I pity those who mock him. I think what Christianity gave me was that from an all knowing God I could not hide my shame, so I killed Him and that killed me.

The plaint of the reed in the flute is the longing for it's osier bed. A Sufi saying.
 

WackyDan

Diamond Member
Jan 26, 2004
4,794
68
91
The real problem here is that there are just as many awkward and lonely women, but they don't meet the standards of the incels. It is about entitlement more than anything else. They feel entitled not just to a girlfriend, but to a specific girlfriend. Sometimes it is a very specific girl that they have fixated on, other times it is just that they have impossibly high standards, or have no interest in the woman herself and want a fantasy version of a woman. In all of these cases the real problem is that they feel entitled to this, and will not accept anything else, and believe that they should not have to work for it because it is an entitlement. This attitude of entitlement practically guarantees that they can't get what they feel entitled to, because it colors their every interaction. This in turn just feeds their anger and makes their interactions even more awkward and creepy.

Uhm... You realize that women do the same thing right? They have some standards for men or young men too. Must be this tall, must have this type of job, drive this kind of car... Seen it all.

The difference is, women have far more free agency to sleep with whom they want. I can place any number of men and any number of women in a dive bar and I can assure you all the women regardless of anybody's standards can get some action that night. The men? Not so much.

I think the incel thing exploded because social media further eroded one or two generation's social skills to the point where you can become completely isolated from peer groups even though you attend the same school, etc. Who would have been socially awkward but still had a chance back in the 1980's now have no chance at all.
 

Maxima1

Diamond Member
Jan 15, 2013
3,522
759
146
I think the incel thing exploded because social media further eroded one or two generation's social skills to the point where you can become completely isolated from peer groups even though you attend the same school, etc. Who would have been socially awkward but still had a chance back in the 1980's now have no chance at all.

The two sexes with poor social skills should be comfortable with each other, right? I think with mass media, it's much easier to make comparisons with more affluent and beautiful people, while also increasing the materialistic mindset (doesn't help that income/wealth inequality keeps increasing). Women also have opportunity to be independent with careers, so they have much greater agency than prior generations and can be more picky about partners.

Japan I think is just further along.

https://www.cnn.com/2016/09/20/asia/japanese-millennials-virgins/index.html

"Men are making about a third to half of what they used to make during Japan's economic boom years in the 1980s. Some men's sense of self is tied to their salary and they feel threatened by women who are empowering themselves," said Snow.
She explained that the income decrease made men in Japan feel less confident in attracting Japan's increasingly successful class of women, who have become used to earning their own money and putting themselves first.
"While men are going from a cradle to grave trajectory, there are a lot of professional women with disposable incomes, who think that marriage might not just be worth it," said Snow.
 

SMOGZINN

Lifer
Jun 17, 2005
14,218
4,446
136
Uhm... You realize that women do the same thing right? They have some standards for men or young men too. Must be this tall, must have this type of job, drive this kind of car... Seen it all.

Yes, everyone has standards. The difference is that women tend to be less extreme in their standards, and more willing to compromise them. While a lot of men, especially the ones that trend towards incel type of thinking, have impossibly high beauty standards for women and truly believe that they 'can't get it up' for someone that does not fit their standards. How many times have we seen ridiculous things like men saying that a famous beauty has 'fat elbows' and that would be a deal breaker for them. The incels are the ones that take that into their real life. Add to that things like 'I would rather not have sex than use a condom' and other extreme attitudes surrounding sex and dating and it all but cripples their ability to match with someone.

The difference is, women have far more free agency to sleep with whom they want. I can place any number of men and any number of women in a dive bar and I can assure you all the women regardless of anybody's standards can get some action that night. The men? Not so much.

You are completely wrong about this, in several ways. First off you are basically looking at two different things. Hooking up for an evening is not really what we are talking about, but I'll address it as well.
Next, it is basically untrue if you hold them both to the same standards. I promise you that no matter how ugly and poor a troglodyte you are I can take you into a dive bar and end up with a hookup for the night at least 50% of the time. It is not that hard, if you don't have standards and are willing to be bold and approach women.

But this goes against the point you were just making, that women have standards too. Almost every women in my life complains about the same thing, all the good men are already taken. Most of them at some point or another go out looking for a good time, and most of them end up disappointed, the same as the men. There are a lot of reasons why, but it is worth noting that the main barrier that you have to cross to get women to go home with you is not looks or money, it is not coming across as dangerous or creepy. Something that so many men simply can't accomplish in a few hours at a bar.

