Woosta
Platinum Member
- Mar 23, 2008
- 2,978
- 0
- 71
Btw why the f@ck are we discussing Overeem? If you don't want to compete against the best fighters in the world (ufc) then you don't count IMO. Let him and Fedor pad their records against all the ufc rejects. I'll be watching the fight for the best HW in the world tonight.
Ok sir. You have been successfully brainwashed by:
Ok. Let's take a deep thorough look at the BEST HW division and see how many top fighters they have faced.
BROCK:
Carwin TOP 10
Frank Mir TOP 10
Couture TOP 10
Herring
Min Soo Kim
CARWIN
Brock Lesnar TOP 10
Frank Mir TOP 10
Gabriel Gonzaga
Neil Wain
Christian Wellisch
Sherman Pendergarst
Rex Richards
Rick Slaton
Chris Guillen
Justice Smith
Jay McCown
Casey Jackson
Carlton Jones
CAIN VELASQUEZ
Big Nog TOP 10
Rothwell
Kongo
Denis Stojic
Jake O'Brien
Brad Morris
Jeremiah Constant
Jesse Fujarcyzk
FRANK MIR
Cro Cop
Shane Carwin
Cheick Kongo
Brock Lesnar
Big Nog
Brock Lesnar
Antonio Hardonk
Brandon Vera
Dan Christion
Marcio Cruz
Tim Sylvia
Wes Sims
Wes Sims
Tank Abbott
Ian Freeman
Pete Williams
Roberto Traven
Dan Quinn
Jerome Smith
Junior Dos Santos
Roy Nelson
Gonzaga
Yvel
Cro Cop
Struve
Werdum TOP 10
Geronimo
Joaquim
Jair Goncalves
Joaquim
Edson
Eduardo
Jailson
That's 10 so far. Let me just use 1 fighter from SF.
Fedor - Rogers, Arlovski, Sylvia, Mark Hunt, Coleman, Cro Cop, Big Nog, Heath Herring
That's 8. So, 5 of the most elite HW fighters combined from the UFC have fought 10 top 10 competitors, while Fedor himself has fought 8.
I wonder who has fought the most competition...
Now, stat-wise let's compare win/loss records:
Fedor: 32-2
Barnett: 26-5
Overeem: 33-11
Bigfoot: 14-2
Rogers: 10-2
Kharitonov: 16-4
Werdum: 14-4
COMBINED: 145-30
UFC ( new guard ):
Lesnar: 5-1
Cain: 8-0
JDS: 12-1
Carwin: 12-1
Frank Mir: 14-5
Gabriel Gonzaga: 11-5
Roy Nelson: 15-5
COMBINED: 77-18
If we compared the top 4 vs the top 2
Lesnar, Cain, JDS, Carwin are 37-3
Fedor and Josh Barnett have more wins than Lesnar/Cain/JDS/Carwin have fights. Fedor and Barnett are 58-7 alone.
If we had matchups:
Overeem vs Lesnar
Fedor vs Cain
JDS vs Kharitonov
Carwin vs Bigfoot
Werdum vs Gonzaga
Frank Mir vs Brett Rogers
Arlovski vs Roy Nelson
Overeem has better striking and submissions than Lesnar. Overeem is strong enough to hold his own against Lesnar's wrestling. Lesnar's takedowns have been stopped by Herring ( smaller by 40 lbs diff ) and Couture ( 40 lbs size diff ). Overeem is not some 220 lb scrawny HW like Herring or Couture. I say the odds are heavily on Overeem.
Fedor and Cain have arguably the best cardio at HW. Both are very good strikers. Fedor has the experience against top competition, Cain doesn't. I say Fedor takes this.
Junior Dos Santos vs Kharitonov is a very very good matchup. Both are very good boxers. Kharitonov is testing his striking skills in K-1 now. I'd say they are equal striking-wise. I think it's 50/50.
Carwin vs Bigfoot is a good matchup. Carwin has devastating striking but he gasses after 1 round. Bigfoot is no joke, only 2 losses out of 16 fights. Carwin has the power advantage but Bigfoot outstruck the boxer in Arlovski. Bigfoot has the cardio advantage and the submission/grappling advantage.
Werdum vs Gonzaga happened twice already, Werdum won both fights. Werdum has the better jiu jitsu.
Frank Mir vs Brett Rogers... Frank Mir definitely has the advantage in experience and submission grappling. Mir probably takes this, but never count a guy with Rogers power out. Frank Mir has lost to a light heavyweight in Brendan Vera before.
Arlovski vs Roy nelson has happened before and Arlovski did win, but they are both at very different stages of their careers. Roy Nelson is arguably higher ranked and would probably be the favorite. I think he did damn good against JDS. If Arlovski is really, really motivated and mentally there he takes this though.
Bottom line: The strikeforce HW division is no joke. They have the better experience and records. The UFC HW division top ranked are still green, and we won't really see how good they are until they fight each other a couple of times. Guys like Brock are 1 dimensional in wrestling, Carwin is 1 dimensional as a 1st round striker. If they really are the top 5 elite, they need to be well rounded in all areas.
Fedor is arguably the most well rounded HW ever. Alistair does have better striking than Fedor because of his newly gained K-1 experience and Alistair has ALSO won the ADCC grappling championships. We all know Alistair has had several losses before but that was as a LHW when he was cutting weight and not doing any strength training. He was also very, very young ( early 20s ).
For kicks, let's compare ages:
Brock - 33 ( lots of wear and tear from WWE stint )
Carwin - 35 ( i dont see him fighting for more than another 2-3 years )
JDS - 26
Cain - 28
Mir - 31 ( lots of wear and tear; motorcycle accident )
JDS and Cain are young. They'll be around for 4-5 years. Alistair Overeem is only 30 though, and is more well rounded than both, more experience.
Alistair I think defines the new breed because of his well rounded-ness, strength, speed. Experience helps.
Last edited: