I do have to say, regardless of what happens this is the most interesting and participative game so far.
Oh, and Alive is the Fool.
You mean 4 not 5 for LUCYM0N0. There were five votes prior to Chiro's list, one of which was T_Yamamoto's. Krazy placed the 6th vote after Chiro's tally. As a result, 3 not 2 for Krazy could have been a miscount for all we know.
Chiro stated officially that he only included the top 3 lynching candidates, explaining why Dixycrat's vote for PP and PP's vote for T_Y were not included.
so in this scenario why the witch or the herbalist the true ones come out?!!?!? to draw attention to them?!?!? after all if you are true something you do not know who is claiming your role a good or bad so you stay hiden
as long you do not face lynch you stay hiden.
that is still 2 mistakes not one
thus the savant vote was not counted
and i talked for the top 3 voted people
thus the savant in not penguinpower
I lost my powers. I can't revive anyone at night. and my vote doesn't count anymore
Clarify please.
Wait, why? A penalty because you voted for the bad witch?
Why wouldn't they come out? Those are the exact two classes that COULD come out and make a counter-claim without fear of being eaten. They could be lynched, of course, but in such a case I think people would err on the side of lynching PP rather than 50/50 between herbalists and good witches.
I agree with a couple of points in the rest of your post, but overall it's just not convincing. If we're going to throw out wild theories, it's probably just as likely that PP is a werewolf and claims you (a fool) as an innocent as well as one other person. Not that I believe that, but the amount of chance isn't much different vs PP being a fool and all these other members playing along.
4 instead of 5
and 2 instead of 3
I lost my powers. I can't revive anyone at night. and my vote doesn't count anymore
Either one of those could be explained by someone lying about their roles. See my pre-night action theory in #218, which would in fact account for both discrepancies. My point is that until we know for certain that there are no errors in the tally (or what the error is), we cannot be certain of anything based on voting records.
so if the trough herbalist come out
then what??? it is he said i said
people have so much faith people will come and say i am a liar
they wont come out cause if yamamoto and dixy are both bad
and only the good with comes out it will be 1 vs 2??
or even there will be 2 vs 2 what then???
lynch random?!?!? or leave them for the time being?!?!?!
and dixy always say he lies he lies he lies
all people assume that he is what penguin says
Yes, it would be he said she said. That's my point. As a result of that, PP is the only person that team good KNOWS is evil, and it would be a relatively safe lynch vote (unless he was the fool). Additionally, it screws with the werewolf: he isn't going to try to eat either the real herbalist (because he can't) nor the fake herbalist (because it might be another werewolf). Same applies to the good witch.
anyway the yamamoto i can not vote suddenly is suspicious
is he is the savant of a woolf and thus he can not vote for krazy?!!??!
and thus ohhhhhhhh i can not vote
skin the evil yamamoto out of existance
If T_Y is the savant, how come his vote counted against LUCYM0N0? As we've established, Chiro may have missed a vote, but he didn't say that he could have accidentally added an extra one.
you already said yamamoto vote was after chiro post the lynch votes
so the mistake is the 3 votes for krazy when he shows 2
one mistake as chiro says
all add up know
No, I said Krazy's vote against LUCYM0N0 was after. T_Yamamoto was the fourth person to vote for LUCYM0N0 (which you can see for yourself), and therefore should have been a null vote if he was the savant.
Only the apparent vote tally. You won't be directly told if some of the votes don't count, unless it is enough that an alternate player is killed instead of the apparent lynch "winner."
That being said, T_Yamamoto's most recent post reeks of bullshit, especially since he hasn't tried to explain it at all. If he is a baddie, I'm surprised he'd make up something like that, especially so early on.
I do agree that he wielded incredible power when he made his accusation of the bad witch, and now I am fairly suspicious that he is in fact a werewolf working with PowerPenguin. Not sure if that explains the role of you or DixyCrat in the conspiracy, however.
Of course, that almost seems too easy, so I'm very open to anything to disprove such a possibility.
If he is the savant, why would he bother stating that he's sorry that his vote does not count? If I was in his shoes, I'd stay quiet and wait for the next round of voting, so that someone else could possibly be accused of being a savant. I'm leaning towards daddy wolf at this point. Of course, that also means that PP was complicit in this to some extent, which implies that he too is a wolf, being that the savant does not know the wolves and vice versa, so maybe he's a good guy trying to throw others off of him. All I know right now is that I want an explanation from him.