I think the incel thing exploded because social media further eroded one or two generation's social skills to the point where you can become completely isolated from peer groups even though you attend the same school, etc. Who would have been socially awkward but still had a chance back in the 1980's now have no chance at all.

This is part of the problem, but it is worth remembering that this affected women as much as men. It might represent a bigger problem to the incel crowd because a large part of women's standards are social, not physical or economic and incels don't want to admit that their attitude and lack of social grace is the main barrier for them.
 

nakedfrog

No Lifer
Apr 3, 2001
58,521
12,816
136
This is part of the problem, but it is worth remembering that this affected women as much as men. It might represent a bigger problem to the incel crowd because a large part of women's standards are social, not physical or economic and incels don't want to admit that their attitude and lack of social grace is the main barrier for them.
Let us not forget the term "incel" itself was coined by a woman, to describe her own situation.
 

alcoholbob

Diamond Member
May 24, 2005
6,271
323
126
Yes, everyone has standards. The difference is that women tend to be less extreme in their standards, and more willing to compromise them. While a lot of men, especially the ones that trend towards incel type of thinking, have impossibly high beauty standards for women and truly believe that they 'can't get it up' for someone that does not fit their standards. How many times have we seen ridiculous things like men saying that a famous beauty has 'fat elbows' and that would be a deal breaker for them. The incels are the ones that take that into their real life.

The problem with your theory is all the studies from data we have from dating apps and agencies show that basically 70-80% women end up chasing 20-30% of the men which is just a standard Pareto distribution--the "good man" women talk about are simply the top 20% on a standard 80/20 Pareto curve. We also know men rate women on more or less a linear scale, whereas women rate 80% of men as "below average" on dating apps, again suggesting it's a highly Pareto distributed preference whereas men are a lot more open about dating down.

So women seem much much pickier than men because women largely date up heiarchies (like all female mammals do), men date across and down heirarchies (again, like all male mammals). Because female mammals focus on hierarchy as the highest order value when seeking a mate--due to millions of years of evolution of focusing on security for survival (as survival for the millions of years prior to the industrial revolution was largely a zero-sum game)--you end up heavily narrowing the number of potential mating candidates, hence a heavily declining marriage and birth rate in developed countries as women's status rise, there are less and less potential male mates.
 
Last edited:
sale-70-410-exam    | Exam-200-125-pdf    | we-sale-70-410-exam    | hot-sale-70-410-exam    | Latest-exam-700-603-Dumps    | Dumps-98-363-exams-date    | Certs-200-125-date    | Dumps-300-075-exams-date    | hot-sale-book-C8010-726-book    | Hot-Sale-200-310-Exam    | Exam-Description-200-310-dumps?    | hot-sale-book-200-125-book    | Latest-Updated-300-209-Exam    | Dumps-210-260-exams-date    | Download-200-125-Exam-PDF    | Exam-Description-300-101-dumps    | Certs-300-101-date    | Hot-Sale-300-075-Exam    | Latest-exam-200-125-Dumps    | Exam-Description-200-125-dumps    | Latest-Updated-300-075-Exam    | hot-sale-book-210-260-book    | Dumps-200-901-exams-date    | Certs-200-901-date    | Latest-exam-1Z0-062-Dumps    | Hot-Sale-1Z0-062-Exam    | Certs-CSSLP-date    | 100%-Pass-70-383-Exams    | Latest-JN0-360-real-exam-questions    | 100%-Pass-4A0-100-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-300-135-exams-date    | Passed-200-105-Tech-Exams    | Latest-Updated-200-310-Exam    | Download-300-070-Exam-PDF    | Hot-Sale-JN0-360-Exam    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Exams    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-JN0-360-exams-date    | Exam-Description-1Z0-876-dumps    | Latest-exam-1Z0-876-Dumps    | Dumps-HPE0-Y53-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-HPE0-Y53-Exam    | 100%-Pass-HPE0-Y53-Real-Exam-Questions    | Pass-4A0-100-Exam    | Latest-4A0-100-Questions    | Dumps-98-365-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-98-365-Exam    | 100%-Pass-VCS-254-Exams    | 2017-Latest-VCS-273-Exam    | Dumps-200-355-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-300-320-Exam    | Pass-300-101-Exam    | 100%-Pass-300-115-Exams    |
http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    | http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    |