After seeing another episode of this, I've decided what I like so much about it.
It borrows much, much, MUCH more from "The West Wing" than it does the original BSG series. Each crisis that comes up feels believable - none of the manufactured panics that plagued the original series, or the frequent wondering "Well, if they'd just stop and THINK for a moment, this would never have happened!" You don't have to suspend disbelief over and over to accept that humans could act in a certain way (especially the original Baltar - what WAS that guy's problem!?)
The new series takes a lot from "West Wing". Indeed, as off episode 11, there has been...what...2 major 'military/battle' episodes? And that's counting the first episode of the series?
The old BSG was cheesy popcorn-SciFi. The new BSG is Drama - capital 'D' and all. That it happens to be set in a SciFi universe that is really interesting is completely incidental, it's all about the characters and the people that make up this world.
There is no "alien of the week", there are no constant battles, no plot-oriented plagues or diseases that spring up horribly in one episode only to never been seen from again, no technobabble of any kind (indeed, they use modern military terminology for everything), no fancy gadgets or tech tricks to 'save the day' in one episode only to be forgotten later, etc.
Like "West Wing" - this show is about people in stressful situations and how they deal with it. And the writers....really, really know what they are doing.