I greatly appreciate the abundant replies.
I think there seems to be some confusion as to WHY I want(ed) a Camaro. It was not for speed, it was for having a sweet looking car with some decent creature comforts for front seat passengers (2LT). When staring at tail lights during rush hour for most of my driving life, a 4 cylinder would have been fine most of the time.
Since forum members, my wife, and my parents have almost talked me out of a Camaro I have broadened my horizons.
First, I want a late model (2009+) with low mileage (under 20k) or preferably a new car. This really limits the availability of cars I like a lot (I want to drive off the lot sub-30k).
These are the cars I *LOVE* how they look:
-Camaro
-128i
-328i
-Audi A4 (some A4s look boring, but the 35k+ ones look like they have an upgraded curved bumper that really makes it sporty and not "plain"...just too expensive)
-Might as well throw the Volkswagen CC in here (people have made me nervous about VW though...)
-CTS (LATE models with low mileage are hard to find and still expensive)
Kinda like how they look:
-Acura TSX (affordable, but not sure how I like the looks)
-Infiniti G37 (really don't like the sedan, love the coupe just too expensive)
Based on these, any other suggestions? I am taking my wife to drive the CC tomorrow. I am really liking these, just think as a 24 year old I may look funny in this (same with CTS...something just screams 40+ about these cars design).
The BMW dealer wanted to "work the numbers" to get my payment below a certain amount. He didn't understand the monthly payment is irrelevant, I have a couple thousand in disposable income each month (we are both working with no kids...would be more, but we just bought a house)...I just am trying to set myself up now for future success by being conservative and save as much money as I can in liquid assets.