I believe any one of those coolers will do. The whole thing about different coolers performing better than others, I think, really depends on the system.
What I mean by this is of course how well you install the heatsink, airflow is different per case, and of course ambient temperature.
Those coolers should cool equally well if installed correctly.
I'm using a Thermalright XP-90C and it seems to be cooling pretty well. I just have to wait a week and see if my temps drop after the AS5 has settled in. After that I will try again after lapping my heatsink when I have the time. That should drop my temperatures by 5 degrees or so, if I seat the heatsink properly.
How are you guys speading the thermal interface material for these core2duo cpus?
Normally for my Opteron CPU I would either spread a think layer on then leave a little dot in the middle just incase and that seemed to work extremely well for me. This time around all I did for the C2D was spread a good layer over the core and then I plopped the heatsink down. I'm going to try my Opteron method next week and reseat the heatsink.
Oh, and I guess I jumped the gun when I said I was stable. After close to 8hours core#1 failed and core#0 kept going. I bumped up the voltage one more notch and am priming now.
Both cores are toasting at 64C right now, which will of course keep rising a bit after the case temperature goes up.
Oh and for those having troubles setting a 1T cmd rate, I am running my OCZ Titanium PC6400 @ 4-4-4-15 1T in the BLACK slots with BIOS 0401 with 2.1xxvolts in the bios. That is exactly what my ram is rated for, but my ram is EPP ready ram and I am running EPP Expert mode in the bios.
I'm surprised the yellow slots have been working better for you John, since you've started using the 401 BIOS. I have read a few others with success using the yellow slots, I guess it just really depends on the system.
Other than that little gripe, this board is one friendly overclocker. Reminds me of my old 939 ASRock Dual SATA2 board. That was also very easy to overclock and also had massive vdroop.
Cheers,
Mike
EDIT:: John you've got quite the processor there. Running 1.325v on the core!?!?!? Wow. I have to pump about 1.46ish to keep 3.4GHz somewhat stable.
We'll see if I'm fully stable in about 12 hours.