chusteczka
Diamond Member
- Apr 12, 2006
- 3,399
- 3
- 71
Originally posted by: chusteczka
Originally posted by: Mallow
The Most Respectable Profession?
Mom
Originally posted by: DainBramaged
I'm voting teachers because no other professions tends to have such a strong desire to do something of value to society for so little freaking money.
Originally posted by: BigJelly
Originally posted by: DainBramaged
I'm voting teachers because no other professions tends to have such a strong desire to do something of value to society for so little freaking money.
Private school teacher; yes.
Public school teacher; HELL no.
What public school teachers "lack" in salary they make up in benefits.
1. Full pension: I'd be a lot richer if I didn't need to contribute to my 401k and roth IRA that they don't have to do thanks to the tax payers.
2. Retire by 55: It'd be nice to know that I could retire by 55 with their benefits in tack.
3. Medical: My company's plan is great (and I love it) but it doesn't hold a candle to what teachers get.
4. 3 months vacation: I'd love to be able to get 3 months of extra employment on top of my salary. Christmas break, spring break, and all the extra "holidays" (that no private businesses acknowledge).
5. Make one lesson plan and set for life: Yes some things change but as I recall German lost both WW1 and WW2, 2+2 still equals 4, etc.
6. Job security: Part of the reason our schools keep falling behind is that we can't fire the worthless teachers.
7. Extremely low stress job: Who here doesn't have stress at work? Then think how unstressful it would be to be a teacher. See 8 for low stress too.
8. 5-10 minute breaks between classes, plus lunch break, and 1 free class period Remember high school? Teachers didn't come to you, you wen to their class room. So between classes they get breaks. Teach 8 classes and get 5 minutes for students to get to class is 35 extra minutes plus a free class and you get 80 break minutes a day (not even including lunch break). How many people get 80 minutes of paid, non-lunch break time a day?
So given all that, tack this on their salary: at least 6k for medical, 8-10k for pension (do the math for being able to retire by 55 and never have to worry about running out). Then multiply by 4/3 because of their summer off. And then you realize "underpaid" teachers are really bringing in the money. Then factor in job security and low stress of their job and then try to give me this crap that they are underpaid.
Once again: private school teachers I agree with you 100%, but completely disagree with you when it comes to public school.
FYI I went to public school and had great teachers; not a rip on them just the bullsh!t argument that public school teachers are underpaid.
Originally posted by: Jadow
teacher is NOT a profession I respect. Most are grade-A morons
Originally posted by: FallenHero
Originally posted by: BigJelly
Originally posted by: DainBramaged
I'm voting teachers because no other professions tends to have such a strong desire to do something of value to society for so little freaking money.
Private school teacher; yes.
Public school teacher; HELL no.
What public school teachers "lack" in salary they make up in benefits.
1. Full pension: I'd be a lot richer if I didn't need to contribute to my 401k and roth IRA that they don't have to do thanks to the tax payers.
2. Retire by 55: It'd be nice to know that I could retire by 55 with their benefits in tack.
3. Medical: My company's plan is great (and I love it) but it doesn't hold a candle to what teachers get.
4. 3 months vacation: I'd love to be able to get 3 months of extra employment on top of my salary. Christmas break, spring break, and all the extra "holidays" (that no private businesses acknowledge).
5. Make one lesson plan and set for life: Yes some things change but as I recall German lost both WW1 and WW2, 2+2 still equals 4, etc.
6. Job security: Part of the reason our schools keep falling behind is that we can't fire the worthless teachers.
7. Extremely low stress job: Who here doesn't have stress at work? Then think how unstressful it would be to be a teacher. See 8 for low stress too.
8. 5-10 minute breaks between classes, plus lunch break, and 1 free class period Remember high school? Teachers didn't come to you, you wen to their class room. So between classes they get breaks. Teach 8 classes and get 5 minutes for students to get to class is 35 extra minutes plus a free class and you get 80 break minutes a day (not even including lunch break). How many people get 80 minutes of paid, non-lunch break time a day?
So given all that, tack this on their salary: at least 6k for medical, 8-10k for pension (do the math for being able to retire by 55 and never have to worry about running out). Then multiply by 4/3 because of their summer off. And then you realize "underpaid" teachers are really bringing in the money. Then factor in job security and low stress of their job and then try to give me this crap that they are underpaid.
Once again: private school teachers I agree with you 100%, but completely disagree with you when it comes to public school.
FYI I went to public school and had great teachers; not a rip on them just the bullsh!t argument that public school teachers are underpaid.
Go to a poorer district, then try the same argument.
Originally posted by: everman
No love for lawyers? I'd say it is a well respected profession, just one that some people love to hate until they actually need one.
Judge is also a respected profession.
Originally posted by: FallenHero
I'm a cop, but I voted armed forces. Those people sacrafice much more than any of us to serve our country. That being said, I think its sad that people don't have more respect for law enforcement just because they run into a few bad apples. News flash...most of what you say about paramedics and firefighters carries over to police as well. They have just as many bad apples as the police do, but the media and you doesn't care because they aren't constantly out there doing a job no one wants to do. I think its a sad state of affairs really. You complain about a profession, yet aren't willing to do it yourself nor try to improve the situation.
Originally posted by: Corporate Thug
1. Why isn't Lawyer there?
2. Why isn't mathematician there?
Originally posted by: BigJelly
Originally posted by: everman
No love for lawyers? I'd say it is a well respected profession, just one that some people love to hate until they actually need one.
Judge is also a respected profession.
Why not used car salesman?
Originally posted by: BigJelly
Originally posted by: FallenHero
Originally posted by: BigJelly
Originally posted by: DainBramaged
I'm voting teachers because no other professions tends to have such a strong desire to do something of value to society for so little freaking money.
Private school teacher; yes.
Public school teacher; HELL no.
What public school teachers "lack" in salary they make up in benefits.
1. Full pension: I'd be a lot richer if I didn't need to contribute to my 401k and roth IRA that they don't have to do thanks to the tax payers.
2. Retire by 55: It'd be nice to know that I could retire by 55 with their benefits in tack.
3. Medical: My company's plan is great (and I love it) but it doesn't hold a candle to what teachers get.
4. 3 months vacation: I'd love to be able to get 3 months of extra employment on top of my salary. Christmas break, spring break, and all the extra "holidays" (that no private businesses acknowledge).
5. Make one lesson plan and set for life: Yes some things change but as I recall German lost both WW1 and WW2, 2+2 still equals 4, etc.
6. Job security: Part of the reason our schools keep falling behind is that we can't fire the worthless teachers.
7. Extremely low stress job: Who here doesn't have stress at work? Then think how unstressful it would be to be a teacher. See 8 for low stress too.
8. 5-10 minute breaks between classes, plus lunch break, and 1 free class period Remember high school? Teachers didn't come to you, you wen to their class room. So between classes they get breaks. Teach 8 classes and get 5 minutes for students to get to class is 35 extra minutes plus a free class and you get 80 break minutes a day (not even including lunch break). How many people get 80 minutes of paid, non-lunch break time a day?
So given all that, tack this on their salary: at least 6k for medical, 8-10k for pension (do the math for being able to retire by 55 and never have to worry about running out). Then multiply by 4/3 because of their summer off. And then you realize "underpaid" teachers are really bringing in the money. Then factor in job security and low stress of their job and then try to give me this crap that they are underpaid.
Once again: private school teachers I agree with you 100%, but completely disagree with you when it comes to public school.
FYI I went to public school and had great teachers; not a rip on them just the bullsh!t argument that public school teachers are underpaid.
Go to a poorer district, then try the same argument.
Fine maybe poorer districts have it bad, but as I recall 90% of America isn't poor. Hats off to the teachers that go to the poor districts--they are almost at the same level as private school teachers in my books). But for the 95+% of non-poor districts my arguments still hold water.
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: FallenHero
I'm a cop, but I voted armed forces. Those people sacrafice much more than any of us to serve our country. That being said, I think its sad that people don't have more respect for law enforcement just because they run into a few bad apples. News flash...most of what you say about paramedics and firefighters carries over to police as well. They have just as many bad apples as the police do, but the media and you doesn't care because they aren't constantly out there doing a job no one wants to do. I think its a sad state of affairs really. You complain about a profession, yet aren't willing to do it yourself nor try to improve the situation.
I picked fire fighter over armed forces for a few reasons.
1. Enlistment goes down during times of war. This leads me to believe that people are enlisting with the hope that they won't actually have to fight.
2. The military has to force people to stay in the military during times of war with a stop-loss order.
3. Many/most people in the military use it as a stepping stone, they don't make a career of it. It's an alternative to college for people who can't afford college, or a way to have college paid for.
Fire Fighters might not die as often as soldiers, but they don't sign up hoping there won't be any fires. There are always fires.
In the end it was a toss-up. Law enforcement officer is up there too. I have no respect for people who call cops pigs. I think that most cops are good and want to help people.
Originally posted by: BigJelly
Private school teacher; yes.
Public school teacher; HELL no.
What public school teachers "lack" in salary they make up in benefits.
1. Full pension: I'd be a lot richer if I didn't need to contribute to my 401k and roth IRA that they don't have to do thanks to the tax payers.
2. Retire by 55: It'd be nice to know that I could retire by 55 with their benefits in tack.
3. Medical: My company's plan is great (and I love it) but it doesn't hold a candle to what teachers get.
4. 3 months vacation: I'd love to be able to get 3 months of extra employment on top of my salary. Christmas break, spring break, and all the extra "holidays" (that no private businesses acknowledge).
5. Make one lesson plan and set for life: Yes some things change but as I recall German lost both WW1 and WW2, 2+2 still equals 4, etc.
6. Job security: Part of the reason our schools keep falling behind is that we can't fire the worthless teachers.
7. Extremely low stress job: Who here doesn't have stress at work? Then think how unstressful it would be to be a teacher. See 8 for low stress too.
8. 5-10 minute breaks between classes, plus lunch break, and 1 free class period Remember high school? Teachers didn't come to you, you wen to their class room. So between classes they get breaks. Teach 8 classes and get 5 minutes for students to get to class is 35 extra minutes plus a free class and you get 80 break minutes a day (not even including lunch break). How many people get 80 minutes of paid, non-lunch break time a day?
So given all that, tack this on their salary: at least 6k for medical, 8-10k for pension (do the math for being able to retire by 55 and never have to worry about running out). Then multiply by 4/3 because of their summer off. And then you realize "underpaid" teachers are really bringing in the money. Then factor in job security and low stress of their job and then try to give me this crap that they are underpaid.
Once again: private school teachers I agree with you 100%, but completely disagree with you when it comes to public school.
FYI I went to public school and had great teachers; not a rip on them just the bullsh!t argument that public school teachers are underpaid.