I'm currently playing The Wicther 2 for the first time right now and not enjoying the combat at all.
I'm sorry but its utter trash, I would rather have the first games combat system then some pseudo Arkham style which isn't nearly as good.
Geralt cant take a few hits, you need to constantly roll and run away only hitting when you have a chance, combat ends up like this,
1. Make hit
2. Roll away
4. Use shield
5. Make another hit(Shield buff gone), roll away
6. Run around in a few circles waiting for Mana(endurance) to regenerate and cast shield buff again.
7. Repeat steps 1-6
Maybe its early in the game(only halfway through chapter 1) but I'm used to quality combat that is Dark Souls combat or the Arkham free flowing style. I should note that most of these issue come into play when your fight more than 3 enemies at once(which is quite often so far), or stun lock issue where you cant escape after getting hit, or hitting a shield. Fighting creatures is so far much more enjoyable, until they start putting human features into them like the Nekkers, Drowners etc.
I hope the entire combat system gets a revamp for #3